Gandy "Big G" Pool Tables

Biloxi Boy

Man With A Golden Arm
My quest for a pool table continues. I recently found a Gandy "Big G" 9' table for sale, and after looking and reading, I am initially impressed. (Have not traveled to look at it yet.) I would like to know what y'all think of the basic table. (Not concerned with maintenance and set-up issues.) How well are they built? How do they play? Thanks.
 
 
I did my research. Just looking for more input that is more about design, construction -- the bones. Any table can be mistreated. Not concerned with difficulty in moving.
 
Click on that link - there's a five page thread on them. The consensus is that the construction is not great. Not as good as a GC by...some or a lot depending on the opinion.

sample opinion:
Not even close to GC.
GC's had the Monarch and Super Speed cushions .
Better than any of the K66 on G's.
The frames of G's are not nowhere near GC's frames.
Big G's vibrated too much. You bump a Gandy, you see a table shake.
You bump a GC, nothing happens.
The slates on the GC I and II were pinned.
Gandy's, doubt it.
They were also infamous for warped frames and rails here.
 
These were my initial inquiries:

AzBilliards Forums
https://forums.azbilliards.com › ... › Main Forum


Jun 4, 2017 — The Gandy Big G tables weren't horrible, they were a solid C- to C table but the Gold Crowns are in the solid B+ to A- range with the Diamond tables being A++ ...
Gandy Pool tables any good? - AzBilliards Forums
20 posts
Dec 11, 2009
Need a rough value of a Gandy Big G 9' | AzBilliards ...
19 posts
Aug 8, 2006

paramountbilliardsllc.com

Thank you for all of your help.
 
I played at a room that had all Big Gandy tables. We all thought they played fine. To me, they looked, felt, and played similar to the GC from that period (80s).
 
My first impression, from photos, is that they greatly resemble GCs and have quality wood skirts. Been around long enough to know, however, beauty is more than skin deep.
 
You should check the Macon Ga Craigslist from time to time. It’s not unusual to find several for sale.
Back when we lived in Macon, my wife was friends with members of the family
 
Last edited:
It banks good, I’m no expert but it seems to bank like my GC1.
The rails on this table have been recently replaced.
Years ago I played on a G in Charleston. I thought it banked goofy and the pockets are horrible. I wonder if JZMECHANIC can fix the problems?
 
Small room in my area had one. The pockets were Olhausenish to me. No slamming anything into the facings. It was otherwise more forgiving area wise.
 
All of the Big G's I played on were in commercial settings and were near junk. They recovered the last one I played on six or eight years ago and it was still little more than junk. As noted. bumping them or leaning makes them move, pretty typical. I don't remember cushions and pocket shelves and such but they suck up balls like a hoover sucks up dust.

I think even for home use it would have to be restored to better than new condition. I think the pockets would still play like buckets. I played in rooms with all Big G's way back when. The honky-tonk across the street from the service station I was building my race car in had a half dozen or eight Big G's. I would close up at eight or nine, work on the car awhile, walk across the street and play pool a few hours, back to work on the car. Finally sleeping a couple hours and do it all over again. The only thing those tables had going for them is they were convenient. I played on a few more big G's scattered around. I would play on most anything somebody would gamble on. I can't remember ever playing on a big G that I liked.

I might be wrong after all of these years but I strongly advise staying away from the big G. One thing worth knowing, estate sales typically discount everything remaining 50% on the last day even if it is a two day sale. I could have bought a beautiful Connelly or something home table, nine foot for $200, looked like new although it might have been ten years old or older. 30mm or thicker slate, nice table. I didn't have help to move it and didn't have room for a nine foot table. My back had flared up the week before and I had to pass. By the last day few offers will be refused. That table sold for $190 and I think was worth more than any big G. I think it went for about ten cents on the dollar!

Hu
 
All of the Big G's I played on were in commercial settings and were near junk. They recovered the last one I played on six or eight years ago and it was still little more than junk. As noted. bumping them or leaning makes them move, pretty typical. I don't remember cushions and pocket shelves and such but they suck up balls like a hoover sucks up dust.

I think even for home use it would have to be restored to better than new condition. I think the pockets would still play like buckets. I played in rooms with all Big G's way back when. The honky-tonk across the street from the service station I was building my race car in had a half dozen or eight Big G's. I would close up at eight or nine, work on the car awhile, walk across the street and play pool a few hours, back to work on the car. Finally sleeping a couple hours and do it all over again. The only thing those tables had going for them is they were convenient. I played on a few more big G's scattered around. I would play on most anything somebody would gamble on. I can't remember ever playing on a big G that I liked.

I might be wrong after all of these years but I strongly advise staying away from the big G. One thing worth knowing, estate sales typically discount everything remaining 50% on the last day even if it is a two day sale. I could have bought a beautiful Connelly or something home table, nine foot for $200, looked like new although it might have been ten years old or older. 30mm or thicker slate, nice table. I didn't have help to move it and didn't have room for a nine foot table. My back had flared up the week before and I had to pass. By the last day few offers will be refused. That table sold for $190 and I think was worth more than any big G. I think it went for about ten cents on the dollar!

Hu
No use in holding back -- tell us how you really feel.
I've read many of your comments during the time I've been here. This is as strong as I can recall, and that is saying something.
 
No use in holding back -- tell us how you really feel.
I've read many of your comments during the time I've been here. This is as strong as I can recall, and that is saying something.

You are pretty high up on my good guy list and I think you would regret any money and effort spent on a big G. If I knew of any that had held up I wouldn't have spoken out so strongly against it. I think most of the issues would still be there for a discriminating home user although they probably wouldn't fall totally to pieces with decent care.

Hu
 
My quest for a pool table continues. I recently found a Gandy "Big G" 9' table for sale, and after looking and reading, I am initially impressed. (Have not traveled to look at it yet.) I would like to know what y'all think of the basic table. (Not concerned with maintenance and set-up issues.) How well are they built? How do they play? Thanks.
I sold my Big G to buy a Gold Crown 3 ,great decision imo. spend the extra money and get something you can make play great. The big G will be ok , but it will never be great imo
 
I've had my Big G for 15 years. With the new rails and keeping it clean it work fantastic and shoots great. Can lean against it or bump it with absolutely zero movement, has been a great table
 
Back
Top