---
I have tried them all... cte - toi --- pro one-- 4 strokes of the monk- center ball, only outside...
i just cant find the one that is for me... the decisions are impossible.. and that is why i have struggled for over 20yrs as a b player.. crazy....
Well, all techniques are only as good as your mastery of them. I can hand you the best hammer in the world but if you don't practice your technique you will hammer your thumb quite a bit and the master carpenter next to you will drive more nails and drive them home neater and faster than you with a lesser hammer.
I can only really relate this to jump cues. I sold thousands of them over the years and demonstrated them at shows and taught people to jump. I can tell you that without a doubt a LOT of those people were buying it as a crutch thinking that it worked by itself. They thought no problem I will just use the magic cue and jump out of safeties. Didn't bother to practice or really learn to control it.
The result was that a lot of those players, some whom I knew personally, would sell out a lot even if they managed to make the jump and a good hit. They were flailing with a precision tool.
The people who really practiced learned to make controlled jump shots and ended up winning matches for themselves and their team. I can't tell you the amount of people who came to me at the big tournaments who thanked me for teaching them HOW to use it and MAKING them practice until I was sure they had it down.
After reading your thread I went to the table and decided to do a little experiment on position play with TOI. Using a relatively shallow cut I wanted to see if I could put the cue ball in all the same places with TOI as I could using spin. Not only could I but I could do it more reliably. It's funny but just a little to much spin makes the cueball over run the position by a couple balls in some situations even if your speed was dead on.
I shot center ball to see what happens and was surprised to find out that on some shots I hit dead center and got one reaction which was expected but on others where I was SURE that I had hit center I actually got a little outside spin and that totally blew the position.
But with TOI I was able to use speed and just high/low/center to get where I wanted to go. I personally believe that CJ's advice on favoring one side of center, inside just a hair is the nuts because of the fact that being off towards the outside just brings you back to center and being off a little to the inside doesn't seem to hurt as much. That's with just a little messing with it on one shot. I have a long way to go if I want to say I really know how to do it though.
Anyway that's my book report.