What Was 2015 Match of the Year?

sjm

Older and Wiser
Silver Member
Happy new year to all.

OK, 2015 is in the books, and like most others years, there were some great matches. Here are the nominees for Match of the Year for this pool fan. The nominees are, of course, limited to matches I saw live or on stream.

Match of the Year Candidates


Match1. Ko Pin Yi vs Shane Van Boening, World 9-ball Championship Final
As a pool fan, there are so many years where I feel it was a shame that the most elite players didn’t seem to draw each other in the biggest spots. In 2015, however, I had no such regrets. Possibly the two biggest names in rotation pool and two great rivals reached the World 9-ball Championship final. The matchup was a dream come true for any serious pool fan. Ko Pin Yi was victorious, but Shane won his first ever silver medal in an overseas WPA event and backed it up by winning bronze at the All-Japan Championships. Yes, 2015 was the year that SVB found his game in WPA events. This rivalry is special, and I know we’ll see these two champions meeting in another big spot soon.

Match 2. Alex Pagulayan beats Shane Van Boening at Derby City 9-ball
Customarily, I’m not keen on nominating a one-sided match for Match of the Year, but the buildup to this match was most unusual, the situation quite remarkable. After double dipping Mike Dechaine in the Derby City one pocket final, Alex Pagulayan was the leader for the $20,000 Master of the Table bonus.

Who could forget the heartbreaking way in which Alex so narrowly lost the 2011 Master of the Table Bonus to Shane after having a big lead after the one pocket? Alex wore his pain on his sleeve on that fateful night in January 2011.

But that was then. In the 2015 Derby City nine ball, Alex had already lost to Mika Immonen, so when he drew SVB in the early rounds of the event, it was all or nothing, as a loss would have eliminated him and left him far out of contention for the bonus of $20,000. A day earlier, in the Bigfoot 10-ball, SVB had cleaned Alex’s clock by 11-2, so perhaps it wasn’t Alex’s turn.

Then, however, something magical happened. Alex threw an absolute masterpiece at Shane, winning 9-1, and rode the win all the way to the 9-ball final. Despite a loss to Warren Kiamco, Alex easily won Master of the Table, completing a week in which he won about $45,000. Well played!

Match 3. Shane Van Boening vs. Karl Boyes, Mosconi Cup Day 4
The situation was quite simple. Europe needed just one more match to win the Mosconi. Karl Boyes, second at the US Open nine ball six weeks earlier, had played brilliantly all week at the Mosconi and Shane would have to beat him. The match reached double hill. Shane owned the break in a rack that would either extend or end the Mosconi. The tension was measured but perceptible. Shane broke wet, but was snookered from the one. Shane took his time and surely considered a push out. Ultimately, though, he opted to try a difficult jump shot and nailed it, setting up a run out that sent the American fans into frenzy.

Match 4. Dennis Orcullo vs. Jayson Shaw in the Final at Super Billiards Expo
Jayson Shaw looked unstoppable, beating anyone and everyone to reach the final day, along with Orcullo, SVB, and Dechaine. His win over his Joss Tour rival Mike Dechaine in the quarterfinal earned him a shot at Van Boening, and his win over Shane put him up against Dennis Orcullo, who owned the hot seat. The match was a dandy, and despite Dennis’ fine play, Shaw kept on coming in the race to 13. It got all the way to 12-12, and Shaw looked like he’d prevail, but went wrong four balls from the finish line and Dennis won a 13-12 thriller. What a match!

What, then, was the Match of the Year?

My choice is Ko Pin Yi vs. SVB in the final of the World 9-Ball Championship. Two superstars battling for the biggest title in pool is as good as it gets. What do you think was the match of the year in 2015? Was it one of these? Nominate your own if you like.
 
Last edited:
Personally, I loved the ahead One Pocket match between Alex and Scott Frost from this year. Tons of great pool. A war of attrition in which Alex emerged as the current one pocket money champion.
 
