He's certainly in the conversation.Joshua is 29 years old. Here's a look at his performance over the last nine years.
If taking into consideration the amount of great players today and the harder table conditions (pockets size and shot clock) it’s not hard to say he is the best ever.In men's pool, I think we've reached the point where asking who is best is silly.
This year, Josh has won four majors. Let's call a major a field having 96+ players, a deep internationally diverse field, and $25,000+ first prize. In 2026, Josh has won the Las Vegas Open, UK Open, Bali, Qatar). He also won the Derby 9ball and got bronze at both the World 10ball and the WNT European Open. Four titles and six medals at the majors in a single year is almost unfathomable given the depth of the fields now found at the majors. He is playing pool at a level never seen before and, frankly, beyond anything I thought I would ever see in my lifetime. Restricting my attentions to singles play at the WNT and Predator PBS tours, nobody but Josh has won even two majors this year.
Asking whether Filler is the best ever is a little more reasonable. If I'm momentarily allowed to omit Mosconi and Greenleaf, I've already got Josh as a top three pool player of all time, with Efren and Sigel the only two others worthy of mention. For example, Josh, still 29, already owns a better career resume than the 43-year-old SVB by quite a bit. As I noted in another thread:
At 29, Josh has won more majors than Shane did in his entire career. Shane is, notably, missing the China Open (every bit as hard to win as the US Open 9ball until recently, possibly harder) and is missing nearly all of the ten ball majors (most notably the Las Vegas Open, Bali Open, Qatar Open, World 10ball). Josh has won the gold medal at the World Games and Shane has not. Each has a World 9ball and a World 8ball, but Shane has just one WNT major outside of the World 9ball (Florida Open) while Josh has three (2 UK Opens and 1 European Open). Josh has won the WPA World Teams Championship 10ball and Shane has not. Whether you look at the 9ball majors or the 10ball majors, Josh has outshone Shane by quite a bit.
Shane's five US Open 9balls is awesome, legendary indeed, but so is Filler's 1 US Open, 3 China Opens and 1 World Games gold. To that point of the comparison, there's a discussion, but Josh has also won major championships all over the globe on a very regular basis and Shane has not. That's why Shane is missing so many of the majors on his resume and Josh is not.
I think it's too early to place Josh above Sigel or Efren, but he's the best of the 21st century and I think he'll, one day, be remembered as the best pool player of all time. Yes, he has the highest ever Fargo, but greatness is measured in titles, specifically major titles, and no player of this century measures up to Josh Filler.
Filler has been in dead stroke for a decade!
He (Filler) is certainly impressive. For my money however, it will be awhile before anyone supplants Efren...Maybe never. I don't know that I have ever witnessed anyone who saw and executed the shots Efren has, in tournament play.In men's pool, I think we've reached the point where asking who is best is silly.
This year, Josh has won four majors. Let's call a major a field having 96+ players, a deep internationally diverse field, and $25,000+ first prize. In 2026, Josh has won the Las Vegas Open, UK Open, Bali, Qatar). He also won the Derby 9ball and got bronze at both the World 10ball and the WNT European Open. Four titles and six medals at the majors in a single year is almost unfathomable given the depth of the fields now found at the majors. He is playing pool at a level never seen before and, frankly, beyond anything I thought I would ever see in my lifetime. Restricting my attentions to singles play at the WNT and Predator PBS tours, nobody but Josh has won even two majors this year.
Asking whether Filler is the best ever is a little more reasonable. If I'm momentarily allowed to omit Mosconi and Greenleaf, I've already got Josh as a top three pool player of all time, with Efren and Sigel the only two others worthy of mention. For example, Josh, still 29, already owns a better career resume than the 43-year-old SVB by quite a bit. As I noted in another thread:
At 29, Josh has won more majors than Shane did in his entire career. Shane is, notably, missing the China Open (every bit as hard to win as the US Open 9ball until recently, possibly harder) and is missing nearly all of the ten ball majors (most notably the Las Vegas Open, Bali Open, Qatar Open, World 10ball). Josh has won the gold medal at the World Games and Shane has not. Each has a World 9ball and a World 8ball, but Shane has just one WNT major outside of the World 9ball (Florida Open) while Josh has three (2 UK Opens and 1 European Open). Josh has won the WPA World Teams Championship 10ball and Shane has not. Whether you look at the 9ball majors or the 10ball majors, Josh has outshone Shane by quite a bit.
