Cole was a fearless shot maker and used waterbuffalo. My experience is that hard tips are capable of high performance but requires more skill to control. Softer is more forgiving. 

I play much better with a hard tip. That varies by the person but if we were all robots I think the hard tip would be the way to go, but I'm biased.Could be all in my head. I've been using a medium or soft tip forever. I recently purchased an old Mali with a hard tip. Playing with it I seem to have a better time at pocketing balls. Is this something that would just be in my head or something that might have weight behind it and if so what would be the reason? Thanks!
How the hell does pocket size figure in the tip hardness choice?? WTF.I think this is why you're seeing an increase in the popularity of "medium hard" tips, which offer a kind of middle ground between the super soft and hard tips. I was also told recently that, with Matchroom tightening pockets on their tables, many pros are switching from softer to more of a medium hardness tip.
Harder tips transfer a little more power. That's all.Hard tip makes the cue ball dance. It’s easier to do a lot of things.
Soft tips are for advanced players. You need to have a good stroke.
Both my playing cues have soft and water Buffalo. I switch back and forth. I’m at the point I don’t notice the difference except on draw.
With that said hard tips better suits lower level players.
As for medium I don’t care for it. You usually by the cheap stuff or the most expensive. Anything in between is settling. You by $100 cue or you buy 5k cue. Don’t settle for the $2000 one.
I accidentally installed a hard tip from my small collection/selection of tips. I was really bummed, since I didn't want to go through the work again, so I decided to just suck it up for a while and see. After a month or 2 of switching shafts from Med tip to Hard tip, I started to like the Hard.Harder tips transfer a little more power. That's all.
pj
chgo
I'm no tip expert brother. Far from it. I like cheap black Ultraskins, med or hard depending on the cue. Its all just personal preference.I accidentally installed a hard tip from my small collection/selection of tips. I was really bummed, since I didn't want to go through the work again, so I decided to just suck it up for a while and see. After a month or 2 of switching shafts from Med tip to Hard tip, I started to like the Hard.
There's a few other things in my upbringing that I've come back to. My mentor promoted hard Water Buffalo tips. He also couched me to stand tall, rather than get down on the shot. When an absolute beginner, 1973, I would grab the lightest cue I could find on the wall.
Currently using hard tips, getting down on shots, and play with 16.5oz cue.
I'm no expert like the Gar, I'm just suggesting that all need to experiment.
I think it's more about, You doing what works for you.I stopped using triangles,a while back I couldn't find a good one.the quality,just hasn't been the same in recent years. The older ones where always the best.I never tried pressing them. I done that with elks. you soak them in milk.I like hard pressed Triangles.
Keeps it simple.
They are about a buck apiece.
I think we tend to overthink and complicate the game.
Never understood the idea of a tip gripping the cue ball.
Do tips have opposable thumbs?
I think not.
It is all about your stoke and the purity of you shooting through the ball, even on soft shots.
I think it's more about, You doing what works for you.I stopped using triangles,a while back I couldn't find a good one.the quality,just hasn't been the same in recent years. The older ones where always the best.I never tried pressing them. I done that with elks. you soak them in milk.
But I have found some really nice buffalo tips lately. Hard as hell!! But they play, extremely well.
Your pressed ones,do you need to do any extra shaping, once it's all done?
I was a big fan of the sumo tips. They played greatThere is nothing like the feeling, of the CB zipping of the tip.I like that instant feeling. although you won't get it with everyone, you put on.
Like most solid tips.you got to be a bit lucky. Water buffalo is definitely my favourite. My method is to bite em. If there is not much of an imprint .then it's probably a nice one.
Older members on here, also probably remember sumo tips.I never tried them. But they where suppose to be really good as well. Harder than water buffalo, I seem to remember reading.
On a side note, Mark Williams the snooker player, is known for playing with really hard tips.
I'm with you on the shafts. Too much today is about the technology.rather than actually understanding the way the shaft deflects.as opposed to using a shaft, with the least amount of deflection possible.ridiculously expensive.and it will still take, a ton of work,to get anywhere.A little bit of shaping when newly installed.
I like to keep my whole game as simple as possible.
Still using maple shafts after trying a CF shaft.
Doesn't matter to me what chalk I use at the poolroom either
as I chalk after almost every shot as part of my PSR.
At home I use Taom because of it's cleanliness.
I still think a true lights out player can grab a stick off the wall and beat everyone in the room.
I heard that about those.I seem to remember them being on sugartree cues too.from way back!!I was a big fan of the sumo tips. They played great
Unfortunately, I tend to whack balls around and therefore, miscue sometimes.
Damn sumo would lose a chunk sometimes. That was a shitty moment.
Yeah, your not wrong.you call it a bounce.I feel it as a zip or a fizzing off of the tip. I find the really good ones are more precise.The same can be said for the medium hard.I just find them not as consistent.I've always felt you need to be a bit more precise with a harder tip (This i could be wrong) But that the CB has more of a bounce off the tip with a harder tip.
They last ages and the layers never separate because they are single layer tips.I'm with you on the shafts. Too much today is about the technology.rather than actually understanding the way the shaft deflects.as opposed to using a shaft, with the least amount of deflection possible.ridiculously expensive.and it will still take, a ton of work,to get anywhere.
I use chalk like you do, so it don't really matter,but I like masters or navigator.
Back to the the subject of this thread. At least those triangles keep there shape.once I get a tip right, I try not to mess with them. they will last ages.