Is Joshua Filler the best pool player?

Yes, these allegations are well-known. Of course, the performance-enhancing drug use issue has been around for decades in pool and many players share the possible stigma. It's way too big a topic to address here, but in a world where we have random drug testing in all WPA sanctioned events, it's tough to place a label on anyone that was never caught.

Hence, for me, it is not a factor.
Maybe I am wrong but I don't remember those kind or rumors regarding Efren or Earl........

I con't imagine Earl on stimulants.........
 
These questions always come up when comparing past vs present players. My take is if the game is modified or changed to slow your excellence down then you are THE BEST. That has only happened a few times in pool/carom history. The first was Greenleaf and the second was Hoppe. Rules also have slowed players down. The jump cue took Reyes out of the best equation maybe a little early. He could not compete with even the top 50 or so players in a major event just for that one change. He just couldn't master the jump cue shot. Filler looks like the GOAT but it's so close with the others. And remember the Ko brothers aren't playing our version of pool right now and the Pino's have a group of younger players that are coming on strong. So its a great time for us pool fools right now to kibbutz about THE GAME.
 
Maybe I am wrong but I don't remember those kind or rumors regarding Efren or Earl........

I con't imagine Earl on stimulants.........
I didn't say it pertained to all the greats, just that singling out one player against whom the allegations remain unproven in an era in which many top players were believed to have this issue isn't reasonable. FYI, the issue is far from resolved today regarding the current crop.
 
These questions always come up when comparing past vs present players. My take is if the game is modified or changed to slow your excellence down then you are THE BEST. That has only happened a few times in pool/carom history. The first was Greenleaf and the second was Hoppe. Rules also have slowed players down. The jump cue took Reyes out of the best equation maybe a little early. He could not compete with even the top 50 or so players in a major event just for that one change. He just couldn't master the jump cue shot. Filler looks like the GOAT but it's so close with the others. And remember the Ko brothers aren't playing our version of pool right now and the Pino's have a group of younger players that are coming on strong. So its a great time for us pool fools right now to kibbutz about THE GAME.

it's weird to me considering OP was clearly referring to the best player now, not the full history of cuesports. but yea these threads always turn into a comparison of eras.
 
I didn't say it pertained to all the greats, just that singling out one player against whom the allegations remain unproven in an era in which many top players were believed to have this issue isn't reasonable. FYI, the issue is far from resolved today regarding the current crop.
I found MS to be very entertaining and I am just riffing.

I had trouble beating players that were tweaking.

The same guys minus the stimulants, I could beat....

The action I was playing in wasn't big money.

Tweakers do have unreal levels of concentration and stamina at the table.
 
I found MS to be very entertaining and I am just riffing.

I had trouble beating players that were tweaking.

The same guys minus the stimulants, I could beat....

The action I was playing in wasn't big money.

Tweakers do have unreal levels of concentration and stamina at the table.
Without naming names, I recall a top player that played in all three disciplines one year at Derby City and also seemed to gamble every night with a little help from some performance enhancers. On the Sunday morning after the Derby, when I was in the airport, I saw him passed out on one of those vibrating massage chairs. I woke him up and may well have saved him from missing his flight home. The tweakers, as you call them, can be like Energizer Bunnies, but once they come down, it can get weird.
 
I didn't say it pertained to all the greats, just that singling out one player against whom the allegations remain unproven in an era in which many top players were believed to have this issue isn't reasonable. FYI, the issue is far from resolved today regarding the current crop.
it's rumored that a lone seagull flew too close to the sun
 
fairly sjm rates players by tournament winnings. and that is fair. for determining who is the best that year or in history of winning pool tournaments.

and tournament players mostly play on well tuned and new conditions. so that is also a factor as they can be specialized. or not.

we also have to use the test of time factor in. some have careers that only last 5 or ten years or so. but during that time they may have been the best then or even played better than the best ever. but fails to make them the best in history.
few go back in history, and use present standings in far greater determinations.

playing challenge matches on neutral tables and conditions would lead one to give a lot of credit to those who can best all others.
 
fairly sjm rates players by tournament winnings. and that is fair. for determining who is the best that year or in history of winning pool tournaments.

and tournament players mostly play on well tuned and new conditions. so that is also a factor as they can be specialized. or not.

we also have to use the test of time factor in. some have careers that only last 5 or ten years or so. but during that time they may have been the best then or even played better than the best ever. but fails to make them the best in history.
few go back in history, and use present standings in far greater determinations.

playing challenge matches on neutral tables and conditions would lead one to give a lot of credit to those who can best all others.
There's an accountability issue with the off book guys. ( spy movie fan ) The criteria for accomplishment can be considered more relevant as well. I'm neutral - and ignorant - on that issue.
 
Joshua is 29 years old. Here's a look at his performance over the last nine years.

Joshua is 29 years old. Here's a look at his performance over the last nine years.

Best pool player? Best at what game is one of the questions or Best all around. There are to many different games so the question has to be more specific. .
If it's the best all around player ever I'd put him in the top 5. As the best all around player currently playing today I put him #1.
 
