Playing Off the Rail....real vs fiction

Playing Off The Rail, by David McCumber, Random House, 1996.

This book contains my favorite passage about pool. It has been hanging on my bulletin board ever since the book was published. I hope some of you enjoy the passage as much as I do. It's from pages 276-277. It is the author's thoughts while watching Tony Annigoni's 9-3 9-ball masterpiece over Johnny Archer.

"Tony broke, and made two balls, and I could see the table unfold in my mind, and I knew he could see it even better, and would run it. As he made the shots I was overpowered by the beauty of this game, at once immutably logical, governed by physical inevitabilities, and at the same time infinitely poetic and varied. This game at its best, as it was being played before me, had the transcendent power of a Handel chorus.

I thought about what an impressive mental exercise it was for Tony, after a miserable session against an unremarkable player two hours earlier, to reinvent himself so completely. It was a question of heart, a gathering of everything stored inside a man, a refusal to fall after stumbling. It was a very rare thing for a player to take such advantage of the game's intrinsic quality of renewal, the fresh start with each match, each rack, each shot. Nothing pharmaceutical could ever exceed the jolt of bliss that comes with the self-mastery that sort of play entails: knowing the ball is going in, knowing the cue ball is going to stop precisely where you willed it to, knowing that the next shot is going in too. I thought of Willie Hoppe, running an astonishing twenty-five billiards in an exhibition in 1918, seeing all those rails and angles and spins and caroms in his head like presents waiting to be opened. It was no accident that Hoppe was the most disciplined and controlled player of his era. Power over the cue ball, over the object ball, is power over ourselves. It is the sweetest irony that pool has gathered the reputation of being a game for louts and idlers, when, to be played well, it demands such incredible discipline of movement, of thinking, of emotion."​
 
I thought the New York part of the book was great too. One thing I always wondered was why they didn't play Ginky. I know he is a world beater and all, but I just figured they would've given him a try since they had traveled across the entire country looking for action. Was Ginky at the top of his game when this trip occured or was he still growing as a player?


Been around Danny Green a little bit too...I thought the descriptions of him were dead on.
 
I thought the New York part of the book was great too. One thing I always wondered was why they didn't play Ginky. I know he is a world beater and all, but I just figured they would've given him a try since they had traveled across the entire country looking for action. Was Ginky at the top of his game when this trip occured or was he still growing as a player?


Been around Danny Green a little bit too...I thought the descriptions of him were dead on.

Ginky was near the top of his game and remember they had seen his picture and high run posted at Amsterdam. Tony would have been a 2-1 dog to Ginky at that time imho.
 
I thought the New York part of the book was great too. One thing I always wondered was why they didn't play Ginky. I know he is a world beater and all, but I just figured they would've given him a try since they had traveled across the entire country looking for action. Was Ginky at the top of his game when this trip occured or was he still growing as a player?


Been around Danny Green a little bit too...I thought the descriptions of him were dead on.


He didn't play Ginky because Ginky probably wasn't there. I remember when this book came out and everyone was asking Ginky about the New York chapter and Ginky said something like "supposedly I was there". Ginky wasn't quite at the top of his game at that point, Tony Robles was still top dog in NYC then. The book took place around 1992-1993 and Ginky really peaked from 1997-2000.
 
He didn't play Ginky because Ginky probably wasn't there. I remember when this book came out and everyone was asking Ginky about the New York chapter and Ginky said something like "supposedly I was there". Ginky wasn't quite at the top of his game at that point, Tony Robles was still top dog in NYC then. The book took place around 1992-1993 and Ginky really peaked from 1997-2000.

I remember around that time, Tony Robles writing a column somewhere saying he had lost 10 straight matches to Ginky and might not have ever even beaten him to that point. It was well before 97 without a doubt.

so after reading that article by Tony i went to Chelsea for the weekly tournament which i believe was a race to 9. Tony was up 8-1 on Ginky. Final score 9-8 Ginky. My memory is that TR didnt beat Ginky for another 6months after that. Then Rodney came to town for a while and drilled Ginky, knocking down his confidence a bit and then TR finally started winning his share.

The above is 100% unverifed but thats how i remember it.
 
I remember around that time, Tony Robles writing a column somewhere saying he had lost 10 straight matches to Ginky and might not have ever even beaten him to that point. It was well before 97 without a doubt.

so after reading that article by Tony i went to Chelsea for the weekly tournament which i believe was a race to 9. Tony was up 8-1 on Ginky. Final score 9-8 Ginky. My memory is that TR didnt beat Ginky for another 6months after that. Then Rodney came to town for a while and drilled Ginky, knocking down his confidence a bit and then TR finally started winning his share.

The above is 100% unverifed but thats how i remember it.

You may be right about Ginky going on a hot streak and beating Robles for awhile but I still think Robles was the better player still. I remember a tri-state event at Amsterdam West in the fall of 1994 and Ginky was playing Robles in the semi-final and the general consensus amongst the "A" players was that It would be a close match but that Robles was the slight favorite. Ginky ended up winning the match (hill-hill) and I clearly remember him letting out a huge roar that startled several people, it seemed unlike Ginky to do that. It was like he was thrilled to beat Tony, He then lost to Rodney Morris in the final. Either way he was quite a bit away from what he would eventually become. As late as 1996 he was still getting the 6 from a lot of top pros, but by 1999 they weren't spotting him anything.
 
