Total Offense. A game without safeties.

Total offense is total bs, and that's the end of THAT.
Golf says you're wrong. In so far as it doesn't allow any shots that make your opponent's shots more difficult.

I take the term total offense to mean non-defensive. It needn't infer taking on any shot regardless of percentage.

Colin
 
Last edited:
I've actually played a version of nineball where it's the exact opposite. Safety's are the key to winning. The 9 doesn't matter, its whoever scratches 5 times first loses.

Ring games are great as well, but I feel that solely offensive games will remain action games only. Safeties are a great part about pool. That's why this game is harder than bowling, darts, or golf. There's no strategy in those games, just pure offense.
 
I LOVE This Idea.....Is this something you just made up or is it a actual game...?
I want to Play some 9-Ball with these Rules...ASAP and I'm Betting I will Really
Enjoy it...

I Will Let You Know How I Make Out....

Thanks.....Paul

No, it's something I overheard some pros talking about at a tournament in Reno many years ago.
 
The out of snooker kicks are probably the best highlight shots in rotation pool, because the players shoot at 20% options. In potting play, they'll only play sub 50% difficulty shots when the shot offers a reasonable shot-to-nothing type safety backup.

So yes, these are often the best shots we get to see in rotation events and I'm sure game formats that contain them will survive. But I'd rather see exceptional offensive potting shots than miraculous, with a handfull of luck, escapes. Such offensive shots have been almost entirely removed from consideration in current game formats.


btw: Is payball like Shell Out, a snooker game where you get money per point scored with multiple players?

Colin
Payball is usually played on a 5x10 snooker table with tight pockets (3 in often)...
...you rack up the colours in a triangle, and shoot them in order...money on every ball..
..double on the black ball....if you make a ball, everybody in the games pays you...
....most games are double for a run-out.
The old rules of nine ball apply...and there is no sense in playing safe.

Your game Shell Out, I suspect, is what Canucks call Follow and USA calls Points.
...pay by the point, you pay for what you leave...only the player following you collects.
.....once again, safeties are useless, 'cause if you make a man sell out, it is someone
else who gets paid.

When I was a kid, I was a bit too aggressive as a snooker player.....
...four of us decided to play follow one day....we put the 3 'D' colours and the cue ball in
a pocket and draw for order.....I picked the cue ball, so I break...the guy who drew the
brown ball will be paying me....
....so I smacked 'em wide open and fluked a red ball.....I'm in the mid 70s and it looks like
a table clearance coming up.....the guy who drew the brown ball taps me on the shoulder...
...he says " Excuse me , who are you FOLLOWING?
I thought about it, started laughing and racked 'em up and broke safe....
....what the hell, we WERE playing 'follow'.
 
Payball is usually played on a 5x10 snooker table with tight pockets (3 in often)...
...you rack up the colours in a triangle, and shoot them in order...money on every ball..
..double on the black ball....if you make a ball, everybody in the games pays you...
....most games are double for a run-out.
The old rules of nine ball apply...and there is no sense in playing safe.

Your game Shell Out, I suspect, is what Canucks call Follow and USA calls Points.
...pay by the point, you pay for what you leave...only the player following you collects.
.....once again, safeties are useless, 'cause if you make a man sell out, it is someone
else who gets paid.

When I was a kid, I was a bit too aggressive as a snooker player.....
...four of us decided to play follow one day....we put the 3 'D' colours and the cue ball in
a pocket and draw for order.....I picked the cue ball, so I break...the guy who drew the
brown ball will be paying me....
....so I smacked 'em wide open and fluked a red ball.....I'm in the mid 70s and it looks like
a table clearance coming up.....the guy who drew the brown ball taps me on the shoulder...
...he says " Excuse me , who are you FOLLOWING?
I thought about it, started laughing and racked 'em up and broke safe....
....what the hell, we WERE playing 'follow'.
Nice story :-)

Yeah, that's Shell Out as I remember it.

It was a bit open to wroughting if you went halves with the guy preceeding you, such that he set you up.
 
If the game was total offense, the lay person, would enjoy it much more. Non pool people do not want to watch a safety battle.:thumbup:
 
If the game was total offense, the lay person, would enjoy it much more. Non pool people do not want to watch a safety battle.:thumbup:
I agree on the safety / strategical aspect being uninteresting to the majority of potential viewers.

In terms of offense, it requires more than just say pocketing 9 easy shots in a row. Imagine how many outs off the break there would be with 8 inch pockets, but the viewers would hardly be impressed.

What we need is WOW shots and we see way too few of them in the game formats popular today. A few good WOW shots per match would make vision suitable for news and/or sports stations / websites to give some coverage of events.
 
Back
Top