shaft with sugar lines

Schwinn

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I just bought a beautiful cue and one of the shafts has a couple of sugar lines in it. One is quite large and I find it distracting so I prefer to play with the other shaft.

To our esteemed cuemakers, does the presence of sugar lines/marks make the shaft less desirable in terms of playability or is it just cosmetic? I was curious what the wood experts think.
 
Mostly cosmetic is probably the general thought on this, I tend to aggree with that also. I've hit with some pretty good shafts that wouldn't be easy to sell solely due to the bad looks. It doesn't phase me, I can use them all day long as long as the hit good, but alot of people are more woried about the looks.

I guess It can take away from the overall look of a cue too, unless there was some elements in the handle to tie them together, then maybe they would atleast match each other:D
 
Chris Byrne said:
It is just cosmetic. Just curious, is it right by the ferrule?

Not really...it starts about 9" from the ferrule and is 1.25" in length. It's really only one mark now that I look at it.
Thanks for the quick feedback gentlemen.
 
sugar MARKS on a shaft go in the burner...but short, think lines I'll let go for break or jump shafts...
 
Suger marks are small reddish brown needle or hair looking things, and when cut through the center can be a squigly looking line that is the same color. I find these no problem at all, not even asthetically. Shafts are made of sugar maple, and therefore if it has no sugar signs in the wood it's possibly something to worry about. Shafts that show good sugar is a sign of a healthy tree, and therefore a resiliant & stable piece of wood. Vacuum drying the wood cooks the suger out of the wood, leaving it very white & clean looking. In this circumstance, which is becoming common nowadays, it's making it extremely tough to identify unhealthy wood because it looks exactly the same as the healthy stuff. Vacuum drying makes for "pretty" shafts but I still prefer the traditional kiln dried wood.

The ugly marks that are distracting are mineral marks. They can be green or black or very dark brown. They are very pronounced & stand out. They are distracting even for me, who actually prefers ugly brown shaft wood. The mineral stain comes from the tree growing in mineral rich soil. Often times people get the two types of marks mixed up, and call everything a sugar stain. But actually the sugar stains are light brown/red & the mineral marks are dark colored & blotchy.
 
If it's only one mark, try turning the shaft 180 degrees to get it out of the line of sight, and play on, as the only problem with them is the eye catching distraction it can cause when lining up a shot. Otherwise, they play the same.
Dave
 
Dave38 said:
If it's only one mark, try turning the shaft 180 degrees to get it out of the line of sight, and play on, as the only problem with them is the eye catching distraction it can cause when lining up a shot. Otherwise, they play the same.
Dave
When you are shooting why are you looking at the shaft???#$%!#@$%
 
Schwinn said:
I just bought a beautiful cue and one of the shafts has a couple of sugar lines in it. One is quite large and I find it distracting so I prefer to play with the other shaft.

To our esteemed cuemakers, does the presence of sugar lines/marks make the shaft less desirable in terms of playability or is it just cosmetic? I was curious what the wood experts think.
It is just cosmetic.
 
Back
Top