Is Joshua Filler the best pool player?

Was Tom Brady not the best player in the years he didn't win the Super Bowl? I know, team sport, but pool has luck, which has a strong effect on short-term outcomes just like teammates have on great football players.

Josh won more frequently against top players even when other top players were having their career years by tournament results. Do you think Fedor or FSR aren't as good now? Or did a few hill-hill rolls go one way vs another way the years they won it all vs other years?

That's why who is best is a rotating cast other than Filler.

You do bring up a good point. I was wondering why Mike's analysis was over two-year spans rather than one-year spans. I'm betting if he did one-year spans there were probably a couple years (likely those you mentioned) where someone else edged him out. By doing two-year spans, he was able to get the consistent results he wanted. Just a hunch. It's still compelling evidence, of course.
If I have to bet $$$, my bet is always on Filler - you pick your player and we'll bet $1,000 every match they play. If the answer is "no bet" then we would assume you agree Filler is the best 🤷‍♂️
 
If I have to bet $$$, my bet is always on Filler - you pick your player and we'll bet $1,000 every match they play. If the answer is "no bet" then we would assume you agree Filler is the best 🤷‍♂️
Not sure if you were responding directly to me, or just agreeing with me. But yes, I agree with your succinct assessment. I'm taking Filler even money.

About the only person-game I might consider betting on someone else would be Filler-Gorst 10b. And even then I'm not sure.
 
Of course Filler is an amazing player, and absolutely one of the best, but what about the 1000's of games that likely aren't recorded, or the Philippino/Chinese players that don't play in fargo based events?

His performance is amazing don't get me wrong, but this assessment is truly only valid for Fargo.
 
Last edited:
Of course Filler is an amazing player, and absolutely one of the best, but what about the 1000's of games that likely aren't recorded, or the Philippino/Chinese players that don't play in fargo based events?

His performance is amazing don't get me wrong, but it's only valid for Fargo.

i think for the chinese pool we just have to draw a line, even if there is overlap with some players, and say it's a different cuesport altogether. wu jiaqing and zheng xiaohuai would likely be top 10 fargo if they focused on american pool again.
 
i think for the chinese pool we just have to draw a line, even if there is overlap with some players, and say it's a different cuesport altogether. wu jiaqing and zheng xiaohuai would likely be top 10 fargo if they focused on american pool again.

Yes, it's a different cue sport all together, but this video also discredits the other top players saying they are performing worse than Filler. When, in reality, we only know they are performing worse in Fargo reported games, not necessarily across the board.

Again, Filler is certainly a top player, but stating that he's a notch above everyone else may be misleading.
 
Agree here strongly. Josh hasn't been the best at all times, but his track record over the past decade dwarfs that of all other players. He has a great year every year. This will be the ninth year in a row in which he finished in the top four of the AZB money list.

PS The Gorst slam was absurd. It attempted to treat the World Pool Masters, a small field, invitational event, as if it were a major, and it was never anything close to that. The slam was a Matchroom marketing gimmick.

Fedor did beat Filler in the final of the World Pool Masters that year (hill hill).
 
Yes, it's a different cue sport all together, but this video also discredits the other top players saying they are performing worse than Filler. When, in reality, we only know they are performing worse in Fargo reported games, not necessarily across the board. ...
If those unreported games were included, would Filler go up or down relative to the field?
 
... You do bring up a good point. I was wondering why Mike's analysis was over two-year spans rather than one-year spans. I'm betting if he did one-year spans there were probably a couple years (likely those you mentioned) where someone else edged him out. By doing two-year spans, he was able to get the consistent results he wanted. Just a hunch. It's still compelling evidence, of course.
If you split out a two-year stretch, and one of the years was weaker for Filler relative to the field, the other year would be stronger. I think the trend is pretty clear. (And with nine separate yearly analyses, people's eyes would glaze over.)
 
There was a point maybe 6-7 years ago that I felt Fedor was the best... But it seems Filler has continued to improve, while Fedor, amazing as he is, hasn't really improved... The last few years Josh has become unquestionably the best in the world as his game keeps getting better and better.. it's pretty crazy.
 
Now? Yeah I’d say Josh is the best in the world, however For me it’s Efren, and then Shane is a very close second in the GOAT category. Josh is a phenomenal player and when it’s all said and done he could be the best to ever play.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it's a different cue sport all together, but this video also discredits the other top players saying they are performing worse than Filler. When, in reality, we only know they are performing worse in Fargo reported games, not necessarily across the board.

Again, Filler is certainly a top player, but stating that he's a notch above everyone else may be misleading.

don't think i quite follow here. is this referring to the fargo included players currently playing chinese pool, like ko ping chung?
 
Back
Top