sticking my nose in this section, as I am not a real cue maker (yet!)
I have been experimenting with tips.
In the past three to four months, I have made my own milk duds and even some made from Triangles.
I traditionally always loved Triangles. I believe they are one of the best tips made right out of the box. I always loved that hard, crisp hit with the ability to 'bite' the cue ball.
I had Snipers on a radial pin cue I played with for a while. On this cue, I had an ivory ferrule and a non, both with Snipers on it. I personally didn't like the tip because I felt like it it absorbed too much of the impact and also 'changed' in the way it hit cause it got harder and harder.
I played with a Moori on a new Mezz ZZ-09 and it was a good tip. It did mushroom a little and it also seemed to harden undesirably.
I then went to Milk Duds and though I finally found my 'magic tip' They are consistently the best tip out there with the most feel, but they are a softer tip.
I played with Super pros for a while and they are good, but too hard. Should be used for breaking. I put on on my flat faced radial pin and it was ok, but wasn't on my 14 thread ss joint.
I also tried Wizard and they are bad to the bone. Nice, med/hard tip and consistent.
I have tried the sharp shooter tip from Ebay's Bob Moss. It was so so. I also ordered a Black Diamond and I thought it was so so.
I think Talisman is not consistently good. I tried an Extra Hard and it felt like a medium.
The Triumph is believe it or not a surprisingly good tip. It feels just like a Triangle to me with a little less bite.
Now, I play with the Hercules 23 layer pigskin med/hard extra deluxe from the Cue Component's website. They are 19.99 for 25. This is the tip for me. It is nice and hard, crisp and also bites the cue ball like a shark. I also ordered the water buffalo Hercules and I am not impressed. I think they are a 'cheap tip'. The Hercules pigskin I play with hits crisp and feels hard, but also has a property that lets you 'feel' your shot. I have noticed they are maintenance free as they are the same the entire time they are on your cue.
I have also tried Everest and I like them as well. I think they're hard and I think they play better than sniper. The regular Tiger med tip is about the same. To me, Tiger tips are good, but are expensive and occasionally, you will find a tip with a pocket of air between the layers and for that price, this is unforgivable.
I'm sticking with my Hercules for now. If I wasn't using them, Wizards would be my next choice.
Hope this helps.