Is Joshua Filler the best pool player?

another thing is that every year now he plays a TPA 1.000 match. this year i think both at derby and predator event. i know others have such matches logged in recent years, but filler seems to do it annually
 
Some of the lesser tournaments Filler won during the Gorst Slam year, 2024, are
China Open,
World 8-Ball Championship,
DCC 9-Ball,
DCC Banks,
DCC Bigfoot

and don't forget the Challenge of Champions, where World 8-Ball, 9-Ball, and 10-Ball champions (Filler, Gorst, Biado) battled it out and Filler won.

And Filler was a single rack away from winning World Pool Masters

Regardless, who won more or more significant of these largely single elimination events is a pretty noisy measuring stick

Was 2024 the year that all of the top WNT stars agreed to boycott WPA events, and then Josh backed out and went and played in those events? I think that covers both the World 8b and the China Open. I don’t want to get into the who was right and wrong on that, my point simply is that I personally put less weight on those titles given the absence of the other contenders (although yes, Josh still had to beat a lot of good players, or even great players, to win the titles).

In my view, there are many ways of measuring greatness for pool players. Fargo is certainly one of the leading ways, but I also think winning the biggest titles matters.
So in that year, my vote would go to Fedor, just as it would go to FSR in his great year. I do agree that Josh has been the most consistent over that 9 year stretch.
 
BULLSHIT, is he the best player right now, absolutely, does he have a better career than SVB, nope. not yet.
As I have spelled out the details of the comparison, I'll repeat that Josh can retire tomorrow and have the better resume of the two by a lot.

I fully accept your right to disagree, but obviously, the details of your line of reasoning are a state secret. Josh has not only outachieved Shane's career already but, in Shane's words, "Filler has worn me out for the length of my career." It has been a decade of domination for Josh over Shane. It's about 80% to 20%.

Yelling *****hit rather than justifying such an outburst with your line of reasoning is *****hit, and it leads me to believe that you haven't really thought much about this.

There are numerous major titles that Josh has won that Shane hasn't, but it's not true the other way. What major title does Shane hold that Josh does not? I'm listening. I can't even think of one.
 
Yes Filler is the best player in the world. But there are several players who are very close to his level of play, and on any given day they can beat him in a tournament race to 9 or 11.
Absolutely right! The number of great players today is really something to behold and, just as you suggest, the top few can all beat each other at the majors. That's why Filler's ability to mass produce majors year after year is so impressive and the fact that he seems to always play perfect pool when he reaches the finals at a major is awfully hard to fathom.

The competitiveness at the top of the game, which you rightly note, is why we watch. Filler, FSR, Gorst, SVB, and a few others are why we watch.
 
I can't remember exactly what match it was that I watched between Efren and Sigel. I think it was the first time I ever remembered seeing Sigel wonder if he if he belonged on the same table as another player. There was a time in Efrens day when the other top guys basically knew they were likely playing for 2nd if Efren was in the field.
Efren spent several years as barely the 5th best player in the field and often outside that top 5. Let’s not rewrite history.

If you’re thinking the IPT, Sigel was already retired by nearly 10 years.
 
If I had the opportunity to watch one player compete...it would be FILLER. end of story.
I like Filler, but I would rather watch Efren or Melling. I'm not saying they are "better," but I think I would enjoy watching them more than Filler.
It's hard, albeit impossible to argue his (Filler) talent though.
 
Was 2024 the year that all of the top WNT stars agreed to boycott WPA events, and then Josh backed out and went and played in those events? I think that covers both the World 8b and the China Open. I don’t want to get into the who was right and wrong on that, my point simply is that I personally put less weight on those titles given the absence of the other contenders (although yes, Josh still had to beat a lot of good players, or even great players, to win the titles).

In my view, there are many ways of measuring greatness for pool players. Fargo is certainly one of the leading ways, but I also think winning the biggest titles matters.
So in that year, my vote would go to Fedor, just as it would go to FSR in his great year. I do agree that Josh has been the most consistent over that 9 year stretch.
Yes, but if you are going to get into the devaluation of titles game, don't forget that the best player in the world was not allowed to play in the event when SVB won his only World 9ball title in 2022. Due to the shocking and incomprehensible ban by the WPA of Russian players, Fedor, best player in the world at the time, had to skip the event.

Those who boycotted the 2024 China Open to take a stand against WPA all had a choice and they chose not to play. In 2022, Fedor did not have a choice. It was made for him by WPA. The Filler haters will hate, but they'll never tell the whole story. Not every top player plays in every big event, and it is always going to be that way. If you find the draw for that China Open, you'll see that the field was super-tough. The Asian-based events bring out the countless great Asian cueists who don't have the financing to play the international circuit. Similarly, even without the presence of the world's best player, Shane beat a strong field and I'm not putting any asterisk on his great achievement.
 
I think he’s definitely the best right now. I’m not sure it’s fair to ask if he’s the greatest of all time. If people like Efren and Bustamante and Strickland played on the same equipment early in their careers I’m sure they would adjust and play great
Agree. you can only be the best of your time. Comparing eras is mental masturbation. Champions will be champions regardless of when they played.
 
I like Filler, but I would rather watch Efren or Melling. I'm not saying they are "better," but I think I would enjoy watching them more than Filler.
It's hard, albeit impossible to argue his (Filler) talent though.
I'll never be a huge Filler fan but there is ZERO doubt he's the best of the current gen and as good as any that have chalked a cue.
 
Was 2024 the year that all of the top WNT stars agreed to boycott WPA events, and then Josh backed out and went and played in those events? I think that covers both the World 8b and the China Open. I don’t want to get into the who was right and wrong on that, my point simply is that I personally put less weight on those titles given the absence of the other contenders (although yes, Josh still had to beat a lot of good players, or even great players, to win the titles).

In my view, there are many ways of measuring greatness for pool players. Fargo is certainly one of the leading ways, but I also think winning the biggest titles matters.
So in that year, my vote would go to Fedor, just as it would go to FSR in his great year. I do agree that Josh has been the most consistent over that 9 year stretch.

Here is another way to view the "Gorst Slam" year. These are the 25 players with the most games in common against gorst/Filler in 2024. They both have losing records against SVB for instance (circled means losing record).

Filler wins the head-to-head competition.

And he just generally has fewer opponents that best him

Winning world 9-Ball and US Open is amazing, of course. But I feel like you're adding the suggestion that Gorst outplayed Filler for the year. And that feels like a stretch to me.



1794965229269.png
 
Wonder if Filler and Shane has ever discussed a race to 100. That’s Shane’s game. Would Filler play it. I think he should

And to add when during Covid and Filler was at Roy’s basement playing constantly he put on quite a display
Filler wanted 9 ball. Shane wanted 10 ball. Filler's 10 ball break is way below Shane's but still would have liked to see them play either format.
 
Here is another way to view the "Gorst Slam" year. These are the 25 players with the most games in common against gorst/Filler in 2024. They both have losing records against SVB for instance (circled means losing record).

Filler wins the head-to-head competition.

And he just generally has fewer opponents that best him

Winning world 9-Ball and US Open is amazing, of course. But I feel like you're adding the suggestion that Gorst outplayed Filler for the year. And that feels like a stretch to me.



View attachment 944144
What stands out to me is that SVB had by far the most combined games played against Filler and Gorst while both those players were at their absolute peaks...and had a winning record against both. Shaw, as a point of comparison, lost to both and got cooked by Gorst.
 
Back
Top