My first Instroke case was one of the originals, it was a Buffalo. My main problem with that case, which I voiced to JB when we met in Vegas, was the length. I had a Paul Mottey that was 58.5 inches and it was a just fit in that case. I bought another buffalo case about a year or so ago, not knowing they had been sold to the Chinese. My first impression of the case was that the leather seemed........different. I can't explain it......but not in a bad way, just not the same as my old case. I currently have 59 inch cues and they fit in with plenty of room to spare. The tubes don't seem to be any different than the one I had before. The butt and shafts are held in snug but not tight. I've heard that latches have broken off of the Chinese cases but I have to be a bit skeptical of that and ask "What in the hell are these people doing to their cases that the latches break?"
Anyway, I've had both versions of the case and to be honest, I can't really tell a difference. Only thing really different is that my cues have no problems fitting now so I guess I'd have to say I prefer the one I have now.
MULLY