I will have to disagree on this.
For one, i think you are generalizing the situation.
The world class 14.1 player that Steve and myself were referring to used to practice straight pool all the time.
There are times where he would peel off 60's 70's and 80's, and miss and set up the break shot again, to miss it. Then set it up again, and break, and run like 10 balls and the balls wouldn't cooperate with him, and he'd get into trouble, and then he would lose his concentration for a while and perform poorly throughout that whole time. Then, he would pull it together and return to form, or he would be in the tank, and quit for the day.
If you are talking about a hack, then i will agree that 3's and 10's are basically the best they can do, with the occasional higher run.
But if you are talking about higher level players, 3's and 10's happen when they can't concentrate, or just don't care, or aren't disciplined enough to play the proper way when they know how to.
But i will agree that experienced players know how to work the stack much better then people who have no clue about straight pool, and therefore can generate higher runs more consistently as a result.
Just like the other day. The missed break shots and the low ball runs are not a result of not knowing the game. I know exactly why they happened. And i know that after the initial run, which had ALL of my attention, i started to hit the break shot too hard, and as a result, would send the balls apart, and watch them come clustered back together, or would end uptable with some long off angle shot, or would just tie myself up with lots of stuff all along the rails.
Sure i could have hit the balls a little softer, but i didn't. That's my whole point.
I also know that i do not always have the discipline to take the right shot all the time, despite knowing what the right shot is. That is something i am lacking. Hence, my first question in an effort to maybe identify with something someone said, that might straighten my mind out.
Cut to yesterday. Was up at 4 in the morning, and at the pool hall at 5pm very fatigued, figuring to find some of that enrichment Steve was talking about and see if it just hit me or something.
Mind you, this is all happening on triple shimmed pockets. I'm not sure of the measurements, but it's the tightest table in the room where 2 balls don't fit in the mouth, and everyone usually uses them for one pocket. When the table is worn, balls have been known to go down the rail, and STILL not fall in.
Just to give you an idea.
So anyway, after getting warmed up, i got to 28, before i broke the balls too hard, and got into trouble 2 shots later.
Then it was a couple runs less then 20, then a couple of turkeys thrown in there, and then i got to 34, and this guy who comes in there for league, who i have played tons of times over the years in the handicap tournament, walks up to me, and starts to critique my patterns while i am playing. (INSTANT FRUSTRATION) as i feel a certain responsibility to people in the room, to answer questions they may have about the game, etc. etc., but right there, i am in the tank. The guy is annoying the crap out of me, and comments on how i should hit a certain shot with a certain english, and i am toast at that point.
He's a nice enough guy, but i really want to strangle him because it's hard enough for me to focus, yet now i have to do it with a critic in my ear.
So i miss, and he feels the need to explain what i did wrong, when this guy can't make 2 balls in a row. Typical.
So at that point, i am just shaking my head.
So i go back to crushing the balls and not getting anywhere, repeatedly, and then i settle down again, and am halfway into the 3rd rack of a run, when another person comes up and asks me about why i am playing straight pool. etc. etc.
Again it gets annoying.
And then, finally, someone comes up and is talking about me and if i'm causing trouble on the forums (i love to argue) and we chat for a bit, but again, i am distracted, despite that being kind of funny.
Basically, all of those encounters were harmless.
It is up to me to deal with them and not be affected by them, but undoubtedly, they take away my focus, and i misjudge either the shot, or the speed, and it's back to square 1.
So for some of us, it's not about being a hack, but instead, it's about losing ones mind. Once the concentration is gone, so are the patterns, the speed, and the correct choices.
It's about holding onto that focus so one can try to do better then the 1 and done.
Maybe i should address the practicing in privacy issue in another thread.