Surly said:
Well. In answer to my own question, and hopefully to help others who may be searching for ways to remove chalk stains from their shafts and make them silky smooth;
After using the routine in post 1, where I use a Mr. Clean Magic Eraser with water squeezed completely out and then a rough rub-down with a cotton towel; I used a square cut from a brown paper bag and burnished until hot, which only took about 30 seconds, and Wow. It's soft and smooth as a baby's butt.
Although I would like to find out exactly how to prepare a ME with denatured alcohol... Even with the water completely squeezed out of the ME, it still leaves the surface raggedy = not good.
It should be a while before you use the ME again...it is not an 'everyday' method for cleaning your shaft, and will cause damage if you overuse it. With that said....
...after I use the ME with water squeezed entirely out, I wipe down with a towel or microfiber cloth to catch the water. I then immediately wipe the shaft down with a rag and some 91% isopropyl rubbing alcohol...obviously, squeeze the excess out before wiping. The alcohol will help to extract what moisture is still left behind in the grain of the shaft wood from the ME and water. Immediately wipe down again with a towel or microfiber cloth.
Then, use the finest grit sandpaper you can find...and gently sand the shaft until it feels smooth. The roughness you are feeling is likely where the grain has raised in the wood....usually on the 'spine' of the shaft. Once the shaft feels smooth from sanding, I again wipe down with a cloth, to help remove any of the wood particles (dust) from sanding.
It is at this point that you can apply a sealer or conditioner treatment or wax. For me, I generally use a Q-Whiz after sanding. At that time, if I have it, I will apply SlipStic to the shaft, allow it to sit for a few minutes, and then burnish with a leather burnisher until the shaft is like glass.
Another option, and one I tried on an older shaft, is after I used the Q-Whiz, I burnished up the shaft with leather or a brown paper bag. I then, and this may be a no-no but, I super quickly burnish with a sheet of wax paper, giving it a very fine layer of wax, and making the shaft super slick. I have not experienced any negative results on this older shaft as a result. By burnishing first, you are sealing the wood up with the heat and friction, so, in theory, very little of the wax from the paper should be entering the grain, but rather sitting on top of it.
As far as keeping the chalk off...I keep a microfiber towel with me at all times, and wipe down my shaft frequently during play. This usually does the trick....that and clean hands. As to switching to brown chalk....I used to use it, until I found that while it may not be as noticeable on the shaft as the blue, it most certainly does make your shaft just as nasty dirty, if not more so...not to mention, it will stain a ferrule and can be extremely difficult to remove the stain, even with ME.
Lisa