berlowmj said:
How valid is his claim that the pros use the 2nd ball break almost exclusively? How seriously should I study the book in general?
I do not recall saying that the pros used the 2nd ball break almost exclusively.
When I was active in the 70s and 80s very few pros or good shortstops had any idea of how to play 8-ball on bar tables (they were all 9–ball players). They played like rank amateurs who could cut a ball backwards from rail to rail. Their entire strategy was to run out every time they came to the table which is a good path to bankruptcy on a bar box.
Straight shooting is important, but figuring patterns and using safety play effectively is what wins in bar table play. I made games with pros because they didn't have a clue. You would be amazed at some of the laser straight shooters who went down in flames because they could not figure 8-ball patterns on a bar box.
It was amusing and profitable to watch them run down to the last ball or two and then sputter and burn just like a beginner.
Eight ball on a bar table is much more unforgiving than 9-ball. A little mistake can derail the finest plan with no hope of recovery. Position accuracy and choosing the right shots is critical.
Years ago there were only a handful of really good bar table 8-ball players (Bunny Rogoff was one the best and "Mexican Joe" Salazar was top drawer). With few exceptions the others were just poke and hope shooters. That includes many who won titles in other games.
From what I saw on the IPT tour about half of the players still do not know how to play topflight 8-ball (even on big tables which is easier). In fact, Rodney Morris finished 2nd to Efren Reyes (in Reno) because he violated the strategy of 8–ball and let a substantial lead slip away from him. Morris GAVE the match away with over aggressive play (like 2 or 3 scratches on the break) and poor shot selection at the end of the match.
One reason I wrote the book is that I got tired of watching idiots play a crude version of 8-ball.
R Givens