While we're on this topic, I love one of the rules Earl used when he played Shane on the 10-footer: 10-ball has to be the last ball off the table. You can combo it in, but it comes right back up and spots.
agreed, pool DOES need to man up
players should never be rewarded for missing shots, we should be punished, i love call shot call safety, it's the end of slop as we know it imo
The reason I decided it was moot is because I am already choosing shots depending on who I am playing and a change in the format will not affect that. There are a number of players in the league who will run out if you leave them anything. Of course, there are players who will have a difficult time running out even with a decent layout. I was thinking of passing back a shot that was open but a difficult runout. Also, instead of calling a pocket on a kick shot I will probably call a safety just in case I get a roll where I actually leave the kick safe. I know there are a number of players in the league who will call a shot that has no chance of being made to keep there rating down (misses in USAPL league tend to reduce a rating a tad). Not sure of the exact algorithm.
One comment about Crane. I believe his main game was Str8 pool even though he was great at all games and I believe the interaction between players was reduced whereas in rotation games it happens more frequently unless you are playing at the highest levels which I am not. As you are running out it is all about the balls. When and if you screw up your position, it is all about your choice of how best to put your opponent in a difficult position. His/her speed enters into this decision for me.
Excited about the up coming spring session.
Al
There's one addition to the "call shot/safety" rules they really should use.
TWICE a game the players should be allowed to call a "two way shot," this would include banking a ball cross side, and at the same time playing shape on the next ball AND safe if you miss.
The 'Two Way Shot' is the most strategic, entertaining and skillful shot and it's been taken out playing "one foul" AND this new "call shot/safety" (or whatever they call it). If we're going to "fix" the game, let's go all out to make sure "no shot is left behind".
There's one addition to the "call shot/safety" rules they really should use.
TWICE a game the players should be allowed to call a "two way shot," this would include banking a ball cross side, and at the same time playing shape on the next ball AND safe if you miss.
The 'Two Way Shot' is the most strategic, entertaining and skillful shot and it's been taken out playing "one foul" AND this new "call shot/safety" (or whatever they call it). If we're going to "fix" the game, let's go all out to make sure "no shot is left behind".
I believe it would be more strategic as long as the 2-way shot is called and only can be called on bank shots to bring an element of creativity to add to the entertainment value.
There's another "Two Way Shot" that needs to be addressed. The one where you play a shot and a carom at the same time. This is also a great part of the game and we allowed ONE of these two way shots a game in the Professional CueSports rules.
This would mean that you could call the "one in the corner," and at the same time call the "nine in the side" (this applies to any ball)......making either one is a legal shot.