Originally Posted by sonny burnett View Post
Jay, I often wondered if fatty ever had a confirmed dump or any other thievery per your memory bank?
I defer to you. I'm from the south and fatty sitings around here were pretty rare and probably never happened.
I don't think that was in his M.O. He was pretty much a lone wolf as a gambler and never traveled with a partner to my knowledge. He was out to beat everybody!
IMO he was an honorable gambler, trying to get the best of the game if he could and then win the money. I never heard of him not paying off or welching on a bet.
Fats was an "old school" gambler and I seriously doubt he would be involved in a dump. That was just not in his nature. I knew him to be an ethical but very unorthodox man.
His "thievery" was limited to him outsmarting people and winning their money. He was REALLY good at that!
First they called him Double Smart Fats around New York and eventually that morphed into Triple Smart Fats! No one else ever had a nickname like that.
Not a dumping story but .........
Fats and a guy I only know as Doc from Duquoin, IL arranged a game of 1P at Stardust Billiards in Carbondale, IL. At that time I was the Daytime counter man. So I got the heads up and made sure all the tables and balls were clean and ready.
Doc was a very good 1P player! When the game starts there's maybe half dozen railbirds. Fats asks if any want to bet on the side. Hour later there's around 25-30 birds. The whole time Fats is asking for side bets. And the whole time he's raising the side, he's losing. Handily. Once the side got really nice, the game changed.
Was it a scam? Was Fats laying down? They agreed to split the side?
Or just one of those things.
I'll say this, once I got in, which was late, he started winning. Every game. I never collected from him. Once. He broke me. Literally. I was dumb and young.
The other thing I remember. Triple Smart Fats????
He never missed collecting from everyone who placed a bet. I was like the 7th guy he'd come to after each game. There were around 15 on the side in a crowd of 30 or so.
Fun times, but not that night as I walk back to my dorm room.