I found it to be too messy.Fast tone, you are the only person I have ever heard that has complained about Kamui chalk. I have used it for several years in many places and no one has complained. I like it because you do not have to chalk the tip as often and it seems to stay on the tip better. Yes it is expensive, but I am going on two years with the same piece. I play in two leagues every week and practice at home every day possible for at least an hour. I also chalk across the tip instead of grinding it on the top. But everyone has their likes and dislikes. Bank on.