Is Joshua Filler the best pool player?

I wonder if part of the mystique of SVB was earned through the TAR matches and long challenge matches. Sure, SVB may not have been off winning multiple China Opens or world titles to go with his US opens, but he was for many, myself included, almost like a lone gunfighter willing to step in against anybody.

This skinny kid with a break like a cannon blast was one of the only Americans at the time who you got the sense that had an "anytime, anywhere" attitude...and more often than not it was against a Filipino killer and SVB came out on top after a grueling multi day set.

I don't see how anyone can argue the simple numbers that Filler has more prestigious Titles than SVB, but Filler has never been that "Wyatt Earp" type that catches the imagination of many...not that he couldn't have, but his career just didn't unfold where he needed the long races to 100 to prove his superiority.
 
Filler is the top guy now, but he wasn’t around for the first half of SVB’s career. It’s fine to use titles and so-called “majors “ as the current metric, but I don’t think that has always been the case. SVB played when and where it made economic sense. He chased more titles later on, when it did make sense. Filler came of age at a very opportune time. I’m not downplaying his accomplishments, he has made it his life goal to be the best. Right now he is.
 
I wonder if part of the mystique of SVB was earned through the TAR matches and long challenge matches. Sure, SVB may not have been off winning multiple China Opens or world titles to go with his US opens, but he was for many, myself included, almost like a lone gunfighter willing to step in against anybody.

This skinny kid with a break like a cannon blast was one of the only Americans at the time who you got the sense that had an "anytime, anywhere" attitude...and more often than not it was against a Filipino killer and SVB came out on top after a grueling multi day set.

I don't see how anyone can argue the simple numbers that Filler has more prestigious Titles than SVB, but Filler has never been that "Wyatt Earp" type that catches the imagination of many...not that he couldn't have, but his career just didn't unfold where he needed the long races to 100 to prove his superiority.

easy to forget what a hole pool was in back then. TAR was alright but other than that and US open, china open, there was basically nothing going on. i remember being on here discussing bonus ball and hoping that ultimate 10-ball would evolve into something.

+1 on the coolness / lone gunfighter. the collar flipped up, the laconic comments and the game to back them up.
 
I wonder if part of the mystique of SVB was earned through the TAR matches and long challenge matches. Sure, SVB may not have been off winning multiple China Opens or world titles to go with his US opens, but he was for many, myself included, almost like a lone gunfighter willing to step in against anybody.

This skinny kid with a break like a cannon blast was one of the only Americans at the time who you got the sense that had an "anytime, anywhere" attitude...and more often than not it was against a Filipino killer and SVB came out on top after a grueling multi day set.

I don't see how anyone can argue the simple numbers that Filler has more prestigious Titles than SVB, but Filler has never been that "Wyatt Earp" type that catches the imagination of many...not that he couldn't have, but his career just didn't unfold where he needed the long races to 100 to prove his superiority.
Yes, well said.

Still, to me, the long races mean almost nothing. Beat a single opponent on a single table over sessions so long that stamina is a huge issue and that's very nice., For many years, most of the long races ever played had included SVB. The TAR table was Shane's home table, too. Shane's track record in TAR matches is not taken lightly, but the long race was his sole domain in the TAR days. It was a gimmick that few had even attempted. In addition, 10ball tournaments were few and far between back in the TAR days and, at times, it seemed Shane was the only one that had really worked on and mastered the 10ball break (other than the incomparable JL Chang.)

Give me a guy who knocks off seven straight champions with seven different styles, strengths and weaknesses on seven different tables in a race to eleven and I'm far more impressed. That's what it often takes to win at the majors, and there is little room for error. Shane has rarely accomplished this at the 10ball majors (96+ players, deep internationally diverse field, big first prize) for the length of his career. Shane's greatness has been chiefly at 9ball, where he has often found the finish line at the majors.

Shane's mystique is very real and, as you suggest, some of it was earned in the TAR matches. He is simply one of the greatest ever, a pool immortal. He is the best American player of this century, and he has captured your attention and mine for his sustained long-term excellence. I am just awed by the fact that guys like Shane, Feijen, Alcaide and Souquet were all able to produce top results against the world's best for so many years. I'll bet even Josh and Fedor are awed by it, too!
 
but really, the long races is the true test of who can beat who.

titles are the true test of greatness.

those who has kept the most money are the champions.
 
Filler is the top guy now, but he wasn’t around for the first half of SVB’s career. It’s fine to use titles and so-called “majors “ as the current metric, but I don’t think that has always been the case. SVB played when and where it made economic sense. He chased more titles later on, when it did make sense. Filler came of age at a very opportune time. I’m not downplaying his accomplishments, he has made it his life goal to be the best. Right now he is.
Opportune time? The greatest lineup of players ever. I agree, seeing filler and SVB of 10 years ago playing long sets would be great
 
Yes, well said.

