Die Hard Justis
Hi everyone:
I am a big fan of Jack Justis. I have had pretty much all the cases mentioned here in the forum at one point or another except a Thomas. I have owned a few Instroke cases (both with and without the jump compartment), Swift (both with and without his stamp on the bottom), Flowers, George (vinyl and leather), Whitten (2x4 Alligator Embossed on cowhide with grey trim, and a bigger one with brown lizard pattern embossed on cowhide with black trim), Porper leather and Vinyl, and a very solid and well constructed brown 3x6 Jack.
In my opinion, Jack's case is the most durable and stylish. My Whitten cases were very elegant but they require very careful handling; unfortunately, they both had zipper problems (which was probably an isolated incident); my Instroke has all sorts of problems although I have to agree that they are great cases for the money if you are only concerned about protections against damage and warpage of your cues.
I also like the fact that I can throw the Jack Justis around and it would just look better with age. The leather is very thick and the construction is very solid. I love the way he finishes his leather. His case is almost like a personal fashion statement--sort of like a pair of customized cow boy boots--it sets the owners apart form the rest of the people in the room; and it gains more character as days go by.
I agree that Whitten cases are very elegant. I think they are prefect for those looking for a custom high quality cue case without any metal rivet. His design is very simple but classy. I owned two of them--so obviously, I like them.

To me, they are more like a pair of Bally dressed shoes--very sopfisticated and expensive-looking--which requires constant polishing and caring.
Design is a matter of personal preference. For myself, Jack's design is the most unique, and stylish. The problem is they are so durable and well designed that I cannot find any excuse to get another one.
If I have the chance, I would also like to buy a NY case just to see what they look like. Anyone owns one of those?
Take care folks...
Richard