The Hustler book - quite different from the movie

What I remember the character was very much like Gleason played it.


Sent from my iPhone using AzBilliards Forums

So, nothing at all like Wanderone, and thus, as Trevis has always said, didn't copy anything from Fats except they were both,,,well hefty ;)

I mean, there is no reason to use a character and then change all of his characteristics.
 
So, nothing at all like Wanderone, and thus, as Trevis has always said, didn't copy anything from Fats except they were both,,,well hefty ;)

I mean, there is no reason to use a character and then change all of his characteristics.
Also, in the book Fats barely talks at all other than to say "Let's play pool, Fast Eddie."

The idea that Tevis would model the character after a notorious ham and shit-talker is pretty silly.
 
Last edited:
I recently read the original book by Walter Tevis and highly recommend it. It's a quick and vibrant read.

Some of the major differences:

- A lot more psychological insight into what Eddie is thinking and how he grows/learns over the course of the story.
- Buildup to the initial matchup with Fats.
- Includes a full accounting of the games against the Kentucky billiard player. In the movie they cut directly from Bert agreeing to keep staking him to Findlay having lost.
- Much less melodramatic relationship between Eddie and Sarah. No rape by Bert and no suicide. (Big improvement IMO)
- It's left open to interpretation about how Eddie will respond to Bert's ultimatum that he is now his manager.

Others?

The Color of Money book is barely the same story as the movie, with no Tom Cruise character at all.
I'm sure I read The Color of Money, and it didn't resemble in any way, shape or form the movie of the same name.

Freddie
 
I'm sure I read The Color of Money, and it didn't resemble in any way, shape or form the movie of the same name.

Freddie
I wouldn't go that far, as the book follows Fast Eddie as he gets back into pool shape and slays some old demons by entering the tournament world.

Apart from a pointless and boring dead-end storyline near the end of the book (if you read it, you'll know what I'm talking about) it's almost as good as the Hustler.
 
The book the Hustler came out in 1959. However, in a 1957 Playboy magazine, Walter Tevis's story the Hustler first appeared. I have a copy of the magazine with the story.

Doesn't the short story start out with Eddie getting out of prison? Don't know why I remember it that way, but I thought I remember reading a story like that....?
 
I tracked down a PDF of the January 1957 issue, feel free to PM me for a link.

Features "Louisville Fats" and "Big Sam Willis" rather than the usual Minnesota Fats and Fast Eddie, and does indeed start out with Sam being escorted out of prison.
 
Thanks to you, I had the opportunity to read Tevis short story in Playboy. Except for the physical weight, I don't see any resemblance in the Fats character.


Also, in the book Fats barely talks at all other than to say "Let's play pool, Fast Eddie."

The idea that Tevis would model the character after a notorious ham and shit-talker is pretty silly.
 
That's Hollywood for you. After Raging Bull, the two films Martin Scorsese directed prior to The Color of Money either tanked at the box office or just meh. Tom Cruise was a big box office draw (Top Gun). So, having him in a film was protect the studio's investment. I wouldn't be surprised if the screenplay and story was re-written many times to accommodate the actor.

I'm sure I read The Color of Money, and it didn't resemble in any way, shape or form the movie of the same name.

Freddie
 
The original "The Hustler" short story from Playboy is included in the excellent Byrne's Book of Great Pool Stories, although sans any vintage smut.

I read the novel version of "The Hustler" when it was reprinted in paperback a few years ago.I always wondered if the "property" they allude to at the end as an investment opportunity is Fast Eddie himself.

I like the book of TCOM too, but I can see why Scorsese didn't want to make it into a movie.
 
I'm sure I read The Color of Money, and it didn't resemble in any way, shape or form the movie of the same name.

Freddie

There was a scene in The Color of Money that I wish they had put into the movie...
...Fast Eddie shows up at a nine ball tournament...an older guy that nobody knows...
...as he's warming up, they can see that he knows what he's doing.....
...so they're curious about him.

Then he wins the lag for first break....and pops them about 15 mph...nothing falls.
Somebody in the audience says "Straight pool player." :rolleyes:

And that's why I like reading Walter Tevis....he's one of us.
 
I wouldn't go that far, as the book follows Fast Eddie as he gets back into pool shape and slays some old demons by entering the tournament world.

Apart from a pointless and boring dead-end storyline near the end of the book (if you read it, you'll know what I'm talking about) it's almost as good as the Hustler.

From what I remember The Color of Money movie was nothing like the book. Completely different story. Eddie hooks up with Fats (who's retired) to do some televised exhibition matches for money. Eddie has to talk Fats into it. They become pretty good friends. There is no upcoming young and cocky character like Vince in the book. It's been a while since I had it though, maybe I should read it again. All Wslter Tevis books are worth reading multiple times!
 
From what I remember The Color of Money movie was nothing like the book. Completely different story. Eddie hooks up with Fats (who's retired) to do some televised exhibition matches for money. Eddie has to talk Fats into it. They become pretty good friends. There is no upcoming young and cocky character like Vince in the book. It's been a while since I had it though, maybe I should read it again. All Wslter Tevis books are worth reading multiple times!

If I remember right, Fats steers Eddie somewhere down South to play 8 ball.
 
This thread prompted me to read the Hustler book. Got the e book on Amazon Kindle for $1.99.
Great read.
 
Because of the book, I've always viewed the movie as set in Chicago. Many who have not read the book and even those who have, view the movie as being set in New York. Other than "Ames", I'm not sure if there any NY references. Not that it matters where you view it's setting, it is a great movie and a great book.


Sent from my iPhone using AzBilliards Forums

We had our own Ames here in Milwaukee back in the day only it was called Mike's Just pool period. Couldn't even get a glass of water. Had to go next door to the bar to get a soda but you couldn't drink it in Mike's. You could smoke but otherwise just pool. Table one was covered. Had to earn your way up the ladder to play on it and Mike watched you like a Hauk. I think my high run was 64 when I was 16 with mike watching.
 
From what I remember The Color of Money movie was nothing like the book. Completely different story. Eddie hooks up with Fats (who's retired) to do some televised exhibition matches for money. Eddie has to talk Fats into it. They become pretty good friends. There is no upcoming young and cocky character like Vince in the book. It's been a while since I had it though, maybe I should read it again. All Walter Tevis books are worth reading multiple times!
In my opinion, the book Color of Money is light years ahead of that monstrosity of a movie they put together. It would've been much better if the screenwriters stuck to the theme of the book.
Actually, I thought Color of Money book was a better read than the original Hustler. I know that sounds like heresy, but it's just my opinion.
Keep on truckin'
:thumbup:
 
In my opinion, the book Color of Money is light years ahead of that monstrosity of a movie they put together. It would've been much better if the screenwriters stuck to the theme of the book.
Actually, I thought Color of Money book was a better read than the original Hustler. I know that sounds like heresy, but it's just my opinion.
Keep on truckin'
:thumbup:

I agree....it was more positive...made you want to forgive yourself for spending so much
time playing this game.
 
Just to echo Aunty Dan's post,the original The Hustler short story is included in the late Robert Byrne's Book of Great Pool Stories. The short story collection includes other amazing stories.

Get it


Freddie
 
Back
Top