Personally, I loved the ahead One Pocket match between Alex and Scott Frost from this year. Tons of great pool. A war of attrition in which Alex emerged as the current one pocket money champion.

I didn't see that match, but thanks for bringing it to our attention.
 
Personally, I loved the ahead One Pocket match between Alex and Scott Frost from this year. Tons of great pool. A war of attrition in which Alex emerged as the current one pocket money champion.

+1, five days of great one pocket
 
1) Make it Happen One-Pocket Semifinal - Efren vs. Danny Smith. Billy Incardona called it "The greatest one pocket match I have ever witnessed."

2) SJM's aforementioned Expo Final Jayson v. Dennis. Jayson's difficult cut on the 7 ball in the side pocket was one of the most devestating misses I have ever witnessed.

3) World 9-ball final. Second huge Ko/Shane epic that set the forums ablaze for weeks.

4) SVB/Mike Dechaine match at Snooker's. Riveting hill-hill safety battle which saw Mike narrowly escape while defending his home turf.

5) Ko Pin Yi vs. Kenichi Uchigaki TV match at the U.S. Open. On the one loss side, Ko shot a .950 and lost hill-hill! Brilliant and timely play from Japan's Uchigaki.

U.S. Open honorable mentions:

1st -Jayson Shaw vs. Karen Corr. Another hill-hill thriller on the winner's side, two matches before the hotseat. Karen attempts a thin safety on the 3 ball and scratches, giving Jayson an open table to run out for the win(not televised).

2nd-Justin Bergman vs. Kevin Cheng. Bergman had just defeated Shane on the winner's side, all but crippling his chances at winning an unprecedented 4th consecutive Open. With a full head of steam, this was Berg's coming out party and he had emerged as a huge favorite to win the whole tournament. Cheng would battle him to a 10-10 tie and ran out the last rack, backcutting two insane balls and nearly scratching in the side pocket after making the 8 ball. Shooting off the rail he cut in a tricky 9 ball to go on to the hotseat match(also not televised).

3rd-Cheng/Boyes semifinal. Boyes had upset Shaw to earn a shot at the hotseat, and playing with the utmost confidence, he kept pace with Cheng to tie the match at 5 apiece. Cheng would then erupt and unleash a 5-pack (with the 9 ball being racked on the spot!) on Boyes before breaking dry on the hill. Boyes succumbed but would return to rematch Cheng in the finals.

**One last match for the road**
Shaw put one of the all-time beatdowns on Mika Immonen in the semis at the last Turning Stone. He beat him 11-1 in about 22 minutes flat, including the time it took Mika to rack for him. Momma said there would be days like this.
 
Last edited:
1) Make it Happen One-Pocket Semifinal - Efren vs. Danny Smith. Billy Incardona called it "The greatest one pocket match I have ever witnessed."

2) SJM's aforementioned Expo Final Jayson v. Dennis. Jayson's difficult cut on the 7 ball in the side pocket was one of the most devestating misses I have ever witnessed.

3) World 9-ball final. Second huge Ko/Shane epic that set the forums ablaze for weeks.

4) SVB/Mike Dechaine match at Snooker's. Riveting hill-hill safety battle which saw Mike narrowly escape while defending his home turf.

5) Ko Pin Yi vs. Kenichi Uchigaki TV match at the U.S. Open. On the one loss side, Ko shot a .950 and lost hill-hill! Brilliant and timely play from Japan's Uchigaki.

U.S. Open honorable mentions:

1st -Jayson Shaw vs. Karen Corr. Another hill-hill thriller on the winner's side, two matches before the hotseat. Karen attempts a thin safety on the 3 ball and scratches, giving Jayson an open table to run out for the win(not televised).

2nd-Justin Bergman vs. Kevin Cheng. Bergman had just defeated Shane on the winner's side, all but crippling his chances at winning an unprecedented 4th consecutive Open. With a full head of steam, this was Berg's coming out party and he had emerged as a huge favorite to win the whole tournament. Cheng would battle him to a 10-10 tie and ran out the last rack, backcutting two insane balls and nearly scratching in the side pocket after making the 8 ball. Shooting off the rail he cut in a tricky 9 ball to go on to the hotseat match(also not televised).

