Digiball yes or no??

It's just an instrument. Scanning electron microscopes don't tell you what to look for or what to make of it. All the space telescopes too but there's shit in and out there.

Faux quantifying some difficulty you may or may not have doesn't invalidate the tool or its window. Diminishing returns doesn't mean no returns. Pushing at your margins is how you improve.

I'll ignore the babble jabber of the second paragraph.

Telescopes and microscopes are not analogous to the device at hand. There are already ways of perceiving and quantifying the data the digiball gives. I've never seen anything microscopic without a...microscope.
 
I'll ignore the babble jabber of the second paragraph.

Telescopes and microscopes are not analogous to the device at hand. There are already ways of perceiving and quantifying the data the digiball gives. I've never seen anything microscopic without a...microscope.
It can show you margins and grey zones you can push on. Look what Formula One did for the step on the gas n don't hit nuthin guys. (?)
 
Evolution is the topic. Why go all sarco? It's a learning tool that supplies relevant data. You don't like Nat?

I don't know Nat.

Evolution is not the topic, the Digiball is the topic.

I figured you were being sarcastic comparing electron microscopes, deep space telescopes and F1 to a ball that tells you where you hit it.

Your arguments are inane. Give me a real world situation where the information provided by digiball actually helps a normal person play pool in a solo-learning environment.

You can't rely on the argument that 'more information is better'. That is a trap that third-grade math story problems was supposed to teach you. A blue car traveling at 65mph gets to Cleveland as quickly as the 65mph-driving red car beside it.
 
I don't know Nat.

Evolution is not the topic, the Digiball is the topic.

I figured you were being sarcastic comparing electron microscopes, deep space telescopes and F1 to a ball that tells you where you hit it.

Your arguments are inane. Give me a real world situation where the information provided by digiball actually helps a normal person play pool in a solo-learning environment.

You can't rely on the argument that 'more information is better'. That is a trap that third-grade math story problems was supposed to teach you. A blue car traveling at 65mph gets to Cleveland as quickly as the 65mph-driving red car beside it.
You're just crafting an anti product spiel. Defense attorney much?
Me I'm too cheap to buy one just for the assist but it's still a tool worth exploring. It supplies real data that can translate directly into your abilities.

I always hit that too low or high or left or right yada yada but now you can compile the errors until they become tangible zones you can push on; even if it's only a 10th of a non sequitur.
 
You're just crafting an anti product spiel. Defense attorney much?
Me I'm too cheap to buy one just for the assist but it's still a tool worth exploring. It supplies real data that can translate directly into your abilities.

I always hit that too low or high or left or right yada yada but now you can compile the errors until they become tangible zones you can push on; even if it's only a 10th of a non sequitur.

It seems that the biggest anti-product spiel is the fact that nobody has told me a concrete way that this does anything other than what I've said.

I already have the tools to evaluate everything you mention. I was born with them. They are called, 'eyes' and a 'brain'.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbb
It seems that the biggest anti-product spiel is the fact that nobody has told me a concrete way that this does anything other than what I've said.

I already have the tools to evaluate everything you mention. I was born with them. They are called, 'eyes' and a 'brain'.
Fine. You don't need it. That doesn't invalidate its usefulness.
 
My vision is that players stand and think about their shot solution and specifically pick out their exact tip position on the cue ball by feel and by their accumulated table knowledge. They then approach the cue ball with that tip position in mind and finally hit the ball.

Judging how accurately you matched your predicted tip position from the actual tip position by looking at how the balls move is the only way we have been able to do it, traditionally. Over a long time of playing you get a feedback loop.

The DigiBall shortcuts this process and lets you further validate your tip position with high accuracy. It closes the feedback loop, and reassures you that you are accurate. It also helps you practice the deliberateness of your PSR, and surprises you when you realize you aren’t hitting the cue ball where you thought you were for years.

It isn’t a necessity to learn to play pool. It is a tool to make learning happen faster and to improve your cueing accuracy.

It separates outcome based learning from process based learning, which some think can never be separated.
 
The value would be in communicating with a beginning player and helping them see the clock face with confidence. When one stops looking at it as a solo training device and starts looking at it as an instructive communications device, it makes sense. To a full time instructor, this should be worth a couple thousand, easy. To a beginning player, maybe it's worth something. To those who have any grasp on spin, I just don't see it.

My example in the thread linked above from the test group was that my aim point was off enough (a smudge to the left) to perhaps miss an occasional shot but not enough to be easily visible on my measles ball or on the reaction of the cb or ob. Whether correcting this error improved my game greatly, no.