Some of Ginky's early titles-
1991 Massachusetts State Champion
1994 Rhode Island State Champion
1994 Fifth Annual Ocean State Championship
1995 Rhode Island State Champion
1995 Sixth Annual Ocean State Championship
 
I don't know where my copy of Playing Off the Rail is, so I'm going on memory about some of the stories concerning the Southern California visit.

The part about the room owner in Oxnard refusing to match up is most certainly true. For the longest time he was known to match up with nearly anyone but after taking too many loses, he dodged a lot of traveling players. A few months before Tony got there, a friend and I were on the road in Oxnard and we got a similar response.

The big-money games in Hard Times, on Big Bertha, with all the Mexican players, is also very likely. Those boys liked to bet it up.

I ran into Tony during his Southern California visit. I didn't recognize him but he looked somewhat familiar to me. We were at a bar near Huntington Beach and he asked me to play. I'm sure the locals pointed me out as a guy who would step up and play. I turned him down only because I was busted. Good thing because Tony would've had an easy time with me. But then again, I could've been immortalized in print as being another of Tony's victims. :grin:

The part about Waterdog getting 100 bucks to stay quiet was likely true, even though he may not admit it. There was no reason to own up to this because the locals would be unhappy to learn about him accepting hush money.
 
Tony and I are good friends and have been for a long time. Basically everything in the book happened, but maybe not exactly as depicted. Let's just call it "writer's liberties". I would call the book 90% accurate and 10% embellished. Look, even in my own book Pool Wars I didn't always get my dates and locations 100% accurate. The passage of time blurs the memories. :sorry:

I like the part about Tony ducking Ginky, he wanted NO PART of him, nice to show some heart...
 
Lemke-Annigoni

I watched almost the entire Kamikazee Bob and Boy George match. I recall Bob playing like a fool and losing 10/11 sets for 2000 a pop. Got the 7 out I think but he was drunk and couldn't make any shot over a foot long.

Bob backed Louis Lemke against Annigoni after that and lost in record time on a table with huge pockets and weird rolls. Another 5500.

I had free drink tickets so I just chilled and drank Heineken and watched Bob get fleeced. Great hustle job by Boy George- he even gave him a card with his phone # when they were done in case Bob wanted to play again lol.

I was there in the evening watching the Lemke-Annigoni match. It seemed like a grudge match for Tony, because I think someone said Lemke owed him $500 for some time, and hadn't paid him back. I was sitting there with a friend when it started, and it went back and forth for a while. My friend said it looked like it was gonna be a long match, and headed for his bed in the hotel. After he left, Tony started making 9-balls by combos, on the snap, and Lemke kinda lost it.
It wasn't more than 1/2 hour later that Tony got to 10 ahead; and as he shot the last 9 ball in, he said to Lemke, "C'mon, let's roll it over and play for TEN...." Lemke said no, and that was that...
 
Literary ability

That post of "AtLarge's" (post #21) is a good example of McCumber's literary abilities...
 
That post of "AtLarge's" (post #21) is a good example of McCumber's literary abilities...

Yes, I think it's beautiful writing. (And you're the only one to even comment on it so far!)

beauty ... heart ... renewal -- it's all there in two brief paragraphs.
 
My first Goose sighting was at Reds first or second year. I remember him playing Fat Randy on a box with the big cue ball, I even think the cops raided the place during his "MARATON" match, I think they played 45-56 hours straight, can't remember, but it was a looooooooooooooooooooooooooooG match, the Goose eventually won, chemical warfare one would think....at its finest, with two guys that knew how to take care of business on the box, I think Benny was wearing a white/black outfit at the time, kinda looked like the Penguin in batman. I would put the Goose on the top of the entertainment/player list, right up there with Ronnie Allen/Ether/St Louie....He sure could tell it like "he" saw it....from the Gooses point of perspective, which was Very entertaining. He was the only player in a tournament that ever walked out on me during a match, it was at the McDermott Masters in Vegas, since I'm 6'6" and can reach most shots, I took an up/down length of table cut, Rempe thin, made it, ran out (we're on the winners side) the Goose was so discusted, not that I made it but because I took the shot then ran out. He left the event, didn't even play his next match on the losers, I'm sure he had better action elsewhere.


Nice post Bill, but Goose and Geese are two different guys:

Goose - Benny Conway
Geese - Mike Gerace
 
Last edited:
Absolutely some of the best writing I've ever read, pool book or not. I've read it twice and will probably read it again in a couple of years.
 
The account of the Northern Ohio tournaments and the players was pretty accurate.

Gary Speath's description as a player and gambler were dead on. Gary's backer Dave M. (a friend of mine from SouthEast Indiana near Cincinnati) took Gary to Europe for some matches and made some good scores there.
Just like the book stated.
 
Back
Top