Still, to me, the long races mean almost nothing. Beat a single opponent on a single table over sessions so long that stamina is a huge issue and that's very nice., For many years, most of the long races ever played had included SVB. The TAR table was Shane's home table, too. Shane's track record in TAR matches is not taken lightly, but the long race was his sole domain in the TAR days. It was a gimmick that few had even attempted. In addition, 10ball tournaments were few and far between back in the TAR days and, at times, it seemed Shane was the only one that had really worked on and mastered the 10ball break (other than the incomparable JL Chang.)

Give me a guy who knocks off seven straight champions with seven different styles, strengths and weaknesses on seven different tables in a race to eleven and I'm far more impressed. That's what it often takes to win at the majors, and there is little room for error. Shane has rarely accomplished this at the 10ball majors (96+ players, deep internationally diverse field, big first prize) for the length of his career. Shane's greatness has been chiefly at 9ball, where he has often found the finish line at the majors.

Shane's mystique is very real and, as you suggest, some of it was earned in the TAR matches. He is simply one of the greatest ever, a pool immortal. He is the best American player of this century, and he has captured your attention and mine for his sustained long-term excellence. I am just awed by the fact that guys like Shane, Feijen, Alcaide and Souquet were all able to produce top results against the world's best for so many years. I'll bet even Josh and Fedor are awed by it, too!
Its rare I have to disagree with you BUT SVB dominating against the worlds best is far more impressive than running coin flips against an unlucky roll or a good roll in short races.

Races to 30 or 33 over 3 days to 100 isnt "long sets" at most its 65 games in a day(which it wasn't) hardly a lot of time for a professional pool player. Seriously, if a pro player is worn out after 65 games they should take up knitting or ant farming.

SVBs greatest accomplishment is his races to 100/120 over the world's best consistently for 10+ years. There's not a single person he played in a tournament all those years that would bet even money in a 2 day race to 50 that would like it or be favored. He made champions look like chumps - not always but more than not.

Anyway, love you Stu
 
Yes, I do, but as I've noted before, the Mike/Earl/Josh is very close, so close that any choice makes sense at this point. At 29, however, Josh will eclipse the credentials of the other two by a longshot before his career is over.
You might very well be right...however to surpass Sigels 100+ Tournament wins including 9 in a row will require some effort...
 
Last edited:
You might very well be right...however to surpass Sigels 100+ Tournament wins including 9 in a row will require some effort...
I have zero interest in title count, only major title count. When talking about greatness, regional events, small field events, and bar table events are of absolutely no significance. It's only at the majors where winning nearly always requires outplaying most of the creme de la creme of pro pool. The guys who prevail over the toughest, deepest, international fields most often are the true giants of the game.

Mike Sigel's greatness is not about his title count, but about his ability to triumph over the toughest, deepest fields in both of the two disciplines that defined his prime, straight pool and 9ball. To be fair, Nick Varner wasn't very far behind him in either discipline. Both Strickland and Reyes called Sigel "the toughest opponent I have ever faced."
 
SVBs greatest accomplishment is his races to 100/120 over the world's best consistently for 10+ years. There's not a single person he played in a tournament all those years that would bet even money in a 2 day race to 50 that would like it or be favored. He made champions look like chumps - not always but more than not.
Perhaps you don't remember it but JL Chang wore Shane out in long 10ball races. It got to the point where Shane's backers didn't even want to put Shane in the box against Chang anymore. I was there in the action room at Derby City in 2019. Chang's backers, on day one of the Derby, announced that Chang would play a race to 50 against all comers, with the condition that the bet be $30,000 or more. The buzz was heard all over the Horseshoe, but nobody, including Shane and his backers, wanted any piece of Chang, despite a nine-day window in which to play.
 
Yes, well said.

Still, to me, the long races mean almost nothing. Beat a single opponent on a single table over sessions so long that stamina is a huge issue and that's very nice., For many years, most of the long races ever played had included SVB. The TAR table was Shane's home table, too. Shane's track record in TAR matches is not taken lightly, but the long race was his sole domain in the TAR days. It was a gimmick that few had even attempted. In addition, 10ball tournaments were few and far between back in the TAR days and, at times, it seemed Shane was the only one that had really worked on and mastered the 10ball break (other than the incomparable JL Chang.)

Give me a guy who knocks off seven straight champions with seven different styles, strengths and weaknesses on seven different tables in a race to eleven and I'm far more impressed. That's what it often takes to win at the majors, and there is little room for error. Shane has rarely accomplished this at the 10ball majors (96+ players, deep internationally diverse field, big first prize) for the length of his career. Shane's greatness has been chiefly at 9ball, where he has often found the finish line at the majors.

