I epitomize the scenario presented by the OP. I designed most of the cues I own. I collaborated with the different cue
makers but I made all the final decisions. Quite naturally, those cues have added sentimentality. I have a 6x12 cue case.
When I go to play pool, I am never certain which cue I’ll play with until I open my case and just pick one. If I’m playing
for awhile, I will switch cues too. Recently I added a Kielwood shaft and it only fits one of my cues because it’s a radial.
The other 5 cues in my case are 3/8x10 and 3/8x11 joints. Only my Scruggs cue is a radial joint. It’s my intention to add
2 more Kielwood shafts (3/8x10 & 3/8x11) so each cue in my case has a Kielwood shaft to use like my Scruggs cue.
Recently, I have been mostly playing with my Scruggs cue because of the Kielwood shaft I got from Martin at Superior
Cues. It is made by Cory Barnhart and is the best maple shaft I’ve ever played with. I miss not playing with all my cues.
As I get to play with my favorite pool cues, I am reminded about my love for the game and the tremendous artistry some cues exhibit. The tedious hours invested trimming the inlays, the various phases of construction and the cue maker’s agony.
It took a long time to get my cues made and the wait only elevated the excitement of seeing my cues comes to life with progress photos & conversations with my cue makers. After arrival, I beamed with pride over how the cues turned out.
Nonetheless, despite my hands on involvement designing the cues, there is one cue I’ve nicknamed Frankenstein. Not
because of how it plays, i.e., monster cue, but because I really messed up the design and so wish I could do it over.
All my friends know how much I criticize what I did and the worst part is the darn cue plays fantastic, dead on with my
specs and could have been magnificent, but alas, I created Frankenstein instead. But I only see it at the start and finish.
I never look at my cue’s forearm, or butt again, after removal and assembly from my case. The cue is in my hand or parked in a cue holder adjacent to me. The only thing I see or look at playing pool is the shaft/ferrule. I don’t look at my pool cues.
Now others certainly do look at my cues whether I am playing pool or may approach to ask if they can look at my cue.
As a player, I haven’t need or reason to look at my cues other than when I’m in shooting stance looking down the shaft.
Having several cues to choose from is simply a luxury and if I had to pick a favorite, only 1 cue, I’d have to flip a coin. It
is too close to pick a favorite. As many forum members know, I’m a Joel Hercek admirer but never located the right one.