If I have to bet $$$, my bet is always on Filler - you pick your player and we'll bet $1,000 every match they play. If the answer is "no bet" then we would assume you agree Filler is the bestWas Tom Brady not the best player in the years he didn't win the Super Bowl? I know, team sport, but pool has luck, which has a strong effect on short-term outcomes just like teammates have on great football players.
Josh won more frequently against top players even when other top players were having their career years by tournament results. Do you think Fedor or FSR aren't as good now? Or did a few hill-hill rolls go one way vs another way the years they won it all vs other years?
That's why who is best is a rotating cast other than Filler.
You do bring up a good point. I was wondering why Mike's analysis was over two-year spans rather than one-year spans. I'm betting if he did one-year spans there were probably a couple years (likely those you mentioned) where someone else edged him out. By doing two-year spans, he was able to get the consistent results he wanted. Just a hunch. It's still compelling evidence, of course.