Old post but a great one.............
The one that has helped me more than most others lately and not posted yet is as follows:
Walk into the shot from behind the shooting position and place your shoulder on the shot line. This helps in many ways. The cue stick will tend to stay on the line when you bend down resulting in a straight stroke. When you know the stroke is dead straight you only have to move your butt (or your bridge hand in extreme cases). For some unknown reason your stroke will be much smoother if your shoulder is on line.
This principle works so well that I sometimes think it must be one of those pool secrets of the pros that we hear about but are not revealed. No one told it to me, I found it through trial and error and studying my own success and many failures.
Joe tho no one has gone into the shoulder alignment, I routinely teach a stance/alignment set up technique that promotes your thoughts indirectly.
I teach it two ways.......the first you hold the butt where you want it in the grip hand and place the hand on the side of the hip.
Now from there you can do it two ways.
One: Lay the tip on the table (don't take your hand off your hip) in line with the shot and you can pivot off the tip till your dead nuts. Then without removing the hand from the hip manually, drop into the shot. The hand will automatically fall off the hip into its proper place directly inline with the SHOULDER and elbow.
The second way is to just keep the grip hand on the hip just the same, but instead of laying the cue down on the table you raise the shaft up toward your face (while keeping the grip hand on the hip) B/c of the close proximity of the shaft to your eyes you can "see through" it.
Use the edges of the "see through" shaft and line them up with the particular edges of the CB and OB...........
Then you drop in.............same way, dont take the hand off yourself, it will naturally come off the hip by itself.
I like teaching the first version to beginners as it helps you to judge the distance gap between yourself and the CB better........once you get used to doing it you can just do the raise.
I pretty much apply a mixture, i grab the butt where i need to hold it and hand on hip. Then tip to ball and i set my back foot. I raise the shaft, check my edges and contact points and drop in when i'm ready.
I like what you said but its misleading somewhat as if the cue is not centered properly in the hand, and the hand is not centered properly in relation to the shoulder or elbow the shot, as long as the shoulder is on the line it will feel smoother? Definately NOT TRUE (just saying for those that don't have the rationale to figure out unsaid things)
Its true if you have PLUMB and level mechanics, but if you kick the wrist and other such stuff its out of wack, like a side arm stroke say b/c the player was well overweight.
When done right, HELL YES you are correct as its helping your body to get into the "SLOT" that it naturally has to deliver the motion straighter and smoother.
This "SLOT" is very distinct in feeling. As most players shoot and somewhat "slice" across the body with the shot as in the typical pool stroke (45º stance) the angled stance keeps the hand somewhat farther away from the hip/body.
When you drop in correctly and everything is plumb, it will feel good but I would almost bet you are going to feel "CRAMPED" like your boxed in or something......the stroke/cue just feels awfully close to your core.
When you get over this "cramped" or too tight feeling you realize its almost stupid how easy a straight stroke becomes and you wonder why in god's name didn't you do this a long time ago.
Its very distinct and when you get it you own it, its always there and your always on the hunt.
-Grey Ghost-