Not a big strategy guy, eh?
The APA isn't a league to develop money players, it's a league to develop interest.
With your post you take away at least several reasons to have a team captain.
You have to have something like a 23 rule. Without a 23 rule there would be no need
for novice players and with that the thought of developing new players goes away,
besides, most of the novice players are girls and we like that.
Our team, or more accurately the core of our team has been together for about 25
years. People come and go, some are family, some get married and move away,
sadly some have passed, some leave town with work, some just tire of playing and
move on to bowling, or darts, softball, and so on, but for whatever reason teams can
stay together. We loved it when the APA started the Double Jeopardy leagues. Our
roster went from 8 to 12 people and still whether 8 ball wins or 9 ball wins, or both do
we all share the victory, the money, the travel. Some people grow beyond the APA,
some people start that way. It's for development of the game and the beginning to
intermediate player. I think that you might be one of the people that started out beyond
the APA. It's not for everyone, and some of us love it. I can say confidently that I'm a
player that really doesn't belong in any other league, I've tried it, I don't really fit.
I'm a teacher (not professionally, but a natural teacher), so The APA was built for
someone like me. I read all the complaints and some are valid, some are just whining,
but early on I learned reasons for things that happen the way they do. Most of it is just
part of the game, just roll with it and you too can be a happy and satisfied APA player