There's an accountability issue with the off book guys. ( spy movie fan ) The criteria for accomplishment can be considered more relevant as well. I'm neutral - and ignorant - on that issue.
there was mark tadd, who, in the early 90's didn't apologize to anyone

his backer, John Ryder, snuck him into to Mothers in Charlotte, NC one night and he got Dennis Searcy down getting the 8 for a hun p/game, by the time the dust settled Tadd was giving Searcy the 7and beat his backer out of 3 dimes

granted this wasn't the Searcy of the mid-70's who may have been the best player on the W coast......as far as i know no one went out of their way to play him on the big table, he also played dyno "payball" on a snooker table, but, he was still capable of playing at the top level of most states
 
Best pool player? Best at what game is one of the questions or Best all around. There are to many different games so the question has to be more specific. .
If it's the best all around player ever I'd put him in the top 5. As the best all around player currently playing today I put him #1.
Hmm, are you aware of what Josh has accomplished?. I'd be interested in hearing who has a more complete set of championships across the disciplines.

One Pocket
Few would dispute that the hardest one pocket event in the world to win is the Buffalo Billiards annual event, where the winner usually walks away with $50,000+. Filler has won it.

Straight Pool
In Josh' career, the two hardest titles to capture were the European 14.1 Championships and the American 14.1 Championships. Josh has won both of them. While never really focusing on straight pool alone, he ran over 290 when he was 14 years old and has the highest run ever at the Derby city 14.1 event.

8ball
Josh has won the World 8ball Championship. Yes, the World 8ball only dates back to 2004, so it's hard to compare today's player's to those of the 1990s or earlier, when there was a PBT 8ball event but no true world championship in the discipline.

Bank Pool
Surely, the hardest bank pool event to win is the Derby City Classic 9ball banks event. Josh has won it.

9ball
Josh has won the World 9ball and the US Open 9ball, countless other nine ball majors all over the world and double digit Eurotour titles. He's the best 9ball player I've seen in my 51 years around the game.

10ball
Though having a silver and a bronze at the World 10ball but no gold yet, Josh has won a whole lot of 10ball majors.

Like Efren, Josh has routinely found the top rung of the ladder in virtually every discipline that he has ever tried and has a shockingly compete set of major titles across all the disciplines at the age of 29. Unless you include Harold Worst, an all-time great at both pool and three cushion billiards, it's not clear that anyone rates higher. Reyes, Pagulayan, Lassiter, Varner, SVB and Sigel are at a similar level to Josh in all-around play, but unlike the others, Josh has conquered all of the disciplines by the age of 29. Fedor Gorst is also mind-blowingly great as an all-around cueist and, to this point, he has outachieved Josh at Derby City at both banks and one pocket, with Filler dominant in the 9ball. Any all-around match between Josh and Fedor could go either way.

It's always going to be an interesting comparison between these all-time greats, but I think few realize just how successful Josh has been across the disciplines.
 
Last edited:
Because when 9-ball and 14.1 werr the primary games, Sigel was the #1 player in the world if you scored it by the two primary games.

I did a major tournament count from the time Efren landed in 1985 throughout the 80s. Efren would’ve been in his mid to late 30s. Sigel won 16 major tournament including two major 14.1 tournaments in that span. Efren won 5. It was often joked that Efren was Mr. Second Place, but that would suggest he made a lot of second places compared to some of his peers. That wasn’t the case either. It was the few times he made the finals, didnt win. Compare that to Sigel who won a ridiculous ~95% of the finals he was in for professional tournament finals (~65 finals appearances). This is why. By 1989, Sigel started talking about retirement and fishing more.

Anytime Efren is interviewed, he always points to Mike Sigel as the best player he ever played. Despite Internet, rumors, he didn’t say Strickland or Varner, even though he had every right to say those two. It was Sigel. What he did say was that Strickland didn’t start really winning until Sigel retired early.

Efren’s prowess in one pocket didnt really start to showcase until the late 1990’s, and he is by far the best that’s ever played it. His creativity and IQ shone brightly. But he wasnt a match against Sigel in 9-ball or 14.1. If 10-ball had been the game, Sigel no doubt would be dominant along with Earl. And the few one pocket pro tournaments that were held, Sigel won a couple of those as well. Had the Derby City Classic started in 1980, Sigel and Varner would have been vying for the All-around every year.

And I disagree with some that say Efren is the greatest 8-ball player ever. I think he is but only after the break. Before the Sardo rack, Efren’s break wouldnt have been able to compete with Sigel’s (and other’s) break. I was at the IPT 8-ball. Nobody was break and running like Sigel was in the practice room. Breaking hard, and picking things off like so many cherries like a great 14.1 player would, all the while jawing and jabbing annoyingly. But the Sigel that ended up playing against Reyes in the finals was yippy, nervy and clearly tournament rusty.
Thank you for highlighting this about Sigel's consistent Winning, almost never losing in the Finals. Mike Sigel was the Youngest Player ever Inducted into the Hall of Fame at 35 years old! Sigel was also named the Greatest Living Player by Billiards Digest in 2000! People are so disrespectful and ignorant when it comes to SAigel because he talks a lot, complains to the Audience, and freely expresses his opinions, which he has a right to, if anybody does. Does Strickland Rempe, Archer, and McCready have an Ego, too?? Egos are a part of Pool, and some have a monumental Ego, and can't even agree on a Game!l
 
Back
Top