In a dispute -- APA or BCA?

In a dispute -- APA or BCA..?

  • APA rules

    Votes: 6 8.7%
  • BCA rules

    Votes: 55 79.7%
  • I like to watch 'American Idol'

    Votes: 8 11.6%

  • Total voters
    69
So, what you are saying is that a SL7 will beat a SL4 most of the time. So, you agree that both players do not have an equal chance at winning if they both play up to their respective level of play. That means that their handicapping system is not accurate and thus not fair in actual practice.
You are right, a higher skilled player will make less mistakes and therefore win more games. That is the logic in requiring a higher skilled player to win more games to win a match. So, maybe the higher ranked player should have to win more even more games to make it fair to the lower ranked player, at some point you will be able to make afair match. The problem, of course, is really the sandbagging. Because even if the handicap system is right, if someone is improperly ranked, it won't work. They need to find a way to get a handle on the sandbaggers. I played to win every match, and my handicap kept going up. At one point, I was a 7 in APA 8 ball, and an 8 in APA 9 ball. I didn't mind it one bit, untill I come across opponenets who I have to spot a great deal to, and are close to my equal ( or at least way too good to give a hefty spot to).
Anyways, the APA does not favor higher ranked shooters. Because of the team handicap limit, it can become hard to find a team to play on. The rules can be a factor too. When you are alredy giving an opponent a hefty spot, AND they are playing way above their supposed handicap level, AND they are able to get lucky ( no called shots) and get the benefit from it, it can be difficult to win consistently. I think that is why players tend to gravitate towards the BCA once they reach a higher level.
 
Maniac said:
I have a few thoughts:rolleyes: . First off, without the 23 rule, a team of highly skilled players WILL steamroll the field. Because, at least in my opinion, the handicap system still favors the higher skilled players.
Agree 100%.
For instance, a SL3 playing an 8-ball match against a SL7 has to win 2 games before the SL7 wins 6. Now, most SL7's only need (on most nights) 2 innings at the table to run out while the SL3 is gonna need at least 4 innings (again, on most nights).
I think that if a player averages 4 innings per game the player would be a SL5. A SL3 would need more like 5 or 6 innings per game.
Now when that SL3 misses his/her first shot, they are pretty much in trouble already. Certainly after they miss the second shot of the game, the SL7 is pretty much home free. Then, with game won, the SL7 gets to break, and it's not all that uncommon for a SL7 to get a break-n-run. If not the break-n-run, then certainly they are gonna pot a lot of balls early, pretty much putting SL3 in a bad way already. If the SL3 is well coached prior the the match and using a strategic timeout the SL3 has a chance if they play smart.
IMO, the SL7 is gonna win his/her 6 games before the SL3 wins his/her 2 games way more often than not. So that's how I feel the 23 rule helps equalize TEAMS. Not only that, but the 23 rule is more about economic then anything else. Each time the league generates a new SL7 there will probably be a new team springing up in the next session. The local league operator has told me several times that the 23 rule is all getting more teams and because of that there is not as much sandbagging in this area as I have seen from teams from other areas.
This same reasoning I'm using can also apply to, for instance, a SL4 playing a SL6. The SL6 is gonna, more times than not, win 5 games before the SL4 wins 3 games. I think the answer to this is to have another division, with one division of SL1-SL4's ( with a 17 rule) and a division of SL5-SL7's (with a 32 rule), then of course, still have the Masters division.
This I have to disagree with. One of the best things about APA league play is that there is usually a SL7 on the team that can and should be a mentor to the lesser skilled players by coaching between innings and timeouts. I have learned a lot about playing smarter that way.
I'm not sure this would be a feasible plan, with a shortage of SL6's and SL7's in many areas, but it sure would make things more competitive with less sandbagging.
I agree that too often the player will sandbag but I believe that it is more often the fault the scorekeepers of both teams for not marking defensive shots.

