Is Joshua Filler the best pool player?

Efren spent several years as barely the 5th best player in the field and often outside that top 5. Let’s not rewrite history.

If you’re thinking the IPT, Sigel was already retired by nearly 10 years.
When the big money was on the line, the "barely 5th best player in the field" seemed to walk away with the cheese more often than not.
😉
 
I think we're of a similar mindset with Efren. The Efren legend is based as much on innovation, imagination and adaptation as it is on his tournament credentials. I recently wrote of Efren:

Efren's efforts are legendary, in part, because he advanced the science of the game ... when Efren came to America, he was employing some shots and strategies never seen before. He introduced us to many of the shots that would gradually enter the arsenals of most of the top players. Kick shots, 2-way sots, safeties --- Efren seemed to know shots that nobody else knew. At 9ball, but even more so at 1-pocket, he got everybody thinking differently about how the game can and should be played. Efren's greatness is partly tied to his performance and partly tied to his groundbreaking style of play, which integrated billiard knowledge into pool in a new way. His imagination set the stage for greater development of the theory underlying the game. Another amazing thing about Efren is the speed at which he learned and mastered new games. He had never played straight pool but tried his hand at the 1993 World 14.1 championships and medaled. He had never focused on 8ball, but when the IPT came along in 2006, he won the biggest prize ever paid in 8ball, which was $500,000. He had never tried one pocket until he learned much of it from, among others, Billy Incardona and Fred Bentivegna, and it wasn't long before, in Billy's words, he clearly understood things that even they didn't. He went on to be the greatest ever one-pocket player.

As a tournament competitor, I'd rate both Filler and Sigel above Efren, but Efren is so much more than his playing resume, and that's why, at least for now, I can't give the GOAT label to Filler. That's likely to change at some point.
Why would you rate Sigel above Efren? Hasn't Efern dominated One Pocket, Do close to as well in rotation?
 
Someone knows the answer to this but Shane is considerably older than Josh and for much of Shane's best years many of the "MAJOR" titles of today weren't even on his radar or didn't exist at all so I find it pretty hard to hold it against him that he is behind in the count. The fact that he's even competitive with Filler and Fedor being this much their senior should tell you how strong he played 10-15 years ago...

I know this isn't the best argument as many holes can be poked in it but I'm tired. I'M SHANES AGE lol
 
As for recent years, if speaking purely by average match results (who beats who and who often) in big tournaments, anyone who thinks Filler isn't the best is delusional, since it's a matter of statistics, which Fargo showcases very well.

Apart from this, you can define the "best pool player" in countless ways, so as usual in a pool forum context, this becomes a matter of semantics where the less pedantic posters who don't provide their definitions bash at other people who also didn't provide theirs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbb
As for recent years, if speaking purely by average match results (who beats who and who often) in big tournaments, anyone who thinks Filler isn't the best is delusional, since it's a matter of statistics, which Fargo showcases very well.

Apart from this, you can define the "best pool player" in countless ways, so as usual in a pool forum context, this becomes a matter of semantics where the less pedantic posters who don't provide their definitions bash at other people who also didn't provide theirs.

i go by the eye test. watch enough matches and it becomes obvious that he's something else. like earl was in his day.
 
Whoever thinks Shane is old is crazy. Was in the best shape of my life at 47, stopped training and went downhill, but he is certainly not old
 
Why would you rate Sigel above Efren? Hasn't Efern dominated One Pocket, Do close to as well in rotation?
Because when 9-ball and 14.1 werr the primary games, Sigel was the #1 player in the world if you scored it by the two primary games.

I did a major tournament count from the time Efren landed in 1985 throughout the 80s. Efren would’ve been in his mid to late 30s. Sigel won 16 major tournament including two major 14.1 tournaments in that span. Efren won 5. It was often joked that Efren was Mr. Second Place, but that would suggest he made a lot of second places compared to some of his peers. That wasn’t the case either. It was the few times he made the finals, didnt win. Compare that to Sigel who won a ridiculous ~95% of the finals he was in for professional tournament finals (~65 finals appearances). This is why. By 1989, Sigel started talking about retirement and fishing more.