3rd-Cheng/Boyes semifinal. Boyes had upset Shaw to earn a shot at the hotseat, and playing with the utmost confidence, he kept pace with Cheng to tie the match at 5 apiece. Cheng would then erupt and unleash a 5-pack (with the 9 ball being racked on the spot!) on Boyes before breaking dry on the hill. Boyes succumbed but would return to rematch Cheng in the finals.

**One last mach for the road**
Shaw put one of the all-time beatdowns on Mika Immonen in the semis at the last Turning Stone. He beat him 11-1 in about 22 minutes flat, including the time it took Mika to rack for him. Momma said there would be days like this.

Good choices, but a few corrections are needed. For the US Open 9-Ball Championship:

• Ko shot .953 in losing to Uchigaki's .891.

• Shaw's hill/hill win over Corr was in the winners' round of 32, 4 rounds (not 2) from the hot seat.

• The Cheng/Boyes hotseat match was never tied 5-5, in fact it ended at 11-4. Cheng ran out Game 9 after Boyes' dry break, and then had a 4-pack (not 5) to take the score to 10-3. Cheng then broke dry and Boyes ran out to get it to 10-4. Boyes had an illegal break in the final game, and Cheng ran out (with a 3/9 combo) for the 11-4 win.

And for the Shaw "beatdown" on Immonen at Turning Stone, it was at TS XXIII last January rather than the most recent TS event, and the score was 9-1 (still super speedy).
 
Last edited:
^^^ Thanks for the clarifications. I made an extemporaneous list in haste, and some of the minor details were hazy.
 
1) Make it Happen One-Pocket Semifinal - Efren vs. Danny Smith. Billy Incardona called it "The greatest one pocket match I have ever witnessed."

Yeah, I caught that one. That was fantastic. Nice call.
 
Hooo-weeee

Good choices, but a few corrections are needed. For the US Open 9-Ball Championship:

• Ko shot .953 in losing to Uchigaki's .891.

• Shaw's hill/hill win over Corr was in the winners' round of 32, 4 rounds (not 2) from the hot seat.

• The Cheng/Boyes hotseat match was never tied 5-5, in fact it ended at 11-4. Cheng ran out Game 9 after Boyes' dry break, and then had a 4-pack (not 5) to take the score to 10-3. Cheng then broke dry and Boyes ran out to get it to 10-4. Boyes had an illegal break in the final game, and Cheng ran out (with a 3/9 combo) for the 11-4 win.

And for the Shaw "beatdown" on Immonen at Turning Stone, it was at TS XXIII last January rather than the most recent TS event, and the score was 9-1 (still super speedy).

Happy New Year!

I'm so glad gents like you and sjm keep track of some of the circumstances around the statistics-thank you!!

sjm - Derby-2011 and last year for Alex were absolutely outstanding- that's why I'm always happy when you and others describe the circumstances behind the wins that paint the match in an entirely different colour!

(plus it's nice because I got all the stuff leading up to those games on film)

:thumbup:
 
Happy New Year!

I'm so glad gents like you and sjm keep track of some of the circumstances around the statistics-thank you!!

sjm - Derby-2011 and last year for Alex were absolutely outstanding- that's why I'm always happy when you and others describe the circumstances behind the wins that paint the match in an entirely different colour!

(plus it's nice because I got all the stuff leading up to those games on film)

:thumbup:

Right on, my friend. Seeing Alex get over the Derby City hump this year was something we did together and, as we were both there during the 2011 heartbreak, it completed the most improbable of stories that we experienced. Save that footage, for its one of pool's more memorable moments.
 
Happy new year to all.

