Who has the best tip finish after a stroke?

A wonky stroke will in most cases not produce the desired hit on the cueball so no great players have one.

Now.Which great player would you say has a wonky stroke..?

Just answer the question.
Now who is missing the point?
 
You are.Again, which great player uses a wonky stroke?

Stop running.
Who is running? I'm waiting for you to ask a relevant question. Pro player strokes are not relevant to a discussion on stroke physics. It's a logical fallacy that every good stroke is represented by at least one pro player.

It doesn't matter if the player is a pro or a local league player. The only part of a stroke that matters is the momentum of the cue during the millisecond of contact with the cue ball. The cue ball neither knows nor cares how the cue came to arrive at that momentum. Nor does the cue ball care a whit about the cue's momentum after the millisecond of contact.

It makes sense that when one works on their stroke, they work on their entire stroke. If the whole stroke is good, from lead-up to follow-through, then the millisecond of the stroke that matters will be also good. It does not follow that a wonky stroke is a bad stroke. As long as it's consistently good during the critical millisecond, it's a good stroke, no matter how bad its aesthetics.

Obviously, no one is suggesting anyone try to develop a wonky stroke. But not every good stroke is picture perfect, and that's okay, because only a teeny-tiny part of the stroke actually matters. The rest is just an arbitrary path the cue takes, of zero consequence, fouls and equipment damage notwithstanding. If it isn't broke, there's no need to fix it for the sake of aesthetics.
 
Last edited:
striking the cueball with accuracy
There you go! I get the most accurate strike to the cueball by focus on the white at impact. If the follow through helps insure that the contact is accurate then perfect the follow through also.
Shaun Murphy is my favorite example of holding the follow through until the balls have stopped.

Here's a match between Shaun and Mark Williams. The opening break and next shot by Shaun show his method. Mark Williams moves much quicker after the stroke but the last thing to move is his cue from the finish position. His body raises up yet his cue stays down.
Mark Williams appears to have his eyes on whitey as it is struck.
 
You seem to fail to understand that a good follow through is one of the keys to deliver the cue properly and therefore striking the cueball with accuracy.
You seem to fail to understand that a really great stroke is even, leveled out, and this will not leave your cue tip buried in the cloth.

There are those that “strike down” on the ball like the Miz did, those that don’t, those that “hit” the ball like SVB accounting for his cue stopping pretty much right after contact, not following through. While many great players strokes have massive follow through like Gorst, some do not. It’s about being able to strike the cue ball where intended, time after time, a repeatable stroke.
 
if you ever used a stroke like allen hopkins and worked on it, you would find it very effective. as the stroke does what is needed perfectly.

looks as they say can be deceiving.

look at arnold palmers golf swing. about the same type of wacky swing compared to other pro's. try beating him at golf.
 
There you go! I get the most accurate strike to the cueball by focus on the white at impact. If the follow through helps insure that the contact is accurate then perfect the follow through also.
Shaun Murphy is my favorite example of holding the follow through until the balls have stopped.

Here's a match between Shaun and Mark Williams. The opening break and next shot by Shaun show his method. Mark Williams moves much quicker after the stroke but the last thing to move is his cue from the finish position. His body raises up yet his cue stays down.
Mark Williams appears to have his eyes on whitey as it is struck.
I would guess that 99% of players look at the object ball last but there are exceptions such as Jayson Shaw.

An argument could be made that if you are lined up properly and execute the stroke perfectly, the ball could be pocketed
even with your eyes closed.However, the term '' taking the eye of the ball'' has been used by legends such as Buddy and Nick and I think for most players it's important that you see the cueball hit the object ball.

Jerry Mcworter talks about this here

 
You seem to fail to understand that a really great stroke is even, leveled out, and this will not leave your cue tip buried in the cloth.

There are those that “strike down” on the ball like the Miz did, those that don’t, those that “hit” the ball like SVB accounting for his cue stopping pretty much right after contact, not following through. While many great players strokes have massive follow through like Gorst, some do not. It’s about being able to strike the cue ball where intended, time after time, a repeatable stroke.
So, you are saying Mizerak, Varner and Sigel who all ''bury'' their tips don't have great strokes..?

