This topic is about pool league play. I began looking at the leagues that play in my area. I live and work in Scranton, PA. I know pool is not the favorite pastime in this area. I also know that this area is a pretty serious drinking area in general. We have a large population of college students in this area from all over the tri-state area. I know there are a few different types of leagues around here among them are TAPS, APA, Scranton Pool League. Also within an hour drive of here I could likely find a BCA league as well.
I understand that the majority of the leagues are team based. I also understand that they have caps on the combined skill levels of individual teams. Players are ranked by skill level to implement handicaps to try and make the game fairer for the unskilled players.
What I am not seeing in any of those leagues is any inspiration for players to practice or improve their individual skill levels. I see the direct opposite happening. If a player puts in the time and effort to improve they are faced with harder and harder handicaps. In fact if they put in a lot of time and effort and become highly skilled they risk being kicked off their teams or even out of their league entirely. If their league determines they play at a skill level beyond their idea of amateur. Yes, I know if their team wins enough they may earn a trip to SBE or even Vegas but if they saved their weekly dues and expenses they might be able to afford those trips on their own.
As an outsider looking in around my area the leagues here seem to be nothing more than a reason for a group of friends to get together and drink and bang balls around a pool table in a bar once or twice a week.
I know not all leagues are like that and nothing I can say or do will change anything. I have however heard that the fargo rating system may be very accurate at rating players. If that is true then why have no leagues come up with a system to separate the players by skill levels for matches in a way to promote them to strive to improve their game. Maybe something prize based where the higher level players earn more money or prizes. Making it more like weekly tournaments. It would be nice if the pool halls could somehow get together and organize competitions and tournaments between themselves in a network. Something like that might do a lot in the way of making the sport more popular. If that could be arranged one could have local, county, state, regional, and national tournament levels. It would be nice to see some sort of system in place to promote pool excellence and skill. The existing system I see is failing miserably. The Idea of a governing body for pool is great as long as it promotes people to compete and strive to continually improve their skill level.
Many of the recognized sports out there have children learning the basics from a young age. While most of those children never go professional the ones that do seem to be able to make a substantial living at it. Pool never grew up like that. Most of of the best players in the world today started playing at a young age but did not win any major tournaments until they were in their late teens or early twenties. In today’s generation we have children and young adults that have no idea what pool is or how to play it at all.
I understand that the majority of the leagues are team based. I also understand that they have caps on the combined skill levels of individual teams. Players are ranked by skill level to implement handicaps to try and make the game fairer for the unskilled players.
What I am not seeing in any of those leagues is any inspiration for players to practice or improve their individual skill levels. I see the direct opposite happening. If a player puts in the time and effort to improve they are faced with harder and harder handicaps. In fact if they put in a lot of time and effort and become highly skilled they risk being kicked off their teams or even out of their league entirely. If their league determines they play at a skill level beyond their idea of amateur. Yes, I know if their team wins enough they may earn a trip to SBE or even Vegas but if they saved their weekly dues and expenses they might be able to afford those trips on their own.
As an outsider looking in around my area the leagues here seem to be nothing more than a reason for a group of friends to get together and drink and bang balls around a pool table in a bar once or twice a week.
I know not all leagues are like that and nothing I can say or do will change anything. I have however heard that the fargo rating system may be very accurate at rating players. If that is true then why have no leagues come up with a system to separate the players by skill levels for matches in a way to promote them to strive to improve their game. Maybe something prize based where the higher level players earn more money or prizes. Making it more like weekly tournaments. It would be nice if the pool halls could somehow get together and organize competitions and tournaments between themselves in a network. Something like that might do a lot in the way of making the sport more popular. If that could be arranged one could have local, county, state, regional, and national tournament levels. It would be nice to see some sort of system in place to promote pool excellence and skill. The existing system I see is failing miserably. The Idea of a governing body for pool is great as long as it promotes people to compete and strive to continually improve their skill level.
Many of the recognized sports out there have children learning the basics from a young age. While most of those children never go professional the ones that do seem to be able to make a substantial living at it. Pool never grew up like that. Most of of the best players in the world today started playing at a young age but did not win any major tournaments until they were in their late teens or early twenties. In today’s generation we have children and young adults that have no idea what pool is or how to play it at all.