Match1. Ko Pin Yi vs Shane Van Boening, World 9-ball Championship Final
As a pool fan, there are so many years where I feel it was a shame that the most elite players didn’t seem to draw each other in the biggest spots. In 2015, however, I had no such regrets. Possibly the two biggest names in rotation pool and two great rivals reached the World 9-ball Championship final. The matchup was a dream come true for any serious pool fan. Ko Pin Yi was victorious, but Shane won his first ever silver medal in an overseas WPA event and backed it up by winning bronze at the All-Japan Championships. Yes, 2015 was the year that SVB found his game in WPA events. This rivalry is special, and I know we’ll see these two champions meeting in another big spot soon.



My choice is Ko Pin Yi vs. SVB in the final of the World 9-Ball Championship. Two superstars battling for the biggest title in pool is as good as it gets. What do you think was the match of the year in 2015? Was it one of these? Nominate your own if you like.


Happy New Year's to you, Stu.
I'm voting with you on Ko vs Shane in WPA finals.
The drama and pressure on the line for both players was insurmountable by human standards, and these two professionals performed brilliantly.

It was an amazing treat and an unforgettable edge-of-your-seat match.
 
Happy New Year's to you, Stu.
I'm voting with you on Ko vs Shane in WPA finals.
The drama and pressure on the line for both players was insurmountable by human standards, and these two professionals performed brilliantly.

It was an amazing treat and an unforgettable edge-of-your-seat match.

Happy new year to you as well.
 
Lots of good responses in this thread.

One of the questions that arises is the extent to which the size of the moment factors into the quality of the match.

Certainly SVB vs Ko Pin Yi was not the match that Ko Pin Yi vs Wu Jiaqing was at the World 9-ball Championships, but the stakes were higher with the title hanging in the balance.

Alex vs SVB at the Derby City 9-ball was not even a good match, but the circumstances made it huge and truly memorable. The semifinal between Sossei and Kiamco was a much better match, but the moment was smaller.

It has gotten me thinking. The best matches are only sometimes the most memorable and the circumstances of a match figure significantly in its potential for greatness.

Let's see what 2016 brings. The Derby is just three weeks away. Are you ready?
 
Lots of good responses in this thread.

One of the questions that arises is the extent to which the size of the moment factors into the quality of the match.

Certainly SVB vs Ko Pin Yi was not the match that Ko Pin Yi vs Wu Jiaqing was at the World 9-ball Championships, but the stakes were higher with the title hanging in the balance.

Alex vs SVB at the Derby City 9-ball was not even a good match, but the circumstances made it huge and truly memorable. The semifinal between Sossei and Kiamco was a much better match, but the moment was smaller.

It has gotten me thinking. The best matches are only sometimes the most memorable and the circumstances of a match figure significantly in its potential for greatness.

Let's see what 2016 brings. The Derby is just three weeks away. Are you ready?

Yes, sir. Size of the moment always increases the memorable factor in my eyes.
Different circumstances create huge special moments out of mundane situations. A break and run by these players can be like hitting two free throws in an NBA regular season game OR hitting 2 free throws while the opposite coach is calling time outs to freeze you in overtime of the NBA finals.

Both (foul shots or break and runs) have the same result, approached, executed and played the same way....But under different circumstances, the second set is elevated in it's greatness.

Maybe Ko vs Shane didn't have the most technically proficient pool, but the stage was higher which adds top the equation IMO.
 
Yes, sir. Size of the moment always increases the memorable factor in my eyes.
Different circumstances create huge special moments out of mundane situations. A break and run by these players can be like hitting two free throws in an NBA regular season game OR hitting 2 free throws while the opposite coach is calling time outs to freeze you in overtime of the NBA finals.

Both (foul shots or break and runs) have the same result, approached, executed and played the same way....But under different circumstances, the second set is elevated in it's greatness.

Maybe Ko vs Shane didn't have the most technically proficient pool, but the stage was higher which adds top the equation IMO.

As you can see, though, others feel differently and look at play quality in a vacuum. Perhaps that's the right way. Definitely a matter of opinion.
 
Back
Top