I have found this to be a very interesting thread. But, it lacks pictures, so I thought I'd add some. This situation came up for me last Sun. nite at the local tourn. Bar box Diamonds, race to three, alt. break. I was playing another A player, and he had me down 2-0. I tied it up 2-2 and it was my break. I made the one on the break, and then faced this scenario. The 2 is very easily cut into the corner. But, you will run into the 4 doing so. I need to get right on the 3 to be able to get back on the 4 which should stay in the general vicinity it now is after hitting the 9.
The trick to it is this- I have to hit the 4 thin enough to be able to spin off it two rails to get on the 3. After much studying of it, I determined that I had a very fine line in which to hit the 4 properly. Too full on the 4 and I have no shot on the 3. So, what do I do here?
Did you have enough room to thin the 2 on the left side, and go 2 rails behind the 3-8? (Or was it a dead scratch?)
Even if you make the 2 and 3, it looks like the 9 occupies a large part of the area to land on the 4 ball....and it's hard to get to the 5 ball from THERE....what an ugly layout.