My other thought is this: Why in the heck, in an amatuer league set up primarily for fun and socializing, would a player wanna tank shots or throw a game to keep his/her skill level down? Damn, if you wanna go to Vegas that bad, just go online and buy yourself an airline ticket and TYA. If it's a trophy you want, go get yourself one at a local awards shop. It's embarrassing to watch players, who you know can shoot better than what they're showing, miss an easy shot on the 8-ball (or usually on the last object ball before the 8) when their opponent (and always a LOWER skill level) still has 6 or 7 balls on the table. It's not only ugly, it's disrespectful to the game of pool. I'm thankful that I play on a team with six other players who try to make a ball with every shot they attempt (less safeties and kicks).
There are many times when rolling a ball in front of a hole to block or just to set up an easier run out later is the right thing to do when the player can not get out, instead of making the easy shot and again if the scorekeepers do not mark the defensive shot it is sandbagging. And keep in mind that it takes BOTH teams to do this.

No, the APA handicap system isn't perfect. But then it's only supposed to be for fun, socializing, and getting more people out shooting pool. Unfortunately, the sandbaggers turn off a lot of people from the enjoyment portion of the league.

I would opt to shoot in a BCA league if I was wanting to take it all seriously.

Thanks for listening.

Maniac

IMO the BCA is more for the SL6 & SL7s, while the APA is more for the SL2-5s with the SL7s to make it a learning experience.


Steve
 
poolpro said:
So, what you are saying is that a SL7 will beat a SL4 most of the time. So, you agree that both players do not have an equal chance at winning if they both play up to their respective level of play. That means that their handicapping system is not accurate and thus not fair in actual practice.
You are right, a higher skilled player will make less mistakes and therefore win more games. That is the logic in requiring a higher skilled player to win more games to win a match. So, maybe the higher ranked player should have to win more even more games to make it fair to the lower ranked player, at some point you will be able to make afair match. The problem, of course, is really the sandbagging. Because even if the handicap system is right, if someone is improperly ranked, it won't work. They need to find a way to get a handle on the sandbaggers. I played to win every match, and my handicap kept going up. At one point, I was a 7 in APA 8 ball, and an 8 in APA 9 ball. I didn't mind it one bit, untill I come across opponenets who I have to spot a great deal to, and are close to my equal ( or at least way too good to give a hefty spot to).
Anyways, the APA does not favor higher ranked shooters. Because of the team handicap limit, it can become hard to find a team to play on. The rules can be a factor too. When you are alredy giving an opponent a hefty spot, AND they are playing way above their supposed handicap level, AND they are able to get lucky ( no called shots) and get the benefit from it, it can be difficult to win consistently. I think that is why players tend to gravitate towards the BCA once they reach a higher level.

I have been told by several SL7s that their toughest matches are against SL4s. They say that playing them 7 to 4 would not be so bad but playing 5 to 2 is brutal.

Steve
 
World Standardized Rules

Actually, to be correct. The rules the BCA uses are the World Standardized rules that were made from Pool organizations around the world. They are not the BCA rules. Both the American CueSport organization and the BCAPL use these rules. APA uses a variation and VNEA uses their variation.

Maybe a new poll with
APA rules
VNEA rules
World Standardized Rules
Bar Rules (there are no rules)
The heck with the pool game, let's drink.

LOL
 
poolpro said:
You are right, a higher skilled player will make less mistakes and therefore win more games. That is the logic in requiring a higher skilled player to win more games to win a match. So, maybe the higher ranked player should have to win more even more games to make it fair to the lower ranked player, at some point you will be able to make afair match. The problem, of course, is really the sandbagging. Because even if the handicap system is right, if someone is improperly ranked, it won't work. They need to find a way to get a handle on the sandbaggers.

Bingo!!! This is the only underlying problem with the APA (IMO), as long as you don't have a problem with the rules of the 8-ball and 9-ball games.

I have seen many posters on this site say that all you have to do is mark a supposed sandbag miss as a safety to keep the shooters innings down.
But how can you prove (even in your own mind) that the shot was missed on purpose? A decent player can make a miss look for real simply by messing up the shape on the previous shot. I can do it, and I'm not even that good of a player. I would not like to think I screwed a person over on a legitimate miss just because I thought he tanked the shot. Yes, there ARE some shots that you just KNOW were missed on purpose, but costing the person a legitimate inning could effect his chances of winning for a few weeks if it keeps his skill level higher than it should be. I don't like being the judge and jury over somebody's skill level based on my opinion.

