Here's you dilemma but it's a good one.
For a budget in your upper range of $2500, you can get a lot of cue......probably cues that were listing for $700-800 more a year or so ago. You can can some deals if you find the right seller.
So what's your dilemma? Way too many choices and you're gonna get way too many opinions.
You have to decide if you want a cue from one of the great master cue-makers who's not longer making cues or from some contemporaneous cue-maker and then do you go with an established name or a newbie?
You have to try and place with the cue made by the cue-maker but sometimes that's not possible. Remember that advice is valueless until you pay to get it and when it's bad, you suffer the consequences.
Here are some established cue-makers you'd like........Chris Nitti, Steve Klein, Leon Sly, Jerry Rauenzahn, Bob Owen, Robert Harris, Kenny Murrell, Richard Black, Bob Runde and these cue-makers are still active and kickin' ass with killer cues.
Retired/deceased cue-makers.......I'd aim for a Tim Scruggs, Bill Stroud, Verl Horn, Paul Mottey cue.
And as far a newbie cue-makers, I think you should consider Eddie Cohen who make you just about anything you like. I think he's going to be a star cue-maker in the future and he probably has some cues right now that cost less than your $2500 max budget. So that's your dilemma.........
I went with Bob Owen and he's making my custom but you have to be prepared to wait. From start to finish, the cue will probably be 10-11 months lead time but the design was a little complicated. Cues probably typically do not take that long unless you go to someone terribly backlogged. But backlogs are a good sign that the cue-maker is popular but if the backlog doesn't move and advance, it's a sure sign you're going to get screwed. The bad cue-makers are known on the Forum and none of the names I mentioned are such.
Contact Eddie Cohen a call........do a search for "Cohen Cues" and look at the beauties he made. Heck, you could get the MOP cue he had which was spectacular.........I'm telling you that cue is a winner........I might still get it because it's a honey........if he doesn't have that cue any longer, he'll make you one.
Good Luck,
Matt B.