Commentary

Flakeandrun

Well-known member
For the Bangkok open...
Said it before, will say it again... Phil Yates... this guy gets paid to commentate... how? Listening to him speak, I am surprised he knows the order in which to pocket the balls...
Had Mickey Krause in the booth yesterday, the pair of them yabbering on...
A professional commentator, and a professional player... confidence in abundance, but scraping the bottom of the barrel when it comes to knowledge...
Listening to Mickey waffle on about his Chinese factory cue (without calling it that), listening to him talk about a player he doesn't really know about (but should - WKL), listening to him talk about a game he doesn't really understand (235), listening to him talk about equipment in general, made me actually consider that there will be someone out there who laps all that up...

Why is it so hard to find literate, and knowledgeable people in the commentary booth?
 
Last edited:
I'm as confused as you.

Pool commentary is full of unnecessary predictions, explaining what the commentary thinks a player should do or what they themselves would do, shilling bs products, and droning on about what they had for lunch or some other unrelated personal crap.

Just call the match as you see it. Some knowledgeable anecdotal stuff about the players in the match. That's it. That is the job.

Hopefully one day it will evolve.
 
I'm as confused as you.

Pool commentary is full of unnecessary predictions, explaining what the commentary thinks a player should do or what they themselves would do, shilling bs products, and droning on about what they had for lunch or some other unrelated personal crap.

Just call the match as you see it. That's it. That is the job.

Hopefully one day it will evolve.
Listening to the pair of them... like tweedle dee and tweedle dumb.
Even when they would steer towards an interesting topic or point, they demonstrated such a bewildering lack of knowledge (and even straight up wrong statements that they then both agreed on as fact...).
Not only would anyone new to the game be misled, but I know for a fact, there are players who will argue about such bollocks, and use the fact Mickey Mouse, or Yates briefly waffled on about it as gospel...
 
Listening to the pair of them... like tweedle dee and tweedle dumb.
Even when they would steer towards an interesting topic or point, they demonstrated such a bewildering lack of knowledge (and even straight up wrong statements that they then both agreed on as fact...).
Not only would anyone new to the game be misled, but I know for a fact, there are players who will argue about such bollocks, and use the fact Mickey Mouse, or Yates briefly waffled on about it as gospel...
I'd rather just hear the sounds of the game than be subjected to 99% of pool commentary.
 
I have been playing/watching and reading about the game for 60 years.
Always wondered if I could do better than some?
Never been asked to jump in the booth but I would not turn an invitation down.
 
I have been playing/watching and reading about the game for 60 years.
Always wondered if I could do better than some?
You could do better than those two without trying...
Never been asked to jump in the booth but I would not turn an invitation down.
Me either... bet my bottom dollar that I could not only do a better job, but also present the game in a much more captivating way. It's safe to say I have the infinite knowledge of my hobbies type of 'tism (...though I wish it was the rig the lottery, beat the casino, mega-scientist type 😂 )

I guess just like them, we just need to blow the right people to get our shot... not much in life comes on merit after all ;)
 
Last edited:
most think or just like to hear themselves talking and thats what the booth is about to them.

the few good ones usually come from older retired players with lots of knowledge.

plus you have to pay more to get good people in anything.
 
most think or just like to hear themselves talking and thats what the booth is about to them.
Right, it's self-glazing or a sales pitch (or in the case of Yates, an old bloke waffling on about things he should probably know more about, but obviously doesn't...)
the few good ones usually come from older retired players with lots of knowledge
Agree. Usually the most insightful, and because they know what they are talking about, actually captivating
plus you have to pay more to get good people in anything.
Just irks me that this leads to all kinds of idiots (you know the ones that buy Predator everything and think they're God's on the table because they occasionally win in a bar), preaching all kinds of nonsense as fact...
It also gives anyone new to the game an absolute load of BS to digest...
 
For the Bangkok open...
Said it before, will say it again... Phil Yates... this guy gets paid to commentate... how? Listening to him speak, I am surprised he knows the order in which to pocket the balls...
Had Mickey Krause in the booth yesterday, the pair of them yabbering on...
...
Is that on one of the sessions on WNTTV? Which one (and time stamp if you have it)? I think the UK commentator is Mark White, not Phil Yates. And in a short search, his was the only voice I heard. The wnttv.com videos are not very well organized. At least one of them is nothing but waiting music.
 
jRvyPa.gif
 
and nothing irks me more than if they have no commentary and put some music i have to listen to to watch it. but i can turn it off and i do.

lets go back to the old days where some had mic's on and the players talked during the match and they were the commentary.

then it was entertaining.

then viewership will go up and so can the prize money which can be distributed to any player that has been listened to. so those that don't cash may get paid something.
 
Is that on one of the sessions on WNTTV? Which one (and time stamp if you have it)? I think the UK commentator is Mark White, not Phil Yates. And in a short search, his was the only voice I heard. The wnttv.com videos are not very well organized. At least one of them is nothing but waiting music.
It was the TV table last night, the match prior to Mickey's match.

I may well have got them muddled up, but no real apologies to Yates if I have. I've certainly complained about Yates before on the forum. Could just add Mark White to the list of IQ reducing noise if that is the case.

I usually watch the streams on CPBA WeChat or Douyin channel - Found a link via. Fullcan (great Youtube streams) - Wu Kun Lin Vs. Pierfrancesco Garzia


Expert commentary is seldom entertaining.
I don't know, I generally find it far more entertaining. Even sports I am unfamiliar with. It is very easy to be entertained by someone who is able to understand the technicality of what they do, and express it confidently and succinctly.

and nothing irks me more than if they have no commentary and put some music i have to listen to to watch it. but i can turn it off and i do.
Elevator music haha
lets go back to the old days where some had mic's on and the players talked during the match and they were the commentary.
I'm down for that, especially with some of the conflict averse man babies like Shaw
 
I don't know, I generally find it far more entertaining. Even sports I am unfamiliar with. It is very easy to be entertained by someone who is able to understand the technicality of what they do, and express it confidently and succinctly.

To players who get it and agree - absolutely. To fans who know a little (me) it's a toss up. A significant portion of the 99% perspiration I put in learning was sweating the advanced matches. Sometimes the expert opinions interfere with that state of mind. If that happens I turn the sound down and go with my intuition. More relevant from the get go.
 
To players who get it and agree - absolutely. To fans who know a little (me) it's a toss up. A significant portion of the 99% perspiration I put in learning was sweating the advanced matches. Sometimes the expert opinions interfere with that state of mind. If that happens I turn the sound down and go with my intuition. More relevant from the get go.
Agree, and I find myself more often than not in the same boat these days. I always give the commentary a chance, but often turn it off. Just irks me that that is what new players to the game (and the "bar table pros") will absorb and spit back in debate form. It also influences what they buy, and ultimately the product and experience available to us in the game we love.

I like when the commentary is restreamed by enthusiasts on WeChat or Douyin, and can practice my Chinese listening skills. The only time I don't really mind when they are talking nonsense haha
 
... I may well have got them muddled up, but no real apologies to Yates if I have. I've certainly complained about Yates before on the forum. Could just add Mark White to the list of IQ reducing noise if that is the case. ...
Ahhh. Yes, that was Mark White. Easy enough to mix them up -- all those people from the UK sound pretty much the same.
 
Ahhh. Yes, that was Mark White. Easy enough to mix them up -- all those people from the UK sound pretty much the same.
There's an abundance of regional accents, dialects and even languages, and somehow you're totally right when it comes to the predominate voices heard on the air 😂
Beyond the commonality of their sound, is their complete lack of understanding of what's going on
 
Back
Top