Anytime Efren is interviewed, he always points to Mike Sigel as the best player he ever played. Despite Internet, rumors, he didn’t say Strickland or Varner, even though he had every right to say those two. It was Sigel. What he did say was that Strickland didn’t start really winning until Sigel retired early.

Efren’s prowess in one pocket didnt really start to showcase until the late 1990’s, and he is by far the best that’s ever played it. His creativity and IQ shone brightly. But he wasnt a match against Sigel in 9-ball or 14.1. If 10-ball had been the game, Sigel no doubt would be dominant along with Earl. And the few one pocket pro tournaments that were held, Sigel won a couple of those as well. Had the Derby City Classic started in 1980, Sigel and Varner would have been vying for the All-around every year.

And I disagree with some that say Efren is the greatest 8-ball player ever. I think he is but only after the break. Before the Sardo rack, Efren’s break wouldnt have been able to compete with Sigel’s (and other’s) break. I was at the IPT 8-ball. Nobody was break and running like Sigel was in the practice room. Breaking hard, and picking things off like so many cherries like a great 14.1 player would, all the while jawing and jabbing annoyingly. But the Sigel that ended up playing against Reyes in the finals was yippy, nervy and clearly tournament rusty.
 
i go by the eye test. watch enough matches and it becomes obvious that he's something else. like earl was in his day.
Sigel for me, when I was a teenager first falling in love with the game. Sigel was winning tournament after tournament. I only saw him a few times growing up, it seemed that every time there was a pool tournament on TV, Sigel won it. The one tournament (before Earl really came on in the late 80’s) that Sigel didnt win on TV was the World Disney Land Championship (Medina).
 
Why would you rate Sigel above Efren? Hasn't Efern dominated One Pocket, Do close to as well in rotation?
Good question.

It is very close. The case for Sigel, much like that for Efren, goes beyond his tournament credentials, and is as follows. Mike played in both the straight pool era and the 9ball era. He was a top five of all time straight pooler (perhaps along with Mosconi, Greenleaf, Mizerak and Crane) during the straight pool era and remains, in my opinion, a top five of all time 9ball player.

There's little question that Efren is the best ever 1-pocket player. I'd rate him as the best ever 8ball player, which is very debatable for sure, but greatness is measured in titles, and when the biggest 8ball events with the biggest first prizes in history were played, Efren was the one shining brightest. He also won the WPA World 8ball Championship in 2004. He's widely regarded as the best ever at fifteen ball rotation in history. Still, neither 8ball, one pocket, nor fifteen ball rotation were the major disciplines in Efren's prime competitive years. At 9ball/10ball, he misses my top ten of all time.

Actually, my inclination is still to place Efren above Sigel, but only for the reasons I spelled out in Post #12 of this thread. As a collector of major championships, Efren is below both Sigel and Filler.
 
The only reason I would consider Filler the best ever is because he plays everygame at the highest of levels that it's easy why anyone would consider taking him in a calcutta at any event. It reminds me of Alex P when he was younger. Alex would play anyone at any game without fear.

Guys like Strickland, Mosconi, Greenleaf pretty much dominated the main game of the time.

I consider Sigel the greatest of all time because of his dominance in 14.1 which he took over to 9 ball. Same with Efren. Like it has been mentioned, he changed the way 9 ball was played here and then he took his talents to 1 pocket and he is considered the greatest player of that game.

Gorst is weird for me because as dominant as he is, it seems he has slowed down lately. I wonder if his focus on his social media outlets have hurt his game considering he probably profits a hell of a lot more from those than the actual game.

But then you ask yourself, what about all the asian players? Where do you put them in this discussion?
 
