I humbly disagree with what you're saying and here's why:
1) ANYONE and I stress ANYONE can play bad on video and have an off day. I've watched countless touring pros absolutely dog it and spray balls non-stop. Does that mean they play bad? A day later they might never ever miss, ever.
2) I've personally played with pros ranging from elite HOF players to the average journeyman pro. I played Gene while on a business trip in MN. He played REALLY well. The guy is a great player and plays at the top of the "instructor" heap of players.
3) Losing to Chris Bartram doesn't mean anything because Chris is a fuggin' terminator. I like how Gene is stepping up. We don't see any other instructor matching up with Chris. So being quiet and minding your own business equates to good business and stepping out once in a while to see what you're made of equates to hurting your business if you don't click like you should?
Just the fact that Gene is playing, in my opinion, lends credit to his teaching business.
One of the smartest guys on AZ
Good post as usual.