I still play with old wooden shafts as the error from deflection (or my ability to compensate for it) doesn’t impact my play materially. So I understand your argument that this level of data or accuracy is not relevant for many people.
 
I would also add that for high level players, the most applicable feature moves away from personal training to streaming in matches, where the tip position of your shots is overlaid on the video so that other players can see where you are hitting the cue ball, and learn more from those matches. For example:

 
It isn’t a necessity to learn to play pool. It is a tool to make learning happen faster and to improve your cueing accuracy.
It separates outcome based learning from process based learning, which some think can never be separated.
if i dont hit where i think i do because of a stroke flaw
how does the digiball make learning happen faster and to improve your (my) cueing accuracy.?
...................................................................................................
It separates outcome based learning from process based learning, which some think can never be separated.

of course you can put numbers and charts on things (process based learning)
which outcome based arning doesnt
so of course the 2 methods can be separated
but that does not mean processed based learning gives you more useful info than processed based learning
it does give you prettier pictures and data to drool over which if that excites you
go for it
jmho
 
I would also add that for high level players, the most applicable feature moves away from personal training to streaming in matches, where the tip position of your shots is overlaid on the video so that other players can see where you are hitting the cue ball, and learn more from those matches. For example:

now that would be a usefull use of the digiball nate.... (y)
i only watched a few minutes
how did you get the tip position to show up before nick hit the ball?
 
now that would be a usefull use of the digiball nate.... (y)
i only watched a few minutes
how did you get the tip position to show up before nick hit the ball?

Hate to be blunt but how much more are the players paid for teaching others where they hit the cue ball?
It may cost them later in cold hard cash!

Johnny Archer hit an eight rail zee kick on a bar table covered with balls playing me. All cushions plus a couple twice. Over the next two weeks I tried that shot for hours all told. I never came even close. The Digiball would probably have let me learn the shot had it been recording when Johnny shot. Obviously a plus for me but what would have been in it for Johnny?

It used to be very common for people to do everything they could to conceal where they hit a cue ball to make a certain shot. Knowledge is power and cash. I wouldn't be eager to give it away to one and all.

Hu
 
now that would be a usefull use of the digiball nate.... (y)
i only watched a few minutes
how did you get the tip position to show up before nick hit the ball?
The stream is live but the video is delayed by a few seconds. This allows the overlay to appear before the shot is taken, which is more visually appealing. You can see how it is done here https://www.digicue.net/obs_setup_windows.php
 
Hate to be blunt but how much more are the players paid for teaching others where they hit the cue ball?
It may cost them later in cold hard cash!

Johnny Archer hit an eight rail zee kick on a bar table covered with balls playing me. All cushions plus a couple twice. Over the next two weeks I tried that shot for hours all told. I never came even close. The Digiball would probably have let me learn the shot had it been recording when Johnny shot. Obviously a plus for me but what would have been in it for Johnny?

It used to be very common for people to do everything they could to conceal where they hit a cue ball to make a certain shot. Knowledge is power and cash. I wouldn't be eager to give it away to one and all.

Hu
I don’t believe in concealing knowledge, and I think that sentiment is largely dying with newer generations of players and the internet.
 
Last edited:
if i dont hit where i think i do because of a stroke flaw
how does the digiball make learning happen faster and to improve your (my) cueing accuracy.?
If you hit the exact same shot 10 times in a row, the DigiBall will record all ten of your tip locations. You can look at your statistical spread of those ten points and determine how consistent you are. Just like shooting a rifle at a target.

If you have a large spread, then go off on your own and figure out why that is happening. Come back again later and try the same 10 shots and see if your variance is smaller.

If you don’t believe that improving your statistical consistency matters then maybe that is why your game has plateaued?
 
I don’t believe in concealing knowledge, and I think that sentiment is largely dying with newer generations of players and the internet.

Do you play cards with all of yours face up?

Definitely a matter of viewpoint. I have raced cars of various types. Every team has secrets they try to protect. I can't think of anyone that gambles at games with other people that doesn't try to conceal knowledge. Very very few road players didn't. It was hilarious, after The Color of Money every player that could run three balls thought they needed to conceal their speed and use an alias.

I understand your viewpoint, I understand the video producer's viewpoint, just pointing out there is another viewpoint. I spent thousands of hours learning to play pool. I generally give that information to others freely, my choice. Giving it to others with no choice and no profit would come hard.

I do wish you well as I do anyone trying to bring something to market. As you already know, it is a long hard climb, especially to make it substantially profitable.

Hu
 
Back
Top