Fuzzy area in the rules can be exploited.

fan-tum

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Example: in 8 ball there's a possible stalemate developing. The 8 ball is overhanging the lip of a pocket, and there's a ball very close to it.The player who's losing wants to try to cozy up the nearest ball to the 8 for the stalemate(assuming no 3 foul rule). He intentionally fouls by placing the tip on the ball and gently inches it forward making the slightest contact with the 8. If he had had to make a legal stroke instead of the push he likely would have knocked in the 8. To me he should be penalized more than just a foul, possibly letting the opponent replace the obj. ball. Any thoughts?
 
I know that in straight pool, some fouls can be considered unsportsmanlike conduct. I don't know if it rolls over but at some point the players morals and pride should roll over and take control... very good question.
 
According to the World Standard Rules;

1.12 Stalemate
If the referee observes that no progress is being made towards a conclusion, he will announce his decision, and each player will have three more turns at the table. Then, if the referee determines that there is still no progress, he will declare a stalemate. If both players agree, they may accept the stalemate without taking their three additional turns. The procedure for a stalemate is specified under the rules for each game.

No referee? You two are on your own if you are playing in a amateur league.

The BCAL has a similar stalemate rule (see rule 2.11)
 
fan-tum said:
... He intentionally fouls by placing the tip on the ball and gently inches it forward making the slightest contact with the 8. ...
This is unsportsmanlike conduct. I'd rule loss of match. That technique is not an accepted part of play, and more than picking a ball up with your and and placing it were you please is part of the game.
 
Back
Top