It says your brother's stick is from the "Graphite Series" ... that makes me want to stay away from it. If you have a couple of extra bucks you can spend over the 200 limit you mentioned, get the McDermott. It's a real cue, from a nice company that gives a lifetime warranty, has a great hit for a production cue, and for 250ish you can get one of their sticks with the G-core low deflection shaft. I like the Warden model, but any of their lower end models that comes with the G-core shaft is a great deal. If you use english and haven't tried a LD shaft, you will more than likely really like the new stick once you get used to it.
Of course, you could always just put a post in the Wanted section and see what you can get used, the cue market right now is super low and you can get a heck of a deal on a used cue.