So, what you are saying is that a SL7 will beat a SL4 most of the time. So, you agree that both players do not have an equal chance at winning if they both play up to their respective level of play. That means that their handicapping system is not accurate and thus not fair in actual practice.
You are right, a higher skilled player will make less mistakes and therefore win more games. That is the logic in requiring a higher skilled player to win more games to win a match. So, maybe the higher ranked player should have to win more even more games to make it fair to the lower ranked player, at some point you will be able to make afair match. The problem, of course, is really the sandbagging. Because even if the handicap system is right, if someone is improperly ranked, it won't work. They need to find a way to get a handle on the sandbaggers. I played to win every match, and my handicap kept going up. At one point, I was a 7 in APA 8 ball, and an 8 in APA 9 ball. I didn't mind it one bit, untill I come across opponenets who I have to spot a great deal to, and are close to my equal ( or at least way too good to give a hefty spot to).
Anyways, the APA does not favor higher ranked shooters. Because of the team handicap limit, it can become hard to find a team to play on. The rules can be a factor too. When you are alredy giving an opponent a hefty spot, AND they are playing way above their supposed handicap level, AND they are able to get lucky ( no called shots) and get the benefit from it, it can be difficult to win consistently. I think that is why players tend to gravitate towards the BCA once they reach a higher level.
You are right, a higher skilled player will make less mistakes and therefore win more games. That is the logic in requiring a higher skilled player to win more games to win a match. So, maybe the higher ranked player should have to win more even more games to make it fair to the lower ranked player, at some point you will be able to make afair match. The problem, of course, is really the sandbagging. Because even if the handicap system is right, if someone is improperly ranked, it won't work. They need to find a way to get a handle on the sandbaggers. I played to win every match, and my handicap kept going up. At one point, I was a 7 in APA 8 ball, and an 8 in APA 9 ball. I didn't mind it one bit, untill I come across opponenets who I have to spot a great deal to, and are close to my equal ( or at least way too good to give a hefty spot to).
Anyways, the APA does not favor higher ranked shooters. Because of the team handicap limit, it can become hard to find a team to play on. The rules can be a factor too. When you are alredy giving an opponent a hefty spot, AND they are playing way above their supposed handicap level, AND they are able to get lucky ( no called shots) and get the benefit from it, it can be difficult to win consistently. I think that is why players tend to gravitate towards the BCA once they reach a higher level.