Shane's five US Open 9balls is awesome, legendary indeed, but so is Filler's 1 US Open, 3 China Opens and 1 World Games gold. To that point of the comparison, there's a discussion, but Josh has also won major championships all over the globe on a very regular basis and Shane has not. That's why Shane is missing so many of the majors on his resume and Josh is not.
I think it's too early to place Josh above Sigel or Efren, but he's the best of the 21st century and I think he'll, one day, be remembered as the best pool player of all time. Yes, he has the highest ever Fargo, but greatness is measured in titles, specifically major titles, and no player of this century measures up to Josh Filler.
Filler has been in dead stroke for a decade!
players aren't lining up to "try" him, are they
I think we're of a similar mindset with Efren. The Efren legend is based as much on innovation, imagination and adaptation as it is on his tournament credentials. I recently wrote of Efren:He (Filler) is certainly impressive. For my money however, it will be awhile before anyone supplants Efren...Maybe never. I don't know that I have ever witnessed anyone who saw and executed the shots Efren has, in tournament play.
FWIW, if anyone has a shot at futurestatus, it would certainly be Josh.
Excellent analysis.In men's pool, I think we've reached the point where asking who is best is silly.
This year, Josh has won four majors. Let's call a major a field having 96+ players, a deep internationally diverse field, and $25,000+ first prize. In 2026, Josh has won the Las Vegas Open, UK Open, Bali, Qatar). He also won the Derby 9ball and got bronze at both the World 10ball and the WNT European Open. Four titles and six medals at the majors in a single year is almost unfathomable given the depth of the fields now found at the majors. He is playing pool at a level never seen before and, frankly, beyond anything I thought I would ever see in my lifetime. Restricting my attentions to singles play at the WNT and Predator PBS tours, nobody but Josh has won even two majors this year.
Asking whether Filler is the best ever is a little more reasonable. If I'm momentarily allowed to omit Mosconi and Greenleaf, I've already got Josh as a top three pool player of all time, with Efren and Sigel the only two others worthy of mention. For example, Josh, still 29, already owns a better career resume than the 43-year-old SVB by quite a bit. As I noted in another thread:
At 29, Josh has won more majors than Shane did in his entire career. Shane is, notably, missing the China Open (every bit as hard to win as the US Open 9ball until recently, possibly harder) and is missing nearly all of the ten ball majors (most notably the Las Vegas Open, Bali Open, Qatar Open, World 10ball). Josh has won the gold medal at the World Games and Shane has not. Each has a World 9ball and a World 8ball, but Shane has just one WNT major outside of the World 9ball (Florida Open) while Josh has three (2 UK Opens and 1 European Open). Josh has won the WPA World Teams Championship 10ball and Shane has not. Whether you look at the 9ball majors or the 10ball majors, Josh has outshone Shane by quite a bit.
Shane's five US Open 9balls is awesome, legendary indeed, but so is Filler's 1 US Open, 3 China Opens and 1 World Games gold. To that point of the comparison, there's a discussion, but Josh has also won major championships all over the globe on a very regular basis and Shane has not. That's why Shane is missing so many of the majors on his resume and Josh is not.
I think it's too early to place Josh above Sigel or Efren, but he's the best of the 21st century and I think he'll, one day, be remembered as the best pool player of all time. Yes, he has the highest ever Fargo, but greatness is measured in titles, specifically major titles, and no player of this century measures up to Josh Filler.
Filler has been in dead stroke for a decade!
