Growing up on old nap cloths that were slower than molasses we played all games such as, 14.1, 3 ball, 6 ball, 9 ball, 1 pocket, pill pool, cribbage, Chicago, 3 cushion and any other game you can think of, never for funsies, always for cash. Everybody had a big stroke, you had to be able to move the cue ball, power draw was power draw, today you can bunt the ball and draw full table.
I had my first 100 ball run at 16 yrs old on my birthday, a 131, using a house cue and a hard as rock champion tip, the table had holes in the cloth and cigarette burns. Looking back I realize I knew nothing of what I was doing.
As the game progressed and table conditions changed so did I. For the most part faster cloth and rails.
I am O.C.D. to a fault. I have studied every player; every style, books, systems until my brain explodes, and then I study it again. I will study after I write this, it might be about fishing but I will study and learn.
From playing many different games I learned to use the entire cue ball. I learned to apply it as needed, a flat hit, use of spin, speed, and stroke required when called upon.
It is not one style or another, as far as I am concerned it's the only style and the best way to play with the cue ball. Anything else and you are cheating yourself. To each their own I guess.
The days of punch players are gone. For every punch player there are 100 flow players. Don't mistake a short backstroke as a punch stroke as many do. Players today worldwide are moving the cue ball around beautifully, using all the strokes.
If a player wants to play a one dimensional game that is all well and good. If teachers want to teach that style that is fine also. I personally think its old news, ancient. Many things I read should be put in the archives in the yesterday's news section.
It's like having a box of tools and using 1 tool, which may not be the right tool for the job; it may get the job done, with a lot of extra and unnecessary work, or could cause more harm than good. Golfers have a variety of clubs, you don't putt with a driver and you don't drive with a putter.
Knowledge and applying that knowledge is power.
I have established players who take lessons on a regular basis; most are B+ and better players, some are beginners
Some are spin players some are punchy players, some are both, and some have no clue yet. I teach them to play inside the cue ball and around the world. They learn to play a complete cue ball.
This is training, we hit hundreds of balls, not a 3 hour session on how to stand, bridge, aim,9 hours of filming the elbow, never to see the student again. We do cover everything from stance, bridges, head, eyes, in out aiming, kicking, banks, safety, 3 cushion etc.etc.etc.
We keep it simple, nothing that is going to fry their brain, pool 101. Not even near the complicated mumbo jumbo I read that's out there. Most of all we have fun, and they love it.
There is more than one way to skin a cat, this is my way, it's very effective and rewarding.
I don't really care what anyone else does or how they do it. This is mine and would not trade this style for anything.