I played a full league season last summer, probably will again this summer, it's just too far of a drive for me to commit to it in the winter.
I think it's easy to look at one or two rules and think they are silly, but in general I feel the whole package works well together.
In general, I'd say the rule set helps deter a lot of the questionable shots and fouls that we often see asked about here, which is nice when there is no ref available. The only real issue I ever encountered was the guys who didn't bother to read/understand the rules before the league started.
It really is designed to keep the game moving. Even down to how much easier the balls break with the 8 on the spot. It definitely reduced clusters and safety play.