And youre completely wrong in that a great stroke needs to be level and even.

A great stroke is one that generates power and precision.

Plus you are defeating your own argument because if a stroke is straight, it does not matter if it's level or not, you will hit the cueball as intended
as Earl, Reyes and Bustamante will show you.

And give me another example of a top player that uses no follow through in the manner of SVB.
 
Last edited:
It's important that you see the cueball hit the object ball.
Seeing the cuetip launch the object ball doesn't keep me from seeing the cueball hit the object ball. My eyes stay with whitey after the launch. I see any rotation and or variation as it travels to the object ball. My focus allows me to see any rotation or skid at the cueball object ball colision.
As a baseball player my eyes were on the baseball as soon as it left the pitchers hand. I had good enough focus to see the laces and rotation of the baseball as it came to the plate. Giving me a reading on the pitch. I can still remember how the baseball looked as my bat launched it on the longest home run I ever hit.
And uh oh yeah I was a good hitter. I hit the wheel in one high school game. Shrug 🤷‍♂️.
With that said, I did start playing pool with a Willie Mosconi book for guidance and Willie the owner of the straight pool high run record saying, "object ball last". I performed to Master level using that method. Jason Shaw has eclipsed the Mosconi high run record. 🤔
Well I created a thread that relates my switch from object ball to cueball at launch. https://forums.azbilliards.com/thre...e-cueball-while-delivering-the-stroke.304747/
 
There are many good ideas about this topic in this post. The top three players SVB, Filler, and Gorst in my opinion use the rifle sighting meathod , not pulling the trigger but squeasing the trigger. The pause with the tip close to the cueball is strickly for allignment purposes which all three players use. Of course a still head and smooth take away are used with this sighting meathod. When SVB was spending a lot of time in Russia and Europe ten yrs ago Filler and Gorst studied his approach to making a shot. SVB also touched the table where he wanted the cueball to end up for position, this was mental training for speed control. Have fun.
 
Seeing the cuetip launch the object ball doesn't keep me from seeing the cueball hit the object ball. My eyes stay with whitey after the launch. I see any rotation and or variation as it travels to the object ball. My focus allows me to see any rotation or skid at the cueball object ball colision.
As a baseball player my eyes were on the baseball as soon as it left the pitchers hand. I had good enough focus to see the laces and rotation of the baseball as it came to the plate. Giving me a reading on the pitch. I can still remember how the baseball looked as my bat launched it on the longest home run I ever hit.
And uh oh yeah I was a good hitter. I hit the wheel in one high school game. Shrug 🤷‍♂️.
With that said, I did start playing pool with a Willie Mosconi book for guidance and Willie the owner of the straight pool high run record saying, "object ball last". I performed to Master level using that method. Jason Shaw has eclipsed the Mosconi high run record. 🤔
Well I created a thread that relates my switch from object ball to cueball at launch. https://forums.azbilliards.com/thre...e-cueball-while-delivering-the-stroke.304747/
Well, Shaw surpassing Mosconi's record does not mean his technique of looking at the object ball last does not mean that it's better to do it that way nor that he achieved the feat by doing so.It would be like saying Sigel won over 100 pro tournaments because he played left handed while in fact being a right hander.

Again, 99% of players do it the other way.And seeing the spin on the cueball after it's launched is of no consequence as you cannot change it's trajectory anymore.

But we'd have to see how well you play using that method, in any event I strongly advise against it.

It's like people on this forum saying Hopkins played great using that hideous flick stroke not realising he did not play great because of it but in spite.
 
if you ever used a stroke like allen hopkins and worked on it, you would find it very effective. as the stroke does what is needed perfectly.

looks as they say can be deceiving.

look at arnold palmers golf swing. about the same type of wacky swing compared to other pro's. try beating him at golf.
Show me an example of Hopkins executing a power shot.

Case closed.
 
Back
Top