That is one of the most well written pieces I've ever read. I think you have both eloquently and precisely captured that "thing" about Efren, that may never be replaced in many of our minds.I think we're of a similar mindset with Efren. The Efren legend is based as much on innovation, imagination and adaptation as it is on his tournament credentials. I recently wrote of Efren:
Efren's efforts are legendary, in part, because he advanced the science of the game ... when Efren came to America, he was employing some shots and strategies never seen before. He introduced us to many of the shots that would gradually enter the arsenals of most of the top players. Kick shots, 2-way sots, safeties --- Efren seemed to know shots that nobody else knew. At 9ball, but even more so at 1-pocket, he got everybody thinking differently about how the game can and should be played. Efren's greatness is partly tied to his performance and partly tied to his groundbreaking style of play, which integrated billiard knowledge into pool in a new way. His imagination set the stage for greater development of the theory underlying the game. Another amazing thing about Efren is the speed at which he learned and mastered new games. He had never played straight pool but tried his hand at the 1993 World 14.1 championships and medaled. He had never focused on 8ball, but when the IPT came along in 2006, he won the biggest prize ever paid in 8ball, which was $500,000. He had never tried one pocket until he learned much of it from, among others, Billy Incardona and Fred Bentivegna, and it wasn't long before, in Billy's words, he clearly understood things that even they didn't. He went on to be the greatest ever one-pocket player.
As a tournament competitor, I'd rate both Filler and Sigel above Efren, but Efren is so much more than his playing resume, and that's why, at least for now, I can't give the GOAT label to Filler. That's likely to change at some point.
not even in one pocket, which he plays twice a year.. probably only fedor would play him even
Pretty sure Alex would if the money were tight.
Agree here strongly. Josh hasn't been the best at all times, but his track record over the past decade dwarfs that of all other players. He has a great year every year. This will be the ninth year in a row in which he finished in the top four of the AZB money list.As I said as a comment on the Facebook version of this:
“It’s always interesting to look at these things.
It’s just hard for me to accept that during the time that Fedor was getting the “Gorst Slam” he wasn’t the best on the planet. Same for FSR during his purple patch. If you are winning the US Open, World 9b etc and Filler *isn’t* winning majors, that means something to me, no matter how much Filler dominates lesser tournaments. It doesn’t mean Filler wasn’t the highest Fargo in that period, but I personally wouldn’t say he was the best.”
I think Josh is currently the best, but my issue above was the suggestion that he’s been the best during all this time.
Was Tom Brady not the best player in the years he didn't win the Super Bowl? I know, team sport, but pool has luck, which has a strong effect on short-term outcomes just like teammates have on great football players.As I said as a comment on the Facebook version of this:
“It’s always interesting to look at these things.
It’s just hard for me to accept that during the time that Fedor was getting the “Gorst Slam” he wasn’t the best on the planet. Same for FSR during his purple patch. If you are winning the US Open, World 9b etc and Filler *isn’t* winning majors, that means something to me, no matter how much Filler dominates lesser tournaments. It doesn’t mean Filler wasn’t the highest Fargo in that period, but I personally wouldn’t say he was the best.”
I think Josh is currently the best, but my issue above was the suggestion that he’s been the best during all this time.
I can't remember exactly what match it was that I watched between Efren and Sigel. I think it was the first time I ever remembered seeing Sigel wonder if he if he belonged on the same table as another player. There was a time in Efrens day when the other top guys basically knew they were likely playing for 2nd if Efren was in the field.I think we're of a similar mindset with Efren. The Efren legend is based as much on innovation, imagination and adaptation as it is on his tournament credentials. I recently wrote of Efren:
Efren's efforts are legendary, in part, because he advanced the science of the game ... when Efren came to America, he was employing some shots and strategies never seen before. He introduced us to many of the shots that would gradually enter the arsenals of most of the top players. Kick shots, 2-way sots, safeties --- Efren seemed to know shots that nobody else knew. At 9ball, but even more so at 1-pocket, he got everybody thinking differently about how the game can and should be played. Efren's greatness is partly tied to his performance and partly tied to his groundbreaking style of play, which integrated billiard knowledge into pool in a new way. His imagination set the stage for greater development of the theory underlying the game. Another amazing thing about Efren is the speed at which he learned and mastered new games. He had never played straight pool but tried his hand at the 1993 World 14.1 championships and medaled. He had never focused on 8ball, but when the IPT came along in 2006, he won the biggest prize ever paid in 8ball, which was $500,000. He had never tried one pocket until he learned much of it from, among others, Billy Incardona and Fred Bentivegna, and it wasn't long before, in Billy's words, he clearly understood things that even they didn't. He went on to be the greatest ever one-pocket player.
As a tournament competitor, I'd rate both Filler and Sigel above Efren, but Efren is so much more than his playing resume, and that's why, at least for now, I can't give the GOAT label to Filler. That's likely to change at some point.