I have used the sealer and clearcoat from Joe at CC for a couple of years now and it has worked out very well for ME...It's very simple to do, won't run the wife out of the house, buffs out like a chrome bumber - super shinney, comes with all the info needed to use....It is not as hard as CA or epoxy, but I would rather have a dent in a cue than a piece of finish that chipped out because of the hardness, it's easier to me to fix at a later date...Just my 2 cents....
And after they set a day or so I buff on an 18" low speed buffer, then wax with Carnuba, works wonders ...
Everyone has their own preferences, and depending on what one uses or how they go about things results can vary. I think the main thing is that the finish protects the cue regardless of what type someone prefers. It's nice for looks too of coarse. there are several finishes out there that work well enough.
I do a lot of repair work, and have touched up all sorts of finishes. For me I'm just the opposite, and I prefer a hard finish, because It seems to be much easier to fix a chip out then a dent in a cue to me. Not to repair physically per say, but rather to get a decent blend. A dent in wood tends to show through the clear cote if I simply try to fill them, and sometimes if I try to feather the wood in to blend the edges of the dent then that can discolor that spot and make It stand out. Ca is hard enough to chip out, but I have seen other softer finishes do the same thing, probably more due to issues during prep then anything, but I have seen many different finishes chip out. I have seen epoxy cues, as well as a whole spectrum of finishes that were so bad, it was like pulling a string on a cloth when you try to prep the spot to touch it up, It just kept getting larger and larger, In some cases it was busting loose all over the cue to the point that the entire cue needed refinished. again I believe to be the result of a bad prep job, something can could happen with almost any finish given the same circumstances. I also like a hard finish specifically because It does protect the cue from denting. I can always refinish a cue, but can't put more wood back unless I steam It or fill It.For this reason I will be using auto clear in the future. The Ca has just been something that I could apply By hand for the time being.
I'm not an advocate for Ca, I feel there are better finishes out there, but there are much worse as well IMO, and It does actually protect the cue that's underneath pretty well. I have 2 cues in My personal case with CA finishes that are over 6 years old, and have been used every week since they were built. One of them has a small chip at the edge of the shaft face but that was My own fault, and is an easy fix. I have beat them off of metal chairs, probably whatever else You can imagine, and It did not chip the butt caps or sleeves Like Ca has a bad rep for, a deserving one though, because It is something that can and does happen, but that varies between products and the methods that are used.. If the cue is not overly abused the finish holds up fairly well enough for me. With that said I didn't get to this point without a few hiccups. I had some chip outs on a earlier cue that I built for a friend when I was learning to use the stuff, although he was extremely hard on the cue. Still yet the finish protected the cue underneath, and I was able to repair the spots without a total refinish. I had another shaft, actually the only one that ever spider-ed on Me, but I think I got the finish a little too thick on that one, and It was dropped on a hard tile floor. I have several cues out there with ca on them though that are holding up as well as most other finishes I see do. There are a lot of different brand and type Ca's out there though, and as I said before they don't all have the same characteristics. Some are more brittle then others, and don't stick as well. There's also a fine line on how thick to go with it. Some are harder to apply too because of their tendency to whiten, as where others are a little more forgiving in that area.
Anyhow I understand the reasoning. I use to feel the same way, and preferred a dent over a chip out, but now My prep skills have changed when repairing them, so I have better luck blending them, and I'll take the chip out over the dent if I'm the one doing the repair, that is as long as It's not a major error in the original prep that is causing It, and a can of worms is not waiting to open up on me.