Wild Wing posted about what he’s been using for years which happens to be what I have used a long time as well.
Spend the money and get the best, at least it was when WW & myself got ours,…..Peradon. It’s made in England
so the shipping expense is as much as the pouch that excludes tariff. It has the best leather, pouch opening and
lasts. I’ve had mine for well over a decade, maybe 2010? It fits snug, pouch mouth is convenient & chalk stays in it.
Look at the photos illustrating how soft and pliable the Peradon pouch leather is. Admittedly mine is worn in a long time but it was always soft from the day it arrived. I recall ordering it after seeing Allison Fisher use a Peradon chalk pouch in a televised pool tournament. It was barely noticeable and so handy when she wanted to chalk. No walk to the chalk or hand carrying to put down to shoot only to have to pick it up again & again. You simply retrieve your chalk and just return it to the pouch.
Screw those magnet holders or goofy chalk sticks that can be like raccoon tails on a Schwin bike like when I was 11 years old. If you want a chalk pouch, don’t come back and gripe about quality. Just toss it in your drawer and forget about it or else get Peradon and tell others it was worth the extra cost. The TAOM pouch quality in pics sucks.