No disrespect to you but, if you think it doesn't "look" legit, then you dont know Tad's work...I'll leave it at that.
If the cue was cheap enough (for me at this point) AND I knew the seller wasnt scamming I would buy it without hesitation.
No disrespect taken, sir... I will say I've owned quite a few Tads.. I'm down to three from
six... I know Tad's work very well. The two different pics of the butt sleeve of the cue look to be the same cue... the inlays and wrap look the same.
Having said that, I've seen a fake Tad Merry Widow that people thought was real, until the guy brought the cue to Tad's to have a shaft made... = fail.
If it's cheap enough, why not?.. it might be a great player! And yeah, it very well could be a scam... got to see it in person, hit some with it.
Over and OUT