Jude Rosenstock said:
When you say this, it's like saying 'I got my new job right after President Bush took office. President Bush is the reason why I have a job.' Now, there may be some truth to that, especially if you are a White House staffer. However, it's pretty obvious this can't always be true.
The smoking laws mixed things up. It forced business owners to re-evaluate their strategy or fold. The fact is, there are a lot of poolroom owners that believe all you need to do to have a poolroom is sign a lease to a 10,000 sq ft space, buy 30 Brunswicks and put your palm out. That's simply no longer true. It's more difficult now and only the savvy owners have survived.
In sum, smoking definitely had an impact but even if smoking were still legal, a lot of places were going to close simply because real estate is so much stronger now than it was when a lot of these poolroom leases were signed 15 years ago. Online poker has had an influence. Nintendo and Playstation have had an influence. There's so much competition now for space and for customers, it's really difficult to create a working product but it can be done. It's just, that guy who expected poolroom business to be easy is definitely having a hard time.
You make some good points, but you are in NYC, commercial space is goimg begging in most of the country. Due in no small part to the
enormos number of people who have LOST good jobs since GWB
became prez.
It is true, many factors are involved in the decline of pool, esp in pool rooms. But I know personally, people whose biz dropped precipitously
directly due to smoking bans. I am also aware, thru the grapevine, of
many other examples based on info from owners, not observers.
My semi-educated guess: the ratio of rooms that have folded or
severly declined in profitability post-ban, compared to ones that have
continued to prosper - 10 to 1.
I would be very interested to hear from anyone who knows
of anyplace that remained just as successful following a smoking ban.
FWIW - Hard Times - IMHO is the exception. Long established, based
on high level players. And more importantly, the population density
of coastal CA. Factors few areas can duplicate.
Dale