How Would You Play This? 9-ball

coryjeb said:
Jude- I ran the table just as Andrew Manning did in my head and on the table. Regarding the comment about the postion from the 5 to the 6 and being too flat off the 5 - As long as it wasn't nearly straight-in, I was still able to get position on the 6 by using more "right" and a little less "top" to spin around for postion.


Do you feel the shots were equally difficult or was one easier than the other? What if you were playing on fairly tight equipment (nothing ridiculous). Would you prefer being flat or creating an angle?
 
Just food for thought -

I mentioned that my opponent ended up miscuing and giving me ball-in-hand. This is how I placed the cueball and played the 5. Noted, with BIH, obviously I can put the cueball much closer to the 5 than how one might position for it so I can afford to set-up more angle on the shot since pocketing the ball is far less difficult.

CueTable Help



The reason my opponent miscued - He ended up very flat on the 5 and tried to juice the cueball with a ton of top right. I told him afterward (since he's a good friend) that the key was to create MORE angle on the 5 so that he didn't have to hit the cueball so hard to get around the table. I thought if you were going to err on one side or the other, to err on the side of MORE angle, not less.

Another few important points - we were playing on new cloth, bouncy rails and big pockets. I personally thought since the equipment was going to let the cueball race anyway, give it a good angle and allow it to happen.
 
Neil said:
Jude, I'm assuming you are left handed by your cb placement?? Why not just put the cb near the side rail to back-cut the 5 and go two rails instead of the three? It would be easier to control.


I'm right-handed, actually. LOLOLOL. I thought about that but I felt more comfortable going this way. Perhaps follow and spin on new cloth bothers me a bit.

I wonder (being very serious) if I chose to go this way because I was sitting on that side of the table. Had I been sitting on the other side of the table, perhaps I would have thought differently.
 
Jude Rosenstock said:
Do you feel the shots were equally difficult or was one easier than the other? What if you were playing on fairly tight equipment (nothing ridiculous). Would you prefer being flat or creating an angle?

I did feel that more angle was better, but not quite as sharp as you placed your BIH would be MY preferred placement. My comment on the flatter angle was just because someone had mentioned it and I tried just to see the differences. There is a wide zone coming off the 5 to still get back down table, though there is that preferred angle most of agree on.
 
Neil said:
Jude, I'm assuming you are left handed by your cb placement?? Why not just put the cb near the side rail to back-cut the 5 and go two rails instead of the three? It would be easier to control.
+1...
...........
Edit: Must...type...faster...!
 
Neil said:
Well, if you told him how he should have shot the 4 BEFORE you shot the 5, you had the 3 rail shot stuck in your mind, and weren't open to other options at the time.


Yes, perhaps that was it. I can see that.
 
Andrew Manning's way, endorsed by several others, is clearly best here. The three rail inside english pattern onto the six is the way to go.
 
Back
Top