compare the hits

ock

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
gina tad and prewitt... gina steel joint, tad steel joint, prewitt ivory joint... i prefer a firm and powerful hit with alot of feedback... currently using mezz-zz10... might even consider mottey or jameswhite... please do give me reviews...currenly very confused...previously used a capone pj but sold to my friend...caNNot get used to it... now the mezz is just barely scraping thru my expectation...please help... thanks
ock
 
Go to a flat face short hard ferrel hard tip for a hard hit. Just changing tips can make a drastic change in hit so to compare one maker to another is hard to do .. My .02 worth Bill
 
i prefer a firm and powerful hit with alot of feedback...
Buy the Zylr coco or olivewood for sale here.
Neither one is cored, has stag collars and stiff hit.
 
1 to collect and keep and play...so i only want either tad or gina ...maybe a mottey..depends on design
 
ock said:
1 to collect and keep and play...so i only want either tad or gina ...maybe a mottey..depends on design
Get a Tad with steel collar then.
Stiff hit you want, Tad makes em.
 
agreed... tad makes really nice, hard hitting cues... luverly... but if you're confused right now about finding a cue for serious play, i think its best you take your time before making a decision...
 
Time

Tap, Tap, go to the expo with a wad of cash and make a deal. You can hit with many of the big named cues at no risk (unless you chalk them with blue chalk or drop them on the floor) I too am having a similar dilemma, have always liked Tad and gina, however my favorite has been Ed Young and Southwest, Im a big wood to wood fan. Do maintain the post so we know what you end up deciding on. Gary, aka bushwhacker always has a TAD on hand and also if you are looking for Mottey (another stiff hitting cue) he is the man also

H.S.I.O.W. said:
agreed... tad makes really nice, hard hitting cues... luverly... but if you're confused right now about finding a cue for serious play, i think its best you take your time before making a decision...
 
No good answer 4 this 1? :~)

I really don't think there is a really good answer for this one? As said by others before.

I would calculate a lot of my experience would say, it depends on the cues construction and materials. I have owned and played with several cues over the last 29+ years. I have only played with one TAD.

I have played in establishments and tournaments off and/on for the last 25 years. If I drop names of cue manufactures from the past to my present hitter, it may give you an idea what kind of style of cue I fancy? My first non-bar cue was a Huebler and I still have her. She has been with me the longest a H-13. I had her upgraded to an ivory ferrel some years back. I think she performs much better with this improvement, but that could just be me?

Since then, I have had several cues. I find cues with the SS insert joint and ivory ferrel work/perform the best for me. I like the focused energy of that style of cue. As I get older, I want the cue to do more of the work and me less of it. I like the cue to draw/masse with little or no effort. For me, I find the composite ferrel (ones on old Schon's) and the ivory work best for me over the plastic ones. Currently in my favorite list would be cues made by Richard Black, Jensen or Skip Weston to my specs, like an old Hoppe or Titlist style cue. I like a cue with points, it maybe just mental, but I think it focuses the energy better to the tip of the cue? I think production cues are great for beginners and I have a few, when I want to fly under the radar of the local bar flies (Joss’s and Schon’s).

I find the best way to find a good hitter, is to play with as many as I can (different makes, production and special order), as often as I can. I ask local players and friends what they have and see if I can hit a ball (loan of the cue for a few racks). My friends have always let me take testdrives of theirs and I will do likewise. In time you will find your "favorite hit" and it will make your day! :D
 
Last edited:
this will not answer your Q about comparisons of the 3 but,,,,,,you can start by calling all three cuemakers and ask them what kind of taper they use on their shafts and would you have input when ordering one.

and you will want to make sure the shaft grain is absolutely dead straight if you want a sharp hit.

btw,,,ss piloted will NOT give you feedback like other joints will,,,,that's a given, therefore any comparison is moot.
 
Last edited:
thanks guys for the responds... i am currently choosing a gina titlist or a tad 4 point...will let you guys know my choices.....anyway, this 2 cue has ss joint and also ivory ferrule... thanks and if therer is anyone still selling their gina or tad at reasonable price, say 3-4k usd, do let me know
sincerely thank you guys for the reviews
 
looks like mottey and white is out of my list... not my cup of tea for the design.... and also, i might try a prewitt.... any reviews yet? best regards
ock
 
Ed Prewitt would be my choice. His attention to detail is fantastic and his cues play great. Ed's cues hit firm. As far as an investment ED's cues have appreciated exponentially since he began making cues.
 
Musashi said:
Ed Prewitt would be my choice. His attention to detail is fantastic and his cues play great. Ed's cues hit firm. As far as an investment ED's cues have appreciated exponentially since he began making cues.

Pardon for my ignorance but who is this Ed Prewitt? I mean he makes nice cues, most of them plain janes with some fancy rings but it's in $2000 range? Why is that? Does he make his own blank for his point cues? Where is he from? Is he in the upper class cuemakers rank such as Tim Scruggs, Southwest, Lambros etc?

Thank's
Steve
 
Last edited:
the_saint_siwa said:
Pardon for my ignorance but who is this Ed Prewitt? I mean he makes nice cues, most of them plain janes with some fancy rings but it's in $2000 range? Why is that? Does he make his own blank for his point cues? Where is he from? Is he in the upper class cuemakers rank such as Tim Scruggs, Southwest, Lambros etc?

Thank's
Steve
Ed is from L.A.
I can tell you this, the workmanship in his cues is second to nobody.
Ed is a master machinist extra-oridnaire.
His silver inlays are as good as McWorter's.
The man is a genius.
I'd buy an EP over a Gina any day.
 
JoeyInCali said:
Ed is from L.A.
I can tell you this, the workmanship in his cues is second to nobody.
Ed is a master machinist extra-oridnaire.
His silver inlays are as good as McWorter's.
The man is a genius.
I'd buy an EP over a Gina any day.

Wow, EP over Gina anyday? EP really that good? Hmm, does he have a website?

Thank's
 
the_saint_siwa said:
Wow, EP over Gina anyday? EP really that good?

Even if you find it inconceivable that EP can be better than a gina (i can't say anything about that, i only ever played with one cue from each maker), but you can be assured that he is REAL GOOD :eek:
 
why not try these?

Look at the Scruggs steel joint,Mottey steel joint,and Tascarella steel joint.All three hit pretty much the same with a good stiff hit with awesome feedback.:)
 
JoeyInCali said:
Ed is from L.A.
I can tell you this, the workmanship in his cues is second to nobody.
Ed is a master machinist extra-oridnaire.
His silver inlays are as good as McWorter's.
The man is a genius.
I'd buy an EP over a Gina any day.



I would second this motion.....:) That Ebony one Martin has is AWWWWWWWWW to die for.......off to buy lotto tickets

Tony
 
Back
Top