Well, that all depends on what a pool cue means to you. For younger, newer players, as you noted, they seem to follow the path of least resistance and gravitate towards the schlock mass produced by the industry that consist of man made materials of carbon fiber, plastic, rubber, drinking deeply of the kool aid the industry markets this crap with, I.E. low deflection, ding and warp proof, etc. etc.
Then there’s those that consider cues a collectible item, revering different custom makers and their cues for varying reasons. Some about the artistry of the cues, some for the notoriety of the maker and their mythical like reputation amongst other collectors and players, some for playability, some for their collectibility and or resale value.
Then there’s players, that value different custom cues for their playability alone. That have spent time in the game, and figured out whatever it is they like about a cue and gravitate towards custom cue makers whose cues have playability characteristics that check all the boxes that are important to them in a playing cue and order a cue, or multiple cues to be made geared towards what they like in both playability and or aesthetics.
I can see both sides of it. I asked an acquaintance why he put away the shafts from his custom and started using CF shafts. He likes the idea that he feels he can buy 3-4 of them and they’re all going to play the same, not ding or warp. Then there’s those are those like myself who love their customs and old school maple shafts. Those cues that they’ve had made, or found along the way, that were just a combination of a bunch of different factors that all aligned perfectly in the making of their custom, that feels just perfect to them and their style of play. Where it was just the right wood, the right glue, the right day in a custom makers career where he was at the peak of his craft and it all comes together to form something magical when in their hands at play in this game.