Shane's mystique is very real and, as you suggest, some of it was earned in the TAR matches. He is simply one of the greatest ever, a pool immortal. He is the best American player of this century, and he has captured your attention and mine for his sustained long-term excellence. I am just awed by the fact that guys like Shane, Feijen, Alcaide and Souquet were all able to produce top results against the world's best for so many years. I'll bet even Josh and Fedor are awed by it, too!
Its rare I have to disagree with you BUT SVB dominating against the worlds best is far more impressive than running coin flips against an unlucky roll or a good roll in short races.

Races to 30 or 33 over 3 days to 100 isnt "long sets" at most its 65 games in a day(which it wasn't) hardly a lot of time for a professional pool player. Seriously, if a pro player is worn out after 65 games they should take up knitting or ant farming.

SVBs greatest accomplishment is his races to 100/120 over the world's best consistently for 10+ years. There's not a single person he played in a tournament all those years that would bet even money in a 2 day race to 50 that would like it or be favored. He made champions look like chumps - not always but more than not.

Anyway,
Perhaps you don't remember it but JL Chang wore Shane out in long 10ball races. It got to the point where Shane's backers didn't even want to put Shane in the box against Chang anymore. I was there in the action room at Derby City in 2019. Chang's backers, on day one of the Derby, announced that Chang would play a race to 50 against all comers, with the condition that the bet be $30,000 or more. The buzz was heard all over the Horseshoe, but nobody, including Shane and his backers, wanted any piece of Chang, despite a nine-day window in which to play.
I dont remember him wearing Shane out 🤷‍♂️
 
What about is it? Which arguments decide, who is the best player now or forever. At least GOAT never van be answered, because times and the game are changing.
I don´t think, it´s a question of the length of a match. It´s more about the circumstances. Filler´s game isn´t very spectacular. No long backswing, noch smooth stroke- but hell: What a consistency under all circumstances. Whether it´s humid or dry, warm or cold- he´s there. In most of the tournaments he looses maximum one set- in the singles, when many others are already out. He is a very intelligent player, when it comes to tactics. He knows, when to pull the short stick, when to play which kind of safe and his resafe- game is extraordinary. That´s not given, but hard work. And what this does tho others, shows Pia, his wife and female #1 in the world. Both at the same time, which has- according to my research- never been given in any sports to any time.

He rarely complains, tries his very best and if there´s a lack of anything, he works on it. And he probably is the hardest worker in the business.

He´s for 16 years on a top level! He already competed succesfully German Top- Pros at the age of 13. And there used to be many on a level near to Souquet, Ortmann and Engert- they just didn´t travel.

You can´t compare guys like Sigel, Mosconi, Strickland and for sure Efren with each other. Earl and Efren maybe- the battled each other in their prime.

The cloth was slower, the cues were worse and the pockets bigger. Nobody can say, if the circumstances made the player or if he would be able to adapt modern circumstances.

Sorry, if the language is poor- English isn´t my first language.
 
I dont remember him wearing Shane out 🤷‍♂️
Yes, but it was the case. Chang was Shane's nemesis.

To my recollection, just one of their longish races was streamed, and that was played in Houston ((best guess is 2017), a race to 50 easily won by Chang. Their hookups were not TAR matches, but long races played after TAR no longer existed. Several of these hookups took place in Asia.

Many of us have compared JL Chang to the Buddy Hall of the 1970s as a guy who became so dominant in action pool that it got to the point that almost nobody would gamble with him. Lassiter had a similar lack of patronage in 9ball in his top action days. At one point, only Harold Worst would try him without weight. Similarly, Jose Parica told me in 1998 that he had a standing offer for a high-stakes "ten ahead" 9ball race but that there were no takers, which greatly frustrated him.

Never gave you the ending of the Derby City story in which Shane, Orcullo and others all ducked Chang. On the final night of the Derby, Chang gave up and relented. He realized he wasn't going to get played at all. He was willing to play a race to 17 for $3,000. There was just one taker, and it was the guy he'd beaten in the Bigfoot 10ball earlier in the week. In the end, a just-truned-21 Josh Filler, who had no stakehorse, tried him.. All of us reckoned Chang would win, but Josh beat him 17-14. I recall discussing the match with Jeremy Jones (who had commentated it) just after its completion, and Jeremy called it " probably some of the best 10ball ever played."

For me, it's noteworthy that Shane prevailed 13-9 in the biggest tournament match he and Chang ever played, which was the 2016 US Open 9ball final. Shane was, undeniably, the better tournament player. As you know, I'll always put more stock in who won when the heat was turned up highest at the majors than who prevailed in action hook-ups.

Chang's early death still stings. What a player he was!
 
Yes, but it was the case. Chang was Shane's nemesis.

