What should I expect for $1200.00

Burtus

Livin like I mean it!
Silver Member
A little long...sorry.
Ordered simonis 760 cloth for a late 1800’s to early 1900’s Rossato Barry 4.5’ X 9’ pool table with return pockes.
Asked for:
Simonis 760, new cushions, redo some of the leather on the pocket irons, new leather gully boots new fringe, new pocket liners. Asked to have the slates installed and leveled on a restored base box sitting rather level. Asked for the rail cushions to be high enough so that rail shots rode on the cloth and not the wood rail. Also had him reline the ball return box with felt. Delivered the rails to his shop with pocket months before the install. requested tight pockets.

He came over replaced the slate and leveled them and installed the cloth on rails then table and bolted up the rails. He said the table looked like it has only benn recovered 2 or maybe 3 times since new.
We paid him and he left.
The first thing we noticed were fold marks in the cloth 22”s apart all the way down the table. The cloth is tight but you can always see it almost like the fibers were disturbed. We also noticed a rainbow like shadows where the cloth was stretched at different angles into the pockets and down the table. We thought all of it would come out when the table was brushed a few times. It doesn’t.
I had asked for tight pockets and mentioned double shimmed. He showed up with single shimmed and I said I don’t need double shimmed as long as they are tight or average for good players. They are 5” corners and 5.5” sides which feel like buckets to me.
I asked that the cushions be high enough that the cue rides on the cloth during rail shots and breaks. He said he could not raise the cushion to do it but would handle it with a bigger or higher feather strip. The cue rides on the wood all around the table.
We can also see the pull marks all down the under side of the rails where the staples are pulling the cloth.
I happen to love rail shots and found that I can’t hold a ball to the rail down one side of the table. When I run my fingers down the slate where the ball runs down the rail I can feel the cloth off the surface where the plugs were not sanded and can feel a divot in the slate when I slide the cue ball down that rail. You can hear it when you do it fast. When we put a 4’ level on the cushion across the side pocket there is a gap on one side of the pocket when held as a strait edge to the other cushion.

We have tried to live with this for two weeks now and want someone else if not him to do it right. I visited Tacony Billiards (a local hall) to pick up some stuff and visit a friend and found the hall tables covered beautifully. In fact the local bar table looks and plays better than this.
I have pictures if helpful.

What should I have expected?

Is there someone of Real King Cobra's caliber in the Philadelphia area.
 
A little long...sorry.
Ordered simonis 760 cloth for a late 1800’s to early 1900’s Rossato Barry 4.5’ X 9’ pool table with return pockes.
Asked for:
Simonis 760, new cushions, redo some of the leather on the pocket irons, new leather gully boots new fringe, new pocket liners. Asked to have the slates installed and leveled on a restored base box sitting rather level. Asked for the rail cushions to be high enough so that rail shots rode on the cloth and not the wood rail. Also had him reline the ball return box with felt. Delivered the rails to his shop with pocket months before the install. requested tight pockets.

He came over replaced the slate and leveled them and installed the cloth on rails then table and bolted up the rails. He said the table looked like it has only benn recovered 2 or maybe 3 times since new.
We paid him and he left.
The first thing we noticed were fold marks in the cloth 22”s apart all the way down the table. The cloth is tight but you can always see it almost like the fibers were disturbed. We also noticed a rainbow like shadows where the cloth was stretched at different angles into the pockets and down the table. We thought all of it would come out when the table was brushed a few times. It doesn’t.
I had asked for tight pockets and mentioned double shimmed. He showed up with single shimmed and I said I don’t need double shimmed as long as they are tight or average for good players. They are 5” corners and 5.5” sides which feel like buckets to me.
I asked that the cushions be high enough that the cue rides on the cloth during rail shots and breaks. He said he could not raise the cushion to do it but would handle it with a bigger or higher feather strip. The cue rides on the wood all around the table.
We can also see the pull marks all down the under side of the rails where the staples are pulling the cloth.
I happen to love rail shots and found that I can’t hold a ball to the rail down one side of the table. When I run my fingers down the slate where the ball runs down the rail I can feel the cloth off the surface where the plugs were not sanded and can feel a divot in the slate when I slide the cue ball down that rail. You can hear it when you do it fast. When we put a 4’ level on the cushion across the side pocket there is a gap on one side of the pocket when held as a strait edge to the other cushion.

We have tried to live with this for two weeks now and want someone else if not him to do it right. I visited Tacony Billiards (a local hall) to pick up some stuff and visit a friend and found the hall tables covered beautifully. In fact the local bar table looks and plays better than this.
I have pictures if helpful.

What should I have expected?

Is there someone of Real King Cobra's caliber in the Philadelphia area.

Tacony Tables are done by A Level Above- Bob DeTurk & Lou Gagliano.
http://pooltableinstalls.com/ They do excellent work.
Bob DeTurk 610-812-4023
Lou Gagliano 215-380-5750
 
Is what I got reasonable?

If your not happy it is not reasonable> Though keep in mind it is a hundred year old table and will never play like a Gold Crown or even a Gandy for that matter. The t-rail bolting systems play different. And the slates are not ground like the slates are today. Most antiques you can feel the hills and valleys. As for feeling the screw holes and t-nuts in the playfield ,I would hope your mechanic would remedy that problem. Call Bob or Lou if you can't get satisfaction from your other mechanic. I am sure you will be happy with their work.
 
Sounds like he did not give you what you asked for. So you are not being unreasonable. If i have a customer that ask for something that I cannot do or is not possible then I tell the customer why.
 
you should find someone that specializes in Antique pool tables. Personally I usually turn down this type of work because I know I'm not the best person for the job.
 
Thanks for your relpies and advice.

I had a pool table mechanic come over to review the table and give me pricing to do it right. He seemed reasonable and it was good to talk to someone that didn't make it feel like he was doing me a favor to discuss it or do it. He also treated his partner/helper like a human.
Tight pockets no problem, they will make them somewhere close to 4.5" corners and 5" sides.
Cloth even with the top of the rails, no problem, solved with feather strip.
Strait rails across the side pockets, no problem can handle it with a series of shims. only needed no one rail. This brings a strait edge.
Remove the carpet backing gray felt he hot glued into the ball return box and replace with the correct green felt. No problem I ordered from that Classic billiards and will replace it.
Fold lines still in Simonis cloth on bed of table. We are first going to try to scrub with combo of Woolite and water. If that doesn't work...new cloth.
Tiger stripes (as described by Ivan at Simonis) from improper stretching around pockets. Will try to re stretch existing cloth if fold marks come out and will stretch it properly if new cloth is used.
Either way we plan to have a new cloth on hand during the process.
Thanks Again
Burt

 

Attachments

  • PICT0041.jpg
    PICT0041.jpg
    92.3 KB · Views: 400
Back
Top