Early 1900s Compo-Ivory pool balls with dot inlays

hunger strike

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I collect pool balls. Some are obvious museum finds, with no question of authenticity. Good luck building your own dangerously flammable celluloid factory just to make fake balls to sell. There is a set that could be, and was, faked.
I got this set from Richard H. Lane, of Marathon Key, FL. Rick collected Coca-Cola trays, and came across these for $25, at a flea market. With no photo, I said we can't lose at $25. The set was missing the #13 and one other ball. A guy from Michigan traded me the two balls I needed, and they matched exactly. I described them to a California collector who then started asking dealers if they had any. So old Tony, the master of fakery made a complete set, inlaid black dots under the numbers. Problem was he used Hyatt "Fancy O" balls to inlay. And he inlaid both sides. The real mccoy are BBC Compo-Ivory balls, and the dots are only inlaid on ONE side. I know the couple in Indiana who bought the fakes, they were not happy, but Tony has died so there is no return policy. I post this because I have a dilemma. If I polish these, then later on when I keel over my sister might have to argue about their originality. If someone faked these, they would probably have to polish them like Tony did to cover up any evidence of drilling. Should I polish them, or leave 'em be? The theory going around is that these were made for some large billiard room to mark them in csse of theft. The star cueball is not original to this set. Thoughts?
 

Attachments

  • 20250509_100006.jpg
    20250509_100006.jpg
    240.2 KB · Views: 129
  • 20250509_100129.jpg
    20250509_100129.jpg
    239 KB · Views: 126
Sell them now and you won't have to sweat the small shit.( it's all small shit as long as you are alive.😉)
 
After looking them over, they are clean enough to leave alone. Many old sets can look a million times better by polishing them, but it is risky with clay balls in a machine, cleaning by hand does not improve them enough to balance out the fact that some original patina is gone. Another collector says he has a set and also believes they were made for a particular poolroom, supposedly in Chicago. How they ended up in Florida, only retirees know.
 
most collectables if you clean them other than removing some dirt and stuff you hurt the value. unless a pro does it to restore and restored has more value.

but those celluloid balls probably dont have enough value to try to preserve it and having them looking newer might be better for show.
 
Last edited:
I'd leave them alone. I think they look great the way they are and you'd stand to potentially do more harm than good by polishing them.
 
Cool items. I’d leave them be as things like this are generally viewed as more valuable in their original condition. Thanks for posting the cool pics though.
 
Cool items. I’d leave them be as things like this are generally viewed as more valuable in their original condition. Thanks for posting the cool pics though.
"Things are only original once." That's one of my favorite sayings when it comes to restoring or cleaning collectibles or antiques. Usually a VERY light cleaning isn't a big deal. But when in doubt, I leave it alone.
 
Back
Top