To my recollection, just one of their longish races was streamed, and that was played in Houston ((best guess is 2017), a race to 50 easily won by Chang. Their hookups were not TAR matches, but long races played after TAR no longer existed. Several of these hookups took place in Asia.

Many of us have compared JL Chang to the Buddy Hall of the 1970s as a guy who became so dominant in action pool that it got to the point that almost nobody would gamble with him. Lassiter had a similar lack of patronage in 9ball in his top action days. At one point, only Harold Worst would try him without weight. Similarly, Jose Parica told me in 1998 that he had a standing offer for a high-stakes "ten ahead" 9ball race but that there were no takers, which greatly frustrated him.

Never gave you the ending of the Derby City story in which Shane, Orcullo and others all ducked Chang. On the final night of the Derby, Chang gave up and relented. He realized he wasn't going to get played at all. He was willing to play a race to 17 for $3,000. There was just one taker, and it was the guy he'd beaten in the Bigfoot 10ball earlier in the week. In the end, a just-truned-21 Josh Filler, who had no stakehorse, tried him.. All of us reckoned Chang would win, but Josh beat him 17-14. I recall discussing the match with Jeremy Jones (who had commentated it) just after its completion, and Jeremy called it " probably some of the best 10ball ever played."

For me, it's noteworthy that Shane prevailed 13-9 in the biggest tournament match he and Chang ever played, which was the 2016 US Open 9ball final. Shane was, undeniably, the better tournament player. As you know, I'll always put more stock in who won when the heat was turned up highest at the majors than who prevailed in action hook-ups.

Chang's early death still stings. What a player he was!
They played what was supposed to be a race to 120 ten ball at skinny bobs in 2021. Shane won day 1. Chang took the lead in day 2. From what I remember Chang had a good lead in day 3. Shane clawed back to 115-115 at 6am. There is a picture of Chang looking completely exhausted after flopping in his chair and Shane laughing. They decided to extend the race to 155 and add a day 4. Shane ended up winning 155-139 I believe. I didnt see day four but either shane played perfect or Chang just didnt have anything left in the tank.
 
Yes, but it was the case. Chang was Shane's nemesis.

To my recollection, just one of their longish races was streamed, and that was played in Houston ((best guess is 2017), a race to 50 easily won by Chang. Their hookups were not TAR matches, but long races played after TAR no longer existed. Several of these hookups took place in Asia.

Many of us have compared JL Chang to the Buddy Hall of the 1970s as a guy who became so dominant in action pool that it got to the point that almost nobody would gamble with him. Lassiter had a similar lack of patronage in 9ball in his top action days. At one point, only Harold Worst would try him without weight. Similarly, Jose Parica told me in 1998 that he had a standing offer for a high-stakes "ten ahead" 9ball race but that there were no takers, which greatly frustrated him.

Never gave you the ending of the Derby City story in which Shane, Orcullo and others all ducked Chang. On the final night of the Derby, Chang gave up and relented. He realized he wasn't going to get played at all. He was willing to play a race to 17 for $3,000. There was just one taker, and it was the guy he'd beaten in the Bigfoot 10ball earlier in the week. In the end, a just-truned-21 Josh Filler, who had no stakehorse, tried him.. All of us reckoned Chang would win, but Josh beat him 17-14. I recall discussing the match with Jeremy Jones (who had commentated it) just after its completion, and Jeremy called it " probably some of the best 10ball ever played."

For me, it's noteworthy that Shane prevailed 13-9 in the biggest tournament match he and Chang ever played, which was the 2016 US Open 9ball final. Shane was, undeniably, the better tournament player. As you know, I'll always put more stock in who won when the heat was turned up highest at the majors than who prevailed in action hook-ups.

Chang's early death still stings. What a player he was!
Im kinda remembering them playing - think I bet on Chang.
 
Perhaps you don't remember it but JL Chang wore Shane out in long 10ball races. It got to the point where Shane's backers didn't even want to put Shane in the box against Chang anymore. I was there in the action room at Derby City in 2019. Chang's backers, on day one of the Derby, announced that Chang would play a race to 50 against all comers, with the condition that the bet be $30,000 or more. The buzz was heard all over the Horseshoe, but nobody, including Shane and his backers, wanted any piece of Chang, despite a nine-day window in which to play.
Didn't Filler play Chang for the cash at Derby City?
 
[...]

For me, it's noteworthy that Shane prevailed 13-9 in the biggest tournament match he and Chang ever played, which was the 2016 US Open 9ball final. Shane was, undeniably, the better tournament player. As you know, I'll always put more stock in who won when the heat was turned up highest at the majors than who prevailed in action hook-ups.
Interestingly, SVB lost 11-4 to Chang earlier in that tournament
 
the difference between the best of the best is very small.

and anyone of them can beat another on any given day especially if the conditions favor one or the other even by a tiny bit.
 
Back
Top