Maniac
 
Maniac said:
Bingo!!! This is the only underlying problem with the APA (IMO), as long as you don't have a problem with the rules of the 8-ball and 9-ball games.

I have seen many posters on this site say that all you have to do is mark a supposed sandbag miss as a safety to keep the shooters innings down.
But how can you prove (even in your own mind) that the shot was missed on purpose? A decent player can make a miss look for real simply by messing up the shape on the previous shot. I can do it, and I'm not even that good of a player. I would not like to think I screwed a person over on a legitimate miss just because I thought he tanked the shot. Yes, there ARE some shots that you just KNOW were missed on purpose, but costing the person a legitimate inning could effect his chances of winning for a few weeks if it keeps his skill level higher than it should be. I don't like being the judge and jury over somebody's skill level based on my opinion.

Maniac

Maybe this will help.

APA Rulebook
tnl/trning/defshots8-ball/011300
DEFENSIVE SHOTS IN 8-BALL
Over the years, there have been many questions and misinterpretations concerning the
Defensive Shots block on the Scoresheet. Marking Defensive Shots both consistently and
correctly ensures the effectiveness of The Equalizer® scoring and handicap system, so it’s
very important! The failure to correctly mark Defensive Shots when scoring matches is an
irregularity. Penalties may be imposed by Local Management, Handicap Advisory
Committees, and/or the American Poolplayers Association (APA), on teams or players who
are not conscientious of this issue.
Some players do not have a clear understanding of what constitutes a Defensive Shot. A
Defensive Shot (also called a Safety) is a shot where there is no INTENT to pocket a ball.
INTENT is the key word and certainly leaves room for judgment. This is why both teams
have a scoresheet. It isn’t necessary for both scoresheets to agree on the number of
Defensive Shots. If your player did not intend to pocket a ball, mark a Defensive Shot.
Note: Innings are marked for every turn, even if it’s a Defensive Shot.
Here are some typical situations that are considered Defensive Shots:
¨ A player does not have what he feels is a makeable shot and decides to leave his
opponent in a difficult situation rather than attempt a bad shot.
¨ A player shoots one of his object balls softly up near a corner to block his opponent,
therefore not intending to make the ball.
¨ A player is well ahead in a game or match and decides to purposely miss a few shots.
This is unethical and is a form of cheating, called sandbagging, which could disqualify a
player or team. The way to prevent sandbagging is to mark these Defensive Shots. If
every member did so, no one would bother to sandbag. It would be pointless.
Here are some examples that are NOT Defensive Shots:
¨ A beginner/weak player misses shots while trying to make them.
¨ A player is left with a virtually impossible shot but does the best he can to try to make it
anyway.
¨ A player is left “hooked” (or “snookered”), hidden in such a manner that he is unable to
shoot directly at one of his object balls. He “kicks” as best he can, but doesn’t make
contact with one of his balls. The scorekeeper must then decide the player’s INTENT.
Did he shoot hard enough to make the ball if he had made contact, (which could NOT be
considered a Defensive Shot) or did he shoot just hard enough to get the ball to go to a
rail to avoid giving up ball-in-hand (which IS a Defensive Shot)? This is a judgment call.
Whether or not the object ball goes in the pocket should not be the deciding factor. Whether
or not the player INTENDED to pass his turn to the other player on purpose is the deciding
factor. Missing on purpose can be ethical or unethical, but that is not the issue. IF, IN THE
SCOREKEEPER’S OPINION, A PLAYER DID NOT INTEND TO POCKET A BALL, MARK IT AS A
DEFENSIVE SHOT.


Steve
 
Da Poet wrote:
> How does playing safe make the game play quicker?

I don't understand your question -- you can also play safe under so-called bar rules.

By the way, whenever someone insists on playing "bar rules" I'll make sure to use those "rules" to show how stupid they really are; f.ex, when my opponent's balls are all in the kitchen, I'd scratch so they have to kick-bank to get to them, and I'd do so over and over again. This is also a reason why playing games by BCA rules go by much quicker.

It's beyond me that so many here in the US won't/can't learn how to play according to some simple rules like the World Standard, (i.e., BCA rules).

-- peer
 
Back
Top