It's an affliction which attacks obsessive analytic types of which I'm a perfect case study. For a descent into utter pool insanity, you can even analyze which pair of playing and break cues just might make you play 2.3641 Fargo Rate points better.
My sarcasm aside, no you are certainly not alone. On the bright side, we help the pool cue economy stay strong.
I know more than a few players who think their new gear will be their savior. My main playing partner, who I have been beating like a drum lately, insists the tide will turn when he gets his "new equipment." He's having a custom cue made by Phillippi.
It's not going to change a darn thing, but he'll find out! (-:
***
In any case, I’ve been playing with a Cuetec at my pool hall and a Whyte Carbon at home. I like both cues a lot, but neither felt like “it.”
I don’t entirely know what “it” would feel like, but I actually have a wood cue that is my noncarbon “it.”
A Players cue. The first good cue I owned. Plays great, feels good in my hand, and makes the absolutely most pleasing crack when I hit a ball. No other cue I’ve tried has matched it, even more expensive wood shafts.
I mainly play with carbon now, though, but the search goes on. I just picked up a Revo, a Lucasi Infuzed used by Oscar Dominguez, and a Luna Nera Sparkle that’s part of the Neils Feijin line.
I played with each for an hour or so doing Burt Kinister’s Six Pointed Star drill. I’ve been doing this drill for the past month.
Did any of my three new shafts turn hay into gold? Nope.
They all played pretty close to the same. The shots in the drill I make with ease, I made with ease with all three shafts. The shots that give me trouble, I had trouble with all three shafts.
Definitely not the arrow!
What did I notice most? I realize I don’t like Kamui Black soft tips. My Luna Nera has one. The last Kamui Black I had, on my Whyte, flaked off in layers.
I much prefer Kamui’s Brown soft tip, however. Took chalk better than the Black and just felt nice.
What else?
The Luna Nera Sparkle is a beautiful cue and butt that actually seems worth the money to me (about $800 new). Just first class all around, and maybe the best or second best extension setup after the Cuetec Duo. Felt great in my hand.
Even with the Kamui black, the Luna Nera seemed to move the ball more effortlessly than my other cues. Not by much, though. The Revo was very close.
The Revo surprised me. I’ve heard a lot about it not sounding all that natural. Sounded almost the same as the other carbon shafts I have used. Not unpleasing at all.
The Lucasi Infuzed seemed a bit “heavier” in my hand, but it performed just as well as the Revo and Luna Nera. I liked the “feedback” as well.
The Lucasi sounded a bit more like wood, as advertised, but not enough to be a difference maker.
I noticed several other things.
I missed some inside spin shots off the rail with the new shafts because each had slight variations in deflection relative to my Cuetec and Whyte shafts that I am used to. That’s one reason why I plan to settle on just one cue and get two of them.
I also realize I like slightly less heavy cues. I’ve been playing with 19 oz or 19.5 oz cues. My new shaft and butts are 18 oz to 18.5 oz.
I feel like I have better control over a lighter cue and, oddly, more power.
Finally, I got the sense my new shafts all moved the ball a bit easier than my Cuetec and Whyte. An illusion.
After I did my drills, I retrieved my Cuetec and it performed just as well as the other shafts.