If those unreported games were included, would Filler go up or down relative to the field?
I'd love to know! My assumption is he would go down slightly against the other top performing players out there. May very well might still be at the top, but the margin would be small.
 
Last edited:
The only reason I would consider Filler the best ever is because he plays everygame at the highest of levels that it's easy why anyone would consider taking him in a calcutta at any event. It reminds me of Alex P when he was younger. Alex would play anyone at any game without fear.

Guys like Strickland, Mosconi, Greenleaf pretty much dominated the main game of the time.

I consider Sigel the greatest of all time because of his dominance in 14.1 which he took over to 9 ball. Same with Efren. Like it has been mentioned, he changed the way 9 ball was played here and then he took his talents to 1 pocket and he is considered the greatest player of that game.

Gorst is weird for me because as dominant as he is, it seems he has slowed down lately. I wonder if his focus on his social media outlets have hurt his game considering he probably profits a hell of a lot more from those than the actual game.

But then you ask yourself, what about all the asian players? Where do you put them in this discussion?
Yes, very well said. Although 2026 has not been a great year for him, Fedor is an all-time great and enters each calendar year as one of the favorites for Player of the Year. I'm looking forward to seeing if he can find his "A" game at the Mosconi next week.

As for the Asian players, there have been many that are very elite. Beyond Efren, I'd rate each of Carlo Biado, Alex Pagulayan, Ko Pin Yi, Ko Ping Chung, and Dennis Orcullo as all-time greats, every one of them probably in the twenty-five best that ever picked up a cue.

Though both insanely great, I left off both JL Chang and Francisco Bustmante, although both were legends in the action room. For much of his career, Bustie was known as one who could not get over the finish line in the biggest spots. During his prime, the four biggest tiles to win were the World 9ball, the China Open, the US Open 9ball and the All-Japan Championships. Up to age 44, he had won just one title at these events, the 2002 All-Japan. At age 46, he won the All-Japan a second time, and at age 47, he won his only World 9ball. With JL Chang, whose career was tragically cut short at age 40, the major title count was similarly modest, with a win at the All-Japan and a World 8ball title. No doubt, those who see action results as the real measuring stick will see this differently, and that's OK. Yes, we all know that JL Chang wore Shane out in 10ball action. I left off Jose Parica for similar reasons, but he was a stone cold killer in the action room whose tournament record was exceeded by most of the all-time greats.
 
Last edited:
Good question.

It is very close. The case for Sigel, much like that for Efren, goes beyond his tournament credentials, and is as follows. Mike played in both the straight pool era and the 9ball era. He was a top five of all time straight pooler (perhaps along with Mosconi, Greenleaf, Mizerak and Crane) during the straight pool era and remains, in my opinion, a top five of all time 9ball player.

There's little question that Efren is the best ever 1-pocket player. I'd rate him as the best ever 8ball player, which is very debatable for sure, but greatness is measured in titles, and when the biggest 8ball events with the biggest first prizes in history were played, Efren was the one shining brightest. He also won the WPA World 8ball Championship in 2004. He's widely regarded as the best ever at fifteen ball rotation in history. Still, neither 8ball, one pocket, nor fifteen ball rotation were the major disciplines in Efren's prime competitive years. At 9ball/10ball, he misses my top ten of all time.

Actually, my inclination is still to place Efren above Sigel, but only for the reasons I spelled out in Post #12 of this thread. As a collector of major championships, Efren is below both Sigel and Filler.
I don't think there is any question about how great MS was.

It is alleged that Sigel may have used performance enhancing stimulants.

Is this a factor?
 
I don't think there is any question about how great MS was.

It is alleged that Sigel may have used performance enhancing stimulants.

Is this a factor?
Yes, these allegations are well-known. Of course, the performance-enhancing drug use issue has been around for decades in pool and many players share the possible stigma. It's way too big a topic to address here, but in a world where we have random drug testing in all WPA sanctioned events, it's tough to place a label on anyone that was never caught.

Hence, for me, it is not a factor.
 
Back
Top