Just played in three events down there during the first six days. Just couldn't get the time to enter the last two events despite being qualified. It was NAPA. Very few handicap problems because of the nature of the system which is what appeals to most about NAPA. There were only one or two players that did the minimum 10 match to qualify thing and came in hot. There are always a few complainers around (after they lose) that complain about handicaps but they were good for 99% plus, of the players in the events.
The real problems that some ran into and I agreed on at least one of the issues which I'll list first, are below...
- Payouts. Never been in a major tournament or sport where first place didn't double up second place, and then the tier structuring started there. First place in nearly every single bracket and format, from C/D/E up thru GM, only made $50 more than second place. This was explained by the man in charge of setting payouts (Dean) as a move to keep payouts low so that taxes wouldn't have to be paid on winnings. So, let's see...you make half as much as you should have if you win, to save a few hundred on taxes while still making half again as much given a proper first place payout? It was bad, very bad. They could have simply taken $5-10 per payout and put it into first place money and had a proper 1st-2nd gap. It's why many of the top NAPA players don't attend and that's bad business.
- Many were complaining about the tables. I never did find out from Tony why Diamond pulled out, but the tables were fine. Played on nearly every table at one point or another and only found one that was rolling bad, which they fixed overnight. The tables were fine.
- They had advertised the captain's tournament, at least by word of mouth from my LO, as being an 'open tournament', yet they broke it up into classes, which many complained about. I don't think this was all that big of a deal, although they should address it next year and make a decision and stick with it, just to avoid the complaints later. Again with the business sense.
- Lastly, the venue was awful. The Hilton was great. Nice place, well taken care of and whatnot, but this tournament location needs to be a 'draw' for players. APA and BCA have Vegas and it's because they're smart enough to understand that it draws players. NAPA needs to figure it out and follow suit. I discussed it with one of the committee members and suggested Atlantic City. They need to find someplace like that, or similar to it, and call it home to the Nationals EVERY year and quit moving it around to bad locales. Tunica was bad because of distances between venues and nowhere to eat but on site unless you wanted to travel 20 miles to get fast food. Atlanta was bad because of hellish midtown traffic and having to walk 3 city blocks to get mall food unless you wanted to pay $20-30 a plate in the Hilton or eat out of a cooler for a week (Hilton doesn't supply fridges in the rooms unless you want to pay more for it). It was $12 a day, at a discount, to park in midtown Atlanta. At nearly $100 a night for a hotel room without a microwave and fridge already, and you can't even park your vehicle there for less than $12 a night. Pool players are on the lower side of income classes as a whole and many found this to be a deal breaker. Places like Vegas and Atlantic City are a little easier on the wallet and just a better fit all around.
Here's to hoping NAPA figures it out. I think things ran much smoother last year when Jeremy and Amy were running the show and I think switching to using just LO's to run things this year was a mistake because most of the bad decisions came down from that. Hopefully they'll figure it out. NAPA has the best handicap system out there in my opinion and based on that system alone, I think anyone that ever gives the league a chance will immediately find it more to their liking than any other system out there, especially those with 'innings' and those littered with sandbagging. NAPA just has to do their part and come up with some